• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Strange New Worlds Season 2 Trailer

To La'an Noonian Singh, you've got a very unique last name. Do you have any relation to Khan Noonian Singh?

So Khan Noonian Singh is pretty well-known. Awkward for Spock and Kirk in Space Seed, given their intimate connections to La'an.

Perhaps it conveniently gets classified again, like Disco S2.
Yawn.

A genetically engineered superman named Khan...who has been cryogenically frozen for centuries. It's not a major leap.
Yaawwnn.
Awkward for Kirk who boned Laan Noonian Singh a few years earlier.

However, in his defense... if this character is Shatner's Kirk, he probably lost track of all the women he had relations with during those years.


Makes me wonder why the SNW team really wanted a Khan relative with such a similar name on the main cast. Strange choice. At the very least they could have come up with a less obvious name for her, but I suspect they wanted the name recognition to draw in the casuals.
Yawning intensifying.
It just makes Space Seed amusing (and awkward).

Perhaps they'll classify La'an Noonian Singh like Discovery Season 2. No one shall mention her again, or face the penalty of death :lol: Canon saved.
Approaching maximum yawning. Lockjaw imminent.
 
I actually wouldn’t mind it if SNW retconned the TOS uniform rank stripes on the sleeves to match what the US navy does to correspond to each rank. Those dress uniforms looked good as hell and I think captains would look neat with 4 stripes, commanders with 3, etc…
I disagree with this. I like the less militaristic look with the rank stripes that Roddenberry and Theiss went for in the TOS uniforms - I miss the dashed half-stripes from those uniforms.
 
I disagree with this. I like the less militaristic look with the rank stripes that Roddenberry and Theiss went for in the TOS uniforms - I miss the dashed half-stripes from those uniforms.

I don’t like it for militarism, I like it because it makes sense and it easy to discern by looking at it quickly. The TNG (and onward) rank pips are based on this scheme just using filled in and outlined dots instead of stripes.
 
I don’t like it for militarism, I like it because it makes sense and it easy to discern by looking at it quickly. The TNG (and onward) rank pips are based on this scheme just using filled in and outlined dots instead of stripes.
Yeah, but the TOS stripes were just as easy to read, if not easier, and made at least as much sense. The only changes that I would make would be to use the simple straight stripes - TAS style - and maybe to change the color. I liked the silver stripes from the JJ-verse, but I really liked the copper stripes from the Kelvin uniforms.
 
Again, Kirk wasn’t unfamiliar with Khan in Space Seed…just wasn’t sure this Khan WAS Khan.

There’s a fair bit of wiggle room in the episode, and besides, we already know TOS was a canonical mess
 
I mean, when they all sit in the Briefing Room and talk about Khan we hear Kirk, McCoy and Scotty all rattle off facts about Khan Noonien Singh so it's clear that a whole lot of people in the mid-to-late 23rd century knew who he was in history. Before then he was just a South Asian man from about two centuries ago who was found in a pre-warp Earth sleeper ship. To be fair he could well have been anybody given the number of humans who cryofroze themselves in the 1990s and early 21st century.

So there's no contradiction whatsoever in "Space Seed."
 
I mean, when they all sit in the Briefing Room and talk about Khan we hear Kirk, McCoy and Scotty all rattle off facts about Khan Noonien Singh so it's clear that a whole lot of people in the mid-to-late 23rd century knew who he was in history. Before then he was just a South Asian man from about two centuries ago who was found in a pre-warp Earth sleeper ship. To be fair he could well have been anybody given the number of humans who cryofroze themselves in the 1990s and early 21st century.

So there's no contradiction whatsoever in "Space Seed."
McCoy: I was hoping for Sonny Clemons.
 
Probably for the best. He'd have just complained about a martini from a TOS Era food synthesizer. They weren't as accurate as TNG Era replicators.
 
It's also pretty reasonable they didn't recognize him on sight, given the outcome of his reign and the historical era. For example, The majority of people in the world could identify a photo of Hitler. Many, could recognize Stalin. But I'd wager the number of people who could identify Mussolini is pretty low by comparison.
 
It's also pretty reasonable they didn't recognize him on sight, given the outcome of his reign and the historical era. For example, The majority of people in the world could identify a photo of Hitler. Many, could recognize Stalin. But I'd wager the number of people who could identify Mussolini is pretty low by comparison.
True and he was just one of several supermen who seized power. And according to our heroes, not the worst of the lot.
 
As I mentioned in another discussion Josef Mengele was still alive within the lifetimes of a lot of posters here. How many people would recognize Mengele's photo from his days as a Nazi? Or Martin Bormann's if he weren't wearing his distinctive Nazi party uniform (or even IF he were)? Hell, there are probably millions of people around the world who can't identify Idi Amin and they made a major Hollywood movie about him.
 
Really, the writer seemed to be working from the instinct to make Trek seem plausibly contemporary by treating history from centuries past as somewhat obscure to people in the present day (and by "people" I mean the 1966 American television audience). The average person then would not have necessarily recognized Wyatt Earp if he walked into a grocery store despite his having a popular fame at that time far out of proportion to his historical importance.

Like almost everything that has to do with the digital age, Trek did not foresee a world in which almost any image or bit of visual information can be recalled from a network in a few seconds.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top