Rank the Trek series

[tomalak301]

Doing this again because it's been a while.

DS9 and TNG
Voyager
Enterprise
Lower Decks
Prodigy
Strange New Worlds
Star Trek
Discovery
The Animated Series
Picard (Season 2 brought this down a lot. Really disappointing, and depressing, season)

 

[ELCHawk]

How I'd currently rate the shows:

Amazing:
TNG
DS9

Great:
TOS
LD
SNW

Good:
VOY
ENT

Meh:
TAS
PIC

Bad:
Prodigy

Terrible:
DSC

If Picard Season 3 ends up actually being good it might raise itself a level (but still be held down by a mixed Season 1 and a terrible Season 2). The rest of these are pretty much set, although its possible that SNW could take a downturn (I hope it doesn't, obviously, but its a possibility).

I would really disagree with you on Prodigy. Season 1 was very very good. Discovery is also not terrible. It is not the best Trek, but it is very good.

 

[kirk55555]

I would really disagree with you on Prodigy. Season 1 was very very good. Discovery is also not terrible. It is not the best Trek, but it is very good.

Well we're all going to have are own lists. I tried to watch Prodigy and really couldn't stand it, it is definitely a kids show made for kids. Discovery I just think is rancid, its a one person show with the worst character on the main cast of a Trek series. Half of ever episode past season 2 is just people softly talking while crying, every long standing Trek alien (outside of Vulcans) are redesigned to look like garbage (they even ruined Orions, how do you ruin painting a person green?), and the actual stories are just BS. I'm not going to go on, at that point it becomes its own topic/rant, but there is no Trek show worse then it in my opinion, and I don't think its actually possible to make a worse Trek show unless someone was actually, genuinely trying to be the worst.

 

[Oddish]

It's fine. This is all opinions anyway.

 

[Kor]

1. TOS

...and the rest.

Kor