• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers The Acolyte

That was a surprising number of named character deaths! Very good dramatic use of a crowd of redshirts; using them to lull the audience in to a false sense of security, and offing half the main cast anyway! I'm honestly more than a little annoyed that they killed off Jecki; I really enjoyed that character and was looking forward to more with her! Yord's death I'm less bothered by, but yet also somehow even more surprised! And Pip!? I mean there's a chance he can be repaired at least, but still; that was pretty brutal!

Only slightly less surprising was the appearance of what one assumes is cortosis. I must admit; I've never been comfortable with the concept, mostly because it's difficult for storytellers not to get carried away with a "kryptonite" substance eventually, even if they're supposed to be extremely rare. You can almost set your watch by the time a whole army armed with the stuff shows up. Or by how much they end up leaning on it for deus ex machina (beskar is already heading in that direction, honestly.) All that said; so far they're using it well enough, and it seems to be just one helmet and a bracer that both look very old and worn, and so likely a relic of the Sith Wars. Indeed I would kind of like the idea that it's not just a natural substance but a particular alloy; and the secret of it's creation has long since been lost, so it only shows up in relics. So more like valyrian steel in that sense. I'd also go a step further though, and have it so any attempt to re-forge it renders it useless; so what you find is what you get with the relics. One can hope.

Still a lot of questions about Sol and what happened that night. I have my thoughts and assumptions; I mean it feels like a given he was the one that struck down Aniseya to break her hold on Kelnacca's and/or Torbin's mind. Though that alone doesn't account for all the missing pieces. I'm sure we'll be getting another flashback to show an alternate perspective on those events soon enough.

He also said he doesn't have a name. Wouldn't a Sith of either Master or Apprentice rank have a Sith name? Sounds like he's an independent operator now or possibly always has been.
Or he's lying. Sith do that too.
Also, it's not like any other Sith we've seen has willingly announced themselves. TheyJedi only discovered Tyranus and Sidious's names from third parties, and it's still a bit of a question how they knew Maul's name (though one assumes one of the Nemoidians blurted it out after they were arrested.)

I'm still running on the assumption that Qimir (or whatever his name is) is the apprentice trying to recruit an acolyte so they can kill his master. So we still potentially have another Sith that may show up.
 
Last edited:
Still a lot of questions about Sol and what happened that night. I have my thoughts and assumptions; I mean it feels like a given he was the one that struck down Aniseya to break her hold on Kelnacca's and/or Torbin's mind. Though that alone doesn't account for all the missing pieces. I'm sure we'll be getting another flashback to show an alternate perspective on those events soon enough.
I’m thinking that they try that trick on Tobin again but something goes horribly wrong and he goes crazy; killing everyone in that colony before he’s stopped by the Wookie Jedi. That could explain why he was so willing to off himself
 
Just a question to all of you - what is the central theme of the show? I have a hard time figuring out the purpose or why it exists at all.

Good action here with a predictable twist reveal of who the Sith is, slightly less boring than the other episodes but mainly due to Lightsaber and hand to hand action ( which we have seen a hundred+ time by now in all of Star Wars).
 
Only slightly less surprising was the appearance of what one assumes is cortosis. I must admit; I've never been comfortable with the concept, mostly because it's difficult for storytellers not to get carried away with a "kryptonite" substance eventually, even if they're supposed to be extremely rare. You can almost set your watch by the time a whole army armed with the stuff shows up. Or by how much they end up leaning on it for deus ex machina (beskar is already heading in that direction, honestly.) All that said; so far they're using it well enough, and it seems to be just one helmet and a bracer that both look very old and worn, and so likely a relic of the Sith Wars. Indeed I would kind of like the idea that it's not just a natural substance but a particular alloy; and the secret of it's creation has long since been lost, so it only shows up in relics. So more like valyrian steel in that sense. I'd also go a step further though, and have it so any attempt to re-forge it renders it useless; so what you find is what you get with the relics. One can hope.
Cortosis is very brittle, it can only resist so many strikes in its pure form before breaking.
That why it's usually mixed/applied with something else.
 
The Mother, the human one.
I agree.

But we're not out of the woods, so to speak, regarding a possible connection between Mother Aniseya and this self-proclaimed Sith master.

