• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Agents of SHIELD. Season 1 Discussion Thread

The Battle of New York was the 9/11 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, I expect them to mention it a lot.

9/11 and Pearl Harbor combjned times 1,000, 000. And it happened inside a year ago. So it makes sense it'd constantly be mentioned.
 
9/11 and Pearl Harbor combjned times 1,000, 000. And it happened inside a year ago. So it makes sense it'd constantly be mentioned.

I think that might be stretching it a bit. We saw hardly any onscreen deaths in Avengers, and even the level of destruction seemed pretty minimal compared to most alien invasion movies we've seen.

Obviously an alien army descending from the sky is a major event, but even in that world I can't see it packing nearly as big an emotional punch as something like 9/11 or Pearl Harbor.
 
Another fine episode. I loved Coulson's confidence in his former protege. That sort of thing, and lines like, "That shouldn't have happened either," are what makes this show a breath of fresh air. The story itself was another high-octane spy thriller, reminiscent of Alias or Man From UNCLE. Before the show premiered, I was hoping we'd see some superheroes pop up, but I'll be happy for them to continue like this.

I do wonder, though, if there will be any consequences to May's unilateral efforts.

And I got a kick out of Sky ogling Ward with the X-ray specs. I can imagine what the reaction would be if the roles were reversed, given the current political climate. :rommie:
 
9/11 and Pearl Harbor combjned times 1,000, 000. And it happened inside a year ago. So it makes sense it'd constantly be mentioned.

I think that might be stretching it a bit. We saw hardly any onscreen deaths in Avengers, and even the level of destruction seemed pretty minimal compared to most alien invasion movies we've seen.

Obviously an alien army descending from the sky is a major event, but even in that world I can't see it packing nearly as big an emotional punch as something like 9/11 or Pearl Harbor.

Compare 911 to Hiroshima.

911 times a thousand isn't difficult.
 
While watching video on demand, I did the sudoku puzzle in the daily paper. Didn't miss the time out from watching, which says something about the engagement this show inspires.

The scene with Squarejaw trying to do something spy-like, namely, manipulate another human being for information, was a painful reminder of how stupid the show is in its own professed terms.

SHIELD is not a spy agency, it is a band of thugs. This dreamworld where US gorillas get to stomp people all around the world is getting offensive.

Nerd and Nerdette still have no personalities, which says to me that their whole point is to be foils to make the leads look good.

The old rule used to be that a character with an exotically cool name, like "Sky," was given that name because the character was a Mary Sue. Or, just possibly, a thinly disguised erotic ideal. This show is not rising above fan fic with this character.

Does anybody really care how they reconcile this Coulson with Coulson's death in the Avengers move? Do you realize that unless there's a bunch of people who do, the relelentless emphasis on that is boring and inept?

I don't care, but I'm not letting it get under my skin that they keep hinting about it anyway. I'm just glad Coulson is there, whatever he is, i like the show, I don't find Agent Boy and Hacker Girl morally offensive, and i can easily get through an episode without my brain exploding.
 
The Battle of New York was the 9/11 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, I expect them to mention it a lot.
Exactly what I thought when I heard it mentioned yet again. Considering what happened in that "battle", they are making as big a deal out of it as should be made.

Liked the last two episodes. This Coulson thing looks like it may be headed for something big. Perhaps his former agent knows something about Coulson's personality that Melinda and the doctor and (Cobie Smulders), don't.

The last scene with Fitz/Simmons (whichever) made me laugh out loud. Considering how anxious he was to kick Agent Squarejaw's ass, he lit out so fast it wasn't funny when he thought Skye might see him naked. Funny.

Liking the Skye/Coulson dynamic too. Jury's still out though.
 
Buildings were destroyed , it's entirely conceivable many died in the destruction and many people's sense of reality were likely destroyed with dimensional portals, aliens descending to take over Earth, Norse gods being real and ScarJo's amazing ass in her suit.
 
S.H.I.E.L.D. tried to nuke New York.

America should have seceded from S.H.I.E.L.D. out right and immediately after that gem came to light.
 
I wonder how well that's known. It's possible to spin it by saying that they intended to give the nuclear missile to Stark to use as a weapon and that was it.
 
Being a Swede, it was so weird seeing so much of Sweden, swedish writing, swedish voices. I did not expect that.

And even the outdoors in Belarus was most definitely filmed in Sweden... :rofl:

Although I am somewhat disappointed none of my friends in Stockholm told me about men in red masks walking around Sergel's Square while cameras where filming.

The show itself keeps getting better and better, the actors are getting into their roles and the mystery is growing, both about the Big Bad and what's up with Coulson.

And about the seeing naked men part, I thought she actually checked out Fitz since she warned him about it. :guffaw:
 
I suppose it's possible that a certain professor in up-state New York has made sure that no such studies produced positive results, or made sure the successful ones weren't seen as credible. ;)
The Vulcan Science Directorate has determined that the existence of Charles Xavier in this continuity is impossible.

I think that might be stretching it a bit. We saw hardly any onscreen deaths in Avengers, and even the level of destruction seemed pretty minimal compared to most alien invasion movies we've seen.

