Interesting. I'd never give something a 10 unless it was amongst my all-time favourites. Otherwise I can't go above it.
Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 1x03 - "Ghosts of Illyria"
- Thread starter Commander Richard
- Start date
Because "flawless[,] or essentially flawless" was exactly what I said, just in different words. The word "or" makes it so. Your allowance of "wiggle-room" reduced what you said to exactly what I said, because it allows the point you were apparently trying to make to be denied; I used an ellipsis to "cut out" that part to demonstrate that. Ironic, isn't it?
Pretty good review, and the "pantropy" concept is one I hadn't heard before. I liked his description of the auxiliary sickbay having a mezzanine level. I guess when there's no medical emergency it could revert to its original role as the ship's mall. or maybe the bowling alley.
Since this is a TOS-era show, you can exceed 10! But by the time we hit TNG era, the scale will have to be revised downwards or else all salamanders will break loose.
Last edited:
Honestlt, I could have given all of the episodes a "10" as they're all the best of NuTrek I've seen. This is really what I've wanted to see and elements of the show look/feel like what my imaginary crew/"fan fiction" looks like. I mean, there's problems with it, but overall I'm really, really liking it. I'm just saving that "10" for the ground-breaking, great, episode on the levels of Yesterday's Enterprise, BOBW, The Visitor, Tapestry, etc. Other level type stuff.
But other than some minor things I've not problems with this series yet.
...and doing Dos Equis commercials.
What I'm saying is that some people may actually see a piece of fiction as actually flawless, despite you saying that it's not possible. So no, we are not saying the same thing. But it's not important, because in the end the larger point is the same: now I know what Serveaux meant by "10".
With the exception of a couple of photographs of Emily Ratajkowski's face (
), I completely agree. I think it was Neil Gaiman who once said that a novel is a long work of prose with something wrong with it.
You know, I have to chuckle at the "Kirk tear" Number One does to her tunic.
Yeah I wonder if that was the intended reference. Sure felt that way.
Oh it had to be intended.
Looked like a normal way to rip a shirt.
You do that often?
It is a cool, refreshing sensation on my body. 
Yeah but it's reverse sexism because a lot of times Kirk went topless too when he tore his shirt...
He was once belted by Gamma rays.You do that often?
You do that often?
I got better.
They'd have to pony up a lot more cash to Rebecca Romijn.Yeah but it's reverse sexism because a lot of times Kirk went topless too when he tore his shirt...
Sometimes it's so bad that it sucks and blows simultaneously, which is not as easy as it sounds.If it's 180 degrees opposite, if it doesn't suck, does that mean it blows?
