• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Strange New Worlds General Discussion Thread

Sam wasn't even in Starfleet in TOS but was a civilian scientist working on Deneva. Which, fine, Sam can resign his Starfleet commission and go to live with his wife and son Peter on Deneva within the next eight years but him being in Starfleet and on the Enterprise of all ships six years before his brother takes command as Captain is a bit of a curve ball.

Ahh, crap. I've gotten Kirk's brother Sam confused for his father, here. Bad on me.
 
Mmm... Sam Kirk maybe shouldn't be there, I would agree, but the others were all established TOS/TAS characters whose existence on-board the ship should start somewhere. Why not in SNW?

IIRC, Robert April was captain of the Enterprise before Pike. So he should be older, a higher rank, and a gold shirt. He also wouldn't be a member of the crew. Those are the issues I have. That said, April is an obscure enough character in Trek that I could bite off on this being his kid, Robert April II, or someone else with the same name.
 
IIRC, Robert April was captain of the Enterprise before Pike. So he should be older, a higher rank, and a gold shirt. He also wouldn't be a member of the crew. Those are the issues I have. That said, April is an obscure enough character in Trek that I could bite off on this being his kid, Robert April II, or someone else with the same name.
It's the same April that captained the Enterprise before. Pike was his First Officer
 
Anyone know why the helmsman's sleeve stripes are red? I'm also guessing she's not a full commander, but hell, almost everyone else is. ;)
In season 2 of DISCO and on SNW, the rank stripes on the Enterprise uniform sleeves were a metallic version of the uniform color.

Check out a picture of Spock's uniform sleeves from SNW. You'll see it's sporting blue stripes.
 
IIRC, Robert April was captain of the Enterprise before Pike. So he should be older, a higher rank, and a gold shirt. He also wouldn't be a member of the crew. Those are the issues I have. That said, April is an obscure enough character in Trek that I could bite off on this being his kid, Robert April II, or someone else with the same name.

If Admiral April is 48 (like the actor portraying him) in 2259, he would've been 34-39 when he commanded the Enterprise between 2245-50. April does not have to be significantly older than Pike to have been his commanding officer. April could have risen up the ranks slightly faster than Pike did.

Spock, after all, was apparently three years older than Kirk.
 
I wasn’t keen on overwriting Chapel, because there’s no need for her to be in the show if they wanted a different character. But there’s a very good reason for changing April, a literal cartoon character.
That we’ve seen like 10 Enterprise captains and they’ve *all* been white is a relic of another time.
 
Oh dear

wokeness, wokness, wokness so apprently spoilers below, please dont read.


Chapel is bisexual in SNW, like really?
And so Kurtzman Trek continues:shrug: they have learned nothing from discovery.

Certainly nothing in the first two episodes suggests that.

And there's absolutely no good reason, dramatic or moral or in terms of blessed "canon," that she shouldn't be.

If this kind of thing offends you, your best course of action is to abandon ship and drop all further interest in Star Trek immediately. This is a given and you can do nothing about it.

If anything, the powers that be learned a great deal from STD, including and importantly that most Star Trek fans have a positive hunger to see the show to become contemporary again, and to embrace the morality of freedom and respect for the rights of all individuals to equal treatment and to inclusion in all aspects of our shared communities and culture.

And the idiot "true fans" who make bank with disgusting YouTube content ranting against this and holding out their manufactured claims of "cultural vandalism" had best fuck off and get lost.
 
Last edited:
Archer - white male.
April - black male.
Pike - white male.
Kirk - white male.
Decker - white male.
Spock - white male.
Harriman - white male.
Garrett - white female.
Picard - white male.
Riker - white male.
Jellico - white male.

April and Garrett are the only outliers, Spock if we count him as being half-alien.
 
Heh .. I had just turned 21 a little over a month before TMP premiered.
I was 16 the year TMP premiered; and like many others was REALLY excited to see it (it was 10 years since the last true 'live action' Star Trek, and when you're 16, ten years is a LONG time ;)) - but afterwards was a little disappointed in that yes, in the end, it was a 40 million dollar redo of TOS S2 - "The Changeling", and I was someone who didn't care for the 1701 exterior update, or the walking pajama ship's uniforms; but enjoyed most of the new interior sets.

The above said, that didn't stop me from seeing it 5 more times while it was in the theatres because I LOVED the opening with the Klingons (and REALLY loved the new 'Klingon' theme used in that scene. Bought the film soundtrack album as soon as it hit the stores and played it a lot.

say it with me now…Alternate Universe…
Yeah, we're not discussing the JJ Abrams/Kelvin films in this thread. We're talking "Strange New Worlds" which is part of the Prime timeline along with TOS, TNG, et al. :nyah:
 
Last edited:
Oh dear

wokeness, wokness, wokness so apprently spoilers below, please dont read.


YouTube hearsay
And so Kurtzman Trek continues:shrug: they have learned nothing from discovery.
swatting-slap.gif
 
Oh dear

wokeness, wokness, wokness so apprently spoilers below, please dont read.

Chapel is bisexual in SNW, like really?
And so Kurtzman Trek continues:shrug: they have learned nothing from discovery.
This contradicts nothing about the original character and simply expands on the relationship possibilities of the character henceforth. That you see something wrong or ruinous about this is simply a measure of you projecting your own insecurities on the audience as a whole and passing on your unsolicited bigotry for us to have to read.

I'd say they have learned something from Discovery, which is not to listen to the exceedingly loud but insignificant voices of racist, sexist, homophobes when making casting decisions, unlike the perpetually risk averse and cowardly Berman-era.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top