Obviously an alien army descending from the sky is a major event, but even in that world I can't see it packing nearly as big an emotional punch as something like 9/11 or Pearl Harbor.

REALLY? Imagine the impact on everything if, IRL, alien invaders, Norse gods, and green monsters that can throw tanks popped up in New York tomorrow. The number of deaths would be absolutely irrelevant. Even if they did nothing more Earth-shattering than ordering Chinese takeout, the world would irrevocably and fundamentally change a lot more than is typically depicted in a comic book-based universe like the MCU.

Compare 911 to Hiroshima.
Beat me to it! The atomic bomb is the only thing that comes close to how world-changing recent events in the MCU would be.

Fitz/Simmons (whichever)
She's Merry, he's Pippin.

and ScarJo's amazing ass in her suit.
:lol:

S.H.I.E.L.D. tried to nuke New York.

America should have seceded from S.H.I.E.L.D. out right and immediately after that gem came to light.
What, you mean when SHIELD...uh...delivered the nuclear weapon to Iron Man? Yeah, that's the ticket....
 
I suppose it's possible that a certain professor in up-state New York has made sure that no such studies produced positive results, or made sure the successful ones weren't seen as credible. ;)
The Vulcan Science Directorate has determined that the existence of Charles Xavier in this continuity is impossible.

Which is just what they want you to think!

Seriously though, I'd love it if they snuck in a few oblique references to X-Men or even Spider-man. I know they're not allowed to name names, but it shouldn't be too difficult to work around.

Also meant to say that I'm glad I'm not the only one who found this episode dull....

I thought it was the good kind of dull. Like the characters are starting to find their footing and develop some real chemistry.

As for the impact the Battle of New York would have....yeah it'd be pretty major and very much a world-wide thing. Imagine 9/11, Pearl Harbour, Hiroshima, the Battle of Britain and the moon landing all rolled into one. I mean it wasn't just aliens, gods and wholesale destruction, there were bloody great kaiju sized flying snake cyborg things!

Mind you, they did have a pair of green monsters tear up Harlem about a year previous and a swarm of robotic drones blew the crap out of the Stark Expo around the same time so maybe the blow was softened a *teeny* bit? :p
 
Last edited:
The Battle of New York was the 9/11 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, I expect them to mention it a lot.
Exactly what I thought when I heard it mentioned yet again. Considering what happened in that "battle", they are making as big a deal out of it as should be made.

Liked the last two episodes. This Coulson thing looks like it may be headed for something big. Perhaps his former agent knows something about Coulson's personality that Melinda and the doctor and (Cobie Smulders), don't.

The last scene with Fitz/Simmons (whichever) made me laugh out loud. Considering how anxious he was to kick Agent Squarejaw's ass, he lit out so fast it wasn't funny when he thought Skye might see him naked. Funny.

Liking the Skye/Coulson dynamic too. Jury's still out though.

Physical evidence of extra-terrestrials has got to count for something in favor of it being a BIG event, no matter what the damage or body count was.
 
Mind you, they did have a pair of green monsters tear up Harlem about a year previous and a swarm of robotic drones blew the crap out of the Stark Expo around the same time so maybe the blow was softened a *teeny* bit? :p

Well that was actually my thinking about it. If word travels as fast in that world as it does in ours, most people would have already been aware of Thor and Hulk, and seen footage of them fighting some pretty crazy things like the Abomination and the Destroyer (since I really doubt SHIELD would be able to keep those events completely contained).

So by the time aliens arrived, people probably would have been much more prepared for the idea than we would be, who've never seen giant monsters and robots and all-powerful gods battling each other in the streets.
 
I know they seem determined to make this more of a spy series than anything else... but it's still only natural to expect a show set in the Marvel Universe to have some actual superheroes in it. The longer they hold out on actually showing us any (even some simpler, scaled-down versions), the more I think the general audience is going to slowly lose interest in this show.

I'm just not sure it's enough to have them chasing after mysterious artifacts, rogue agents, and random mutants-of-the-week.

And, yet, my non-scifi minded wife is still interested in watching the show.

General audience means the largest common denominator. To have a successful show you want to appeal to as many people as possible. If that means little to no aliens or super heroes/villains, then that's what it means.

Odds are more people will be interested in watching a spy/secret agent/CSI/police procedural than won't be. Yes, us hard core nuts what more, more, MORE but this is about attracting eyeballs and competing with everything else on the market.

And, as mentioned, this is Agent's of SHIELD, not the Avengers or X-Men. That's another movie entirely.
 
The number of deaths would be absolutely irrelevant. Even if they did nothing more Earth-shattering than ordering Chinese takeout...

Oh come on! Chinese take out?! They'd obviously opt for Shwarma.

And, I actually think the events in "Thor" would be the ones most easily contained. The destroyer, the portal to Asgard, all of it. We're talking about a small, desert, town in New Mexico. Sure it'd probably generate conspiracy theories and such but it'd hardly be big news that reach most people. The stuff in "Thor" could have easily been contained by SHIELD.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top