Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 2x03 - "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow"

[Mudd]

I actually think it is an alternate timeline,

How Fiction Works: the writers have revised continuity.

Talking about "timelines" is just a sop for ntpickers.

 

[Kraig]

The Department of Temporal Investigations should at least perform some kind of counseling for those who provide them with assistance in protecting the time line, before returning them to their own time.

The big question I have, is will La'an give the watch she got in Vermont back to Pelia?

 

[Mudd]

A fun episode but I am honestly tired of all the fucking time travel episodes. This is a well they've been going to once too often IMO. It seems like they do a time travel episode in any Trek series when they run out of ideas.

They did two in the first year of TOS, both quite good.

Time travel has been a big part of Trek since its beginnings.

 

[Aragorn]

Is there a good place to get Poutine Fries with Gravy in the US?

There are plenty of places to get poutine. My Canadian friends, however, think Americans mess around with it to the point where it shouldn't even be called poutine. For example, Claim Jumper:

 

[NCC-73515]

Thank you for a good faith, constructive, non snarky reply. Wonder how Memory Alpha will treat it...

I'm glad they did it, now they're 'free' to do what they want without contradicting the past anymore
And I'm also one of those on the continuum who want things to fit and make sense whenever possible - just ignore the snarky changelings

 

[ToddCam]

It could be argued that it's always an alternate timeline after time travel occurs.

Anyway, this is like the UNIT dating controversy. Was Khan around in the 1990s? Yes. Was he around in the 2020s? Yes. How? Timey-wimey shenanigans.

 

[bookworm8571]

How Fiction Works: the writers have revised continuity.

Talking about "timelines" is just a sop for ntpickers.

Of course it’s all fiction and whatever the writers decide they want to do. I watch it as a timeline that has been slightly altered after being reset on multiple occasions on the various shows and there are multiple other timelines in which things turned out differently and change is still possible in this one.. For instance, I would personally prefer a timeline where Pike gets to live and avoid that accident and assorted other changes.

 

[Kamen Rider Blade]

...and she says she had to wait 30 years. That suggests TOS/WOK Khan and EW happened in a previous timeline in 1992-96, but in this timeline where SNW takes place, it was prevented in the 90s and happened decades later. Like Judgment Day in the Terminator movies moving forward a few years but still happening whenever they thought they'd stopped it

More Proof of the 3rd Timeline

Spoiler: Anti-Trekker - Star Trek; The Triple Timeline Theory Redux

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

Here's the 3x Time-Line Theory postulated by Anti-Trekker AKA Salty-Trekker.

Spoiler: Here are the 3x Major Time-Lines

Instead of the current 2x Time-Line theory that exists, I postulate that 3x Time-Lines exist and that's what accounts for all the contradictions that we see and make sense of it all.

 

[Guy Gardener]

Nope, and who cares?

Adelaide Kane said that she had been trapped on Earth for three decades and that "this" was supposed to have happened in 1993.

That means that she is important, and that we should see her again, but younger.

It's Adelaide Kane for $ucks sake, you don't waste Adelaide Kane when you have her under contract... Well, she was seriously underused on Teen Wolf, but that's neither here nor there.

90s Eugenics war leads to TOS.

2020s Eugenics War leads to Discovery.

I was very concerned for a moment because I thought Adelaide Kane was cast as Edith Keeler and that would have over egged the pudding, but there's nothing to stop Adelaide Kane from playing an Edith Keeler Romulan time spy assassin later... And that's why McCoy really had to kill her.

 

[Kamen Rider Blade]

There are plenty of places to get poutine. My Canadian friends, however, think Americans mess around with it to the point where it shouldn't even be called poutine. For example, Claim Jumper:

That doesn't look like Canadian Poutine

 

[KennyB]

Not watching this season of SNW, but as one of those annoying canon/continuity people gotta ask is it true this definitively sets up SNW as an alt timeline to TOS?

K bye

 

[Retu]

One of those things I never thought I'd see is a Rommie BoP surrounded by poutine

Lousy weather and time if you're planning to take a photo of International Space Station.

 

[NCC-73515]

I once tried to see a solar eclipse and only saw clouds

But she was lying anyway, that could have just been made up on the spot.

 

[thribs]

That was a fun episode but the Khan thing was confusing. He would be long gone at that time.
So there is still an issue in the timeline. Some attack that shouldn’t have happened that delayed the eugenics wars. Perhaps them correcting that one later on finally fixes everything.

 

[NCC-73515]

That was a fun episode but the Khan thing was confusing. He would be long gone at that time.
So there is still an issue in the timeline. Some attack that shouldn’t have happened that delayed the eugenics wars. Perhaps them correcting that one later on finally fixes everything.

see above, the rommie said so

 

[Agony_Boothb]

Thank you for a good faith, constructive, non snarky reply. Wonder how Memory Alpha will treat it...

Voyager already contradicted the Eugenics Wars happening in 90's. In 'Future's End' they go back to LA 1996 which is all sunny and full of people rollerblading and not one of the Voyager crew are like 'where's khan and why isn't LA blown up' and Janeway is all 'LA became a coral reef because of the big one in 2047 lol'.

 

[Guy Gardener]

I once tried to see a solar eclipse and only saw clouds

But she was lying anyway, that could have just been made up on the spot.

Its possible that she created the legend we saw, based on the tinfoil hat wearing weirdo she killed to get that picture, or its y'know photoshop.

 

[Charles Phipps]

I actually think it is an alternate timeline, How can it not be with all the tampering they’ve done in the various Star Trek series? Here and there little things are changed unnoticed and all those little things start to add up. Kirk is born on U.S.S. Iowa or in Riverside, Iowa. Kirk’s brother is called George by everyone in one timeline and Sam by everyone in another. In the original series, they had to look up the data on Khan Noonien-Singh and his place in the Eugenics Wars. In this one, Khan Noonien-Singh is as notorious a figure of evil as Adolf Hitler and his descendant is the security chief of the Enterprise, her history and that of her ancestor known well to Spock and Uhura because she was their crewmate and comrade. La’an is off the ship by that point and who knows what happens to her but there is no way they would forget everything they knew about Khan. It’s not the same as the original series but it’s better written and more entertaining this way. I’m happy to watch and be entertained.

It's canon so its the main timeline. Don't sweat the details.

 

[thribs]

see above, the rommie said so

It does sort if imply that Discovery and SNW are indeed another timeline from the Prime. Maybe DiscoVerse is actually a thing.

 

[Guy Gardener]

Voyager already contradicted the Eugenics Wars happening in 90's. In 'Future's End' they go back to LA 1996 which is all sunny and full of people rollerblading and not one of the Voyager crew are like 'where's khan and why isn't LA blown up' and Janeway is all 'LA became a coral reef because of the big one in 2047 lol'.

We said that at the time.

15 years later there was no evidence on the home front, irl, anywhere that America was bombing Iraq.