I totally agree that TOS was very good about not showing more than one ship in the same shot in situations where the ships are supposed to be far apart. The only time I remember where it was questionable was "The Tholian Web" with the web spinners.
However, have you guys ever tallied the actual number of times more than one ship appeared in the same shot? As far as I can tell there are 29 episodes that ships (space creatures and shuttles excluded) encountered each other and of those, 11 episodes show more than one ship in the same shot.
That makes 38% of these space encounters to have more than one ship in the same shot. That doesn't sound like it being a rare occurrence IMO.
More than 1 ship in same shot - Name - Ships
Yes - The Corbomite Maneuver - Enterprise+Cube, Enterprise+Fesarius, Enterprise+Fesarius Small Ship
No - Mudd's Women
No - Charlie X
No - Balance of Terror
No - The Conscience of the King
No - Court Martial
No - Arena
Yes - The Alternative Factor - Enterprise with phaser straight to planet targeting Lazarus' ship
Yes - Space Seed - Enterprise+Botany Bay
No - Errand of Mercy
No - Operation Annihilate
No - Friday's Child
Yes - The Doomsday Machine - Enterprise+Constellation, Enterprise+DDM, Constellation+DDM
No - The Changeling
No - The Deadly Years
Yes - The Trouble With Tribbles - Enterprise+K7
No - Journey to Babel
No - Patterns of Force
Yes - The Ultimate Computer - Lexington+Excalibur+Potemkin+Hood
Yes - The Omega Glory - Enterprise+Exeter
Yes - Spectre of the Gun - Enterprise+Melkotian Device
No - Elaan of Troyius
Yes - The Enterprise Incident - Enterprise+3 Romulan Battlecruisers
No - Spock's Brain
Yes - The Tholian Web - Enterprise+Defiant, Enterprise+Tholian Webspinners
Yes - For The World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky - Enterprise+Asteroid Ship
No - Day of the Dove
No - Let That Be Your Last Battlefield
No - The Way to Eden
However, have you guys ever tallied the actual number of times more than one ship appeared in the same shot? As far as I can tell there are 29 episodes that ships (space creatures and shuttles excluded) encountered each other and of those, 11 episodes show more than one ship in the same shot.
That makes 38% of these space encounters to have more than one ship in the same shot. That doesn't sound like it being a rare occurrence IMO.
More than 1 ship in same shot - Name - Ships
Yes - The Corbomite Maneuver - Enterprise+Cube, Enterprise+Fesarius, Enterprise+Fesarius Small Ship
No - Mudd's Women
No - Charlie X
No - Balance of Terror
No - The Conscience of the King
No - Court Martial
No - Arena
Yes - The Alternative Factor - Enterprise with phaser straight to planet targeting Lazarus' ship
Yes - Space Seed - Enterprise+Botany Bay
No - Errand of Mercy
No - Operation Annihilate
No - Friday's Child
Yes - The Doomsday Machine - Enterprise+Constellation, Enterprise+DDM, Constellation+DDM
No - The Changeling
No - The Deadly Years
Yes - The Trouble With Tribbles - Enterprise+K7
No - Journey to Babel
No - Patterns of Force
Yes - The Ultimate Computer - Lexington+Excalibur+Potemkin+Hood
Yes - The Omega Glory - Enterprise+Exeter
Yes - Spectre of the Gun - Enterprise+Melkotian Device
No - Elaan of Troyius
Yes - The Enterprise Incident - Enterprise+3 Romulan Battlecruisers
No - Spock's Brain
Yes - The Tholian Web - Enterprise+Defiant, Enterprise+Tholian Webspinners
Yes - For The World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky - Enterprise+Asteroid Ship
No - Day of the Dove
No - Let That Be Your Last Battlefield
No - The Way to Eden