Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 2x03 - "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow"

[Paul Weaver]

Lucsly: "Seventeen separate temporal violations; the biggest file on record."

Dulmer: "The man was a menace."

Janeway: hold my beer

 

[The Salt Umpire]

Lucsly: "Seventeen separate temporal violations; the biggest file on record."

Dulmer: "The man was a menace."

Beat me to it, Turtle. Has anyone listed all 17?

 

[Zombie Cheerleader]

Beat me to it, Turtle. Has anyone listed all 17?

Most are unknown so kind of hard to list.

 

[Guy Gardener]

If you went through the novels and comics too, it's probably way more than 17.

Maybe because of what happened in this episode, he's figured out that he's not supposed to report problems with time to the authorities, if he can't exactly trust his superiors not to run with the ball.

 

[fireproof78]

Kirk traveled to the past at least four times: "City on the Edge of Forever", "Tomorrow is Yesterday", "Assignment Earth" and "All Our Yesterdays". Five if you count "Yesteryear". Also three days in the past in "The Naked Time" All before Star Trek 4.

One of those was on purpose.

 

[GhoulEddie74]

Well, two. Kirk and Spock HAD to use the Guardian to follow McCoy back to 1930 Earth. That was a preplanned event for both officers and not some random accident while studying the Guardian.

 

[Kraig]

Kirk traveled to the past at least four times: "City on the Edge of Forever", "Tomorrow is Yesterday", "Assignment Earth" and "All Our Yesterdays". Five if you count "Yesteryear". Also three days in the past in "The Naked Time" All before Star Trek 4.

Lucsly: "Seventeen separate temporal violations; the biggest file on record."

Dulmer: "The man was a menace."

Beat me to it, Turtle. Has anyone listed all 17?

This is just speculation on my part. First, you would have to know what constitutes a temporal violation. Each episode with a trip back in time may lead to multiple temporal violations per trip. In Tomorrow is Yesterday, they were picked up on radar by SAC, the Enterprise was recorded by the F104 gun camera, they then crushed an F104 with a tractor beam, beamed the pilot aboard the Enterprise and showed him around, then returned to the base to get the F104 camera footage. Kirk was taken into custody, with a phaser and communicator in his possession, and interrogated by SAC security. They beamed a SAC security SGT aboard, left him in the transporter room to observe its use, then travelled back to a time before the Enterprise arrived and beamed the two US Air force personnel back to their bodies. Some or most of those events in just that one episode in a trip to the past might be considered to be a violation.

Most are unknown so kind of hard to list.

Exactly this. Until you know what constitutes a temporal violation, you aren't going to know where each of them occurred, or whether they mean one trip to the past counts as only one temporal violation.

A current day example, you get pulled over by a cop for speeding, the cop discovers you aren't wearing a seat belt, your driver license has expired, then he smells alcohol on your breath, and thinks you might have been driving impaired. One incident can lead to multiple violations.

 

[Zombie Cheerleader]

If you went through the novels and comics too, it's probably way more than 17.

Maybe because of what happened in this episode, he's figured out that he's not supposed to report problems with time to the authorities, if he can't exactly trust his superiors not to run with the ball.

That Kirk is dead and never existed (in that order.)

 

[The Salt Umpire]

This is just speculation on my part. First, you would have to know what constitutes a temporal violation. Each episode with a trip back in time may lead to multiple temporal violations per trip. In Tomorrow is Yesterday, they were picked up on radar by SAC, the Enterprise was recorded by the F104 gun camera, they then crushed an F104 with a tractor beam, beamed the pilot aboard the Enterprise and showed him around, then returned to the base to get the F104 camera footage. Kirk was taken into custody, with a phaser and communicator in his possession, and interrogated by SAC security. They beamed a SAC security SGT aboard, left him in the transporter room to observe its use, then travelled back to a time before the Enterprise arrived and beamed the two US Air force personnel back to their bodies. Some or most of those events in just that one episode in a trip to the past might be considered to be a violation.

Exactly this. Until you know what constitutes a temporal violation, you aren't going to know where each of them occurred, or whether they mean one trip to the past counts as only one temporal violation.

A current day example, you get pulled over by a cop for speeding, the cop discovers you aren't wearing a seat belt, your driver license has expired, then he smells alcohol on your breath, and thinks you might have been driving impaired. One incident can lead to multiple violations.

Found on Reddit:

• Violation 1: The Naked Time: Enterprise travels downtime 3 days.
• Violation 2: Tomorrow is Yesterday:

Violation 2A: travels downtime to 1969

Violation 2B: travels downtime a day while in 1969

• Violation 3: The City on the Edge of Forever: Travels downtime to 1930
• Violation 4: Assignment: Earth: Travels downtime to 1968. (Operation authorized by Starfleet so not a violation; activities regarding Agent Gary 7 could be considered violation 4).
• Violation 5 and 6: All Our Yesterdays: Kirk travels downtime time twice on the planet Sarpeidon.
• Violation Nil: Yesteryear: Kirk travels to downtime to distant past of planet Orion (authorized by Starfleet, not a violation)
• Violation 8: Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home:

Violation 8A: Travels downtime to 1986, captured Bird of Prey is detected in space by natives of time period

Violation 8B: Holds hostage and threatens with phaser several medical personnel native to time period

Violation 8C: Pawns glasses from 2285 in to pawn broker in 1986

Violation 8D: Decloaks captured Bird of Prey in front of crew of whaling vessel in 1986

Violation 8E: Brings two humpback whales uptime to 2286

Violation 8F: Brings one Gillian Taylor uptime to 2286

• Violation 9: Star Trek Generations: Kirk travels uptime to 2371 to Veridian 3