Osha said that her Mother could get inside a Jedi's head, just like he could. Secondly, there still exists the mystery of how the twins were created in the first place, something that seems to resemble Anakin's creation and seems to be on-topic with the tale of Darth Plagueis as told by Palpatine in the opera house. Finally, there is the question of how Mae was introduced to her instructor.

To me, these issues all suggest the strong possibility that Mother Aniseya has collaborated with the Sith.
 
sounds like a variant of Kylo Ren's theme plays at the end of the episode

also an interesting observation from reddit:

"I noticed the red markings on Manny Jacinto's helmet were all red previously. After using his helmet to cut off the one redshirt's saber it left a blue marking. If the markings are from prior sabers, that means he had to have taken a red saber to the helmet at least once before"
 
You bastards.

I knew Jedi were going to die, even more than just the greyshirts, but I was still absolutely gutted by Jecki's sudden (but perhaps inevitable) demise. She was clearly in waaay over her head while she continuously attacked Qimir (!), mostly on her own. Even with her second saber up her sleeve, that mode of attack wasn't going to end well so I shouldn't have been surprised when Qimir played the same trick. But her death still sucked. Outside of Osha and Mae, she was the character I most enjoyed and wanted to see more of (again, not just because of Dafne Keen) and I'm greatly saddened we won't see anymore of her.

This episode was far more devastating and monumental than I expected and I'm grateful for it. That said, I didn't expect Qimir to actually survive the forest bugs, thinking the show was going to do a major shift by focusing on just Mae's and Osha's continued journey.

Nonetheless, I was saddened when Osha rejected Mae's olive branch of love because of her refusal to see the possible truth. even after questioning Sol about what Qimir meant about not trusting Sol. I really hoped they would make peace with each other, thus beginning to heal together. I should've known better because of what the show has been heavily foreshadowing this whole time, but I still held out onto hope.

However, having the two of them swap positions (unwillingly on Osha's part) makes thematic and symmetric sense (especially considering the episode titles) and the show definitely feels like we're barreling towards what many of us predicted/feared: Osha is about to become the true Acolyte. There's still a chance that might not happen but the show seems pretty consistent so far about what it is projecting.

Speaking of which, sometimes the simplest explanations are the best. Silly me, I talked myself out of believing the obvious and thought Qimir wasn't the true master after all. It's a classic trope and while it might be slightly overused and unsurprising, I don't mind it, if mostly because it gives Manny Jacinto a lot more to sink his teeth into.

Lastly, let's hold up a glass to Yord. He may have been a dweeb, but he was a brave and honorable dweeb. While I'm not nearly as saddened by his death as Jecki's, I am sorry he died, too.

Considering the tweet Mr. Adventure provided about next week's episode, it seems like we might be getting that counter right away. Makes me wonder if the show is going for a mirrored balance with these titles, i.e. two episodes with pairings, followed by single-word title for a flashback episode then a present one, and then doing the reverse (making the speculated Mae perspective flashback episode six, hopefully!).

Or maybe I'm overthinking it...
Looks like I wasn't overthinking it after all! Safe bet on getting the flashback episode next week that'll show Mae's perspective on Brendok.
 
That was an atrocious piece of TV. Clunky dialogue that had no meaning other than to sound profound. And action that went on endlessly with continuous cuts to pointless talking scenes of characters saying they have to leave and then saying they have to go back. And then the weird little alien character walking around the forest like some kind of pervert on patrol.

The action scenes reminded me of this
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
Unending and ultimately pointless.
 
I knew the Sith was the Asian Ezra Miller fellow who was following Mae around.

It was sad to see Yord and especially Jecki die. I wished to have seen more of them in the following episodes.

Twins changing places is an old trope as someone earlier mentioned. Let's see what happens next.
 
I mean the episode certainly had some great moments but it was all kind of ruined when the twin switcheroo thing happened, we're apparently at the point now where a Jedi Master can be fooled by a lightsaber haircut
 
I mean the episode certainly had some great moments but it was all kind of ruined when the twin switcheroo thing happened, we're apparently at the point now where a Jedi Master can be fooled by a lightsaber haircut
We don’t know if he’s fooled yet
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top