• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Strange New Worlds General Discussion Thread

Anyone have thoughts on why the showrunners decided to put Sam Kirk in this show? Was it all just for the fake out in the pilot episode (which was kind of spoiled by the leak/announcement that James would be appearing in season 2).

They don't seem to have any focus for him in season 1. He could have just been any old Lieutenant. Outside of Sam giving some info on James in "A Quality of Mercy", he doesn't do anything that needs him to be Kirk. And even then, they could have had any of the other non-Spock/non-Uhura characters serve with Kirk on an earlier ship to give the same "briefing" to Pike. And wouldn't you think that James's brother is going to give you a less-objective readout than practically anyone else - for good or for bad?

I guess it was just all for that one gag in episode 1...

Mostly for the gag but also maybe a signal to the audience that Captain Kirk will come on the show at some point.
 
My guess is the character is there specifically for his the Jim Kirk episode next season. It does open up the question of why introduce him so early if you're doing that but it does feel much more natural to have him there since the start than having him introduced right before Jim appears.

And hey his appearences so far have been good so I have no issue there.
 

Those are great. But the highlights of the for me are the other shows down at the bottom. Like this one has Riker2Riker. I’ve seen “Everyone Loves Martok”, “The Cardassian” about Garak, “The O Team” featuring Miles, Julian, Worf and Barclay.
So funny.
OMG! Where can I find these?

Indeed. One of my favorite shows of all time and Colonel Potter's quotes are among my favorites. The "queasy gizzard" was a straight quote from the episode "Back Pay." Also features one of my favorite lines from Potter in regards to Hawkeye and Winchester: "Well, in case Hawkeye does go loco I'll make sure Winchester's back is on the mend. At least it's just his spine that's twisted not his brain."
It'd be fun to watch you guys play M*A*S*H trivia with my hubby, who's also a huge fan. I'm curious how well the eps hold up though.
 
The earlier episodes are more funny. The Henry/Trapper loss to Potter/Honeycutt marked the first shift in tone of the show to something with some greater depth. Then when Burns left and was replaced with Winchester, the show completed its final move into the more dramatic era. It was more a show about Viet Nam than Korea.

More recently, there was a show on the Paramount channel (regular cable, not P+) called “68 Whiskey” that tried to be a modern take on MASH. The acting was a bit uneven, but it had the spark of something quite interesting before it was cancelled after only 1 season.
 
It'd be fun to watch you guys play M*A*S*H trivia with my hubby, who's also a huge fan. I'm curious how well the eps hold up though.
I love MASH and my wife and I watch it most evenings. We enjoy the simple episodes and find them to be a good way to unwind.

As far as episodes holding up for me it depends on the episode. Early Hawkeye was far more of a prankster, an even a prop comic at times, using a Sherlock outfit, and Gorilla costumes with Trapper.

As the show continued on you definitely see the more dramatic side, with the comedy, and how different perspectives on the war could come about. Hawkeye, while not infallible, definitely became more fallible as the seasons wore on. Which, in my opinion, is to the show's credit because you can see some character growth despite the episodic format.

More amusing is trying to keep track of individual's referring to family members from season to season.
The earlier episodes are more funny.
I agree and they definitely had a bit of a slapstick edge while later ones utilized more in situation comedy. It definitely takes on a different flavor.
 
I've enjoyed the ten episodes of Season 1... but it's been a mixed bag still. Several very good episodes, a couple of disappointing ones, the rest is good... but still I can't quite get excited by it, despite liking all the characters and the excellent design work done on the show. Don't know why yet. So far, it's not a BluRay purchase for me.

On the flip side I received my copy of Lower Decks S2 yesterday. :)
 
I have to say on the whole I really enjoyed the entire season. Yeah im a visual continuty freak but a good story is a good story. Things I enjoyed the most. The Spock/Chapel interactions. Not sure how theyll explain in canon but its possible as Spock got more control over his emotions he started to focus on career only and left tpring hanging one time too mamy and started to move away from chapels friendship or they were still friends but we didnt see it. Not sure but im still enjoying it. I really like pike he isnt perfect but no captain is. I enjly his cooking for the bridge crew abd that he still loves antique tvs like the tube tv he had in the cage and the plasma he had in his home on earth. Nice call back to his love of old tech. We need to see more erica. Also Hemmer died too soon. I wish he would have gotten his own ep before they offed him. Really nice to get 1 hour stories. Real nice.
 
This does add context to Spock and Chapel having their moment in "The Naked Time(TOS)." Psi 2000 virus infections or not, Christine knows he's still betrothed to T'Pring and thus still unreachable, whatever flings he'd had in the recent past notwithstanding.
 
OK, I have canceled my Paramount+ subscription. I am not really interested in the cartoons. I will be back when one of the live action shows (SNW/Discovery/Picard) is back.
 
Lower Decks is bloody amazing though. You're really missing out, it isn't a kids show.
I have seen the first 2 seasons of LD and I am not a big fan. It is entertaining but the pace is too hectic, the characters speak too loud and too fast (probably normal for comedy cartoons) and the main character is way too annoying. Once I sign up again I will catch up, but I am not going to subscribe just for Lower Decks or Prodigy.
 
This does add context to Spock and Chapel having their moment in "The Naked Time(TOS)." Psi 2000 virus infections or not, Christine knows he's still betrothed to T'Pring and thus still unreachable, whatever flings he'd had in the recent past notwithstanding.

Good point. I wouldnt be disappointed if we get a older chapel and spock circa 2292 and find that Chapel becomes Spocks first wife. So a few years from now we can get a update of sorts.
 
Last edited:
I have seen the first 2 seasons of LD and I am not a big fan. It is entertaining but the pace is too hectic, the characters speak too loud and too fast (probably normal for comedy cartoons) and the main character is way too annoying. Once I sign up again I will catch up, but I am not going to subscribe just for Lower Decks or Prodigy.
That's ok. I've cancelled my Crave.tv subscription as well. I'll wait next year to catch up with everything.
 
So I will say this about the first season, I enjoyed every episode. There wasn't a single bad episode where I'm like "oh that one sucked." My favorite episode so far has to be Spock Amok because Body swapping Hijinks can you say more? I did love that not one episode got below 43 minutes in terms of Run time. Most of them were 50+ which I loved especially after getting BONED hard by Disney+ and their run times. Can't wait for Season 2.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top