hm, why did they cast quinto and pine and urban in those specific roles...? or anson mount XD
apparently that's because the colorizer was colorblind
so they could've kept the original shape, which is the point here. who do you think is trying to fool anyone, and why?
What made you think anyone here was talking about the shape of the ship?
No, actually, they are following through with what Trek has always done: recast. It has nothing to do with apathy or lack of trying. Trek has always updated the look, and actors, as it demands it. It isn't Star Wars, Bond, or any other TV show that insists on keeping a certain look beyond the basics of colored uniforms, phasers, starships, transporters and tricorders. Everything else, everything, is set dressing.
Welcome to fandom.
Because they auditioned and they liked them?
Though another editor on the show who knows him has said they don't think that was the reason why.
Well, that would be ridiculous!!
Best people for the jobs who gave the best performances. Also didn't cost an arm and a leg to the production.hm, why did they cast quinto and pine and urban in those specific roles...? or anson mount XD
Harsh but fair.
Do they also have a problem with the slightly different uniforms, sets, props, etc.? Or is it just the precise dimensions and shapes of the Enterprise parts?
So you're saying they're realistic humans.
Says someone who clearly hasn't watched them, there is nothing like that in them.
Despite seeing it for years now this hyper levels of nitpicking details amaze me still.
They just justify it by saying that it takes place after TOS.
I was speaking about the response at the time. But, it also amazes me what is the limit for rationalizing away.
Not well, I suspect. However, it's my favourite starship design, and my second favourite Trek movie.
CNN also has used FAN FILM footage, and referenced it as Paramount Star Trek footage in a story talking about Paramount's plan for Star trek (and that's happened more than once.) There are plenty of causal entertainment reporters who don't research there references in their stories very well.CNN published a review of the season premiere of Strange New Worlds and called it a "reboot".
Interesting that this is what the reviewer thought of it.
They have since changed the title.
Akiva Goldsman doesn't know Kirk and Star Trek.
It's realistic, but only if they're not trained military officers. It does bother me a bit in DSC because they don't really act like professionals. Not a huge problem.
look at the commonly stated criticism of the discoprise and find out that it's mostly about pylons, secondary hull shape, and compressed neck. find posts that don't criticize those parts, but hull texture instead. one is the vast majority, the other is not.
what exactly is wrong about the fact that the refit, which is explicitly mentioned and part of the story, happens after TOS?
Ah, so that's why Urban doesn't play Kirk, Pine doesn't play Spock, and Quinto doesn't play Scotty? Good to know!
And if Pike mentions a refit?
