• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Starfleet Academy Official Trailer

The point of the show is that it's something Alex Kurtzman really wanted to do. As far as it bringing in new fans, I think we both know that it's not going to. Streaming Trek isn't high profile. It's not Tulsa King or 1923, so let's not kid ourselves.

If they want a bigger audience for Star Trek, they'll have to make a new cinematic movie, or they'll have to reach out beyond Paramount+.

Otherwise, it doesn't matter if it's Legacy or Starfleet Academy or Strange New Worlds. It's still going to be the same dwindling audience, no matter what. Fortunately for me, how big the audience is doesn't factor into whether or not I watch or enjoy a show. Otherwise, I wouldn't have liked DS9, VOY, DSC or PIC.
I mean... that will be the result (not bringing in any new fans /fully relying on the old fanbase).

But it's certainly not the intention - I'm sure Kurtzman had a fantastic elevator pitch how this show is going to connect with a completely new, younger audiences and break out a lá Wednesday or Stranger Things.

Nobody really ever starts out with the intention to do by-the-numbers, bland stuff.
That usually just happens once everybody has to put their money where their mouth is, and everyone, in a thousand small decisions, veers back into their personal comfort zone and delivers the stuff the same way they've always done.
 
Nobody really ever starts out with the intention to do by-the-numbers, bland stuff.
Of course not. Everyone has to get themselves excited about what they're working on. I really do believe that Alex Kurtzman wants to make something for his kids and he was thinking about the future and the literal next generation.

Now that I know what to look out for with Paul Giamatti, I'm prepared for that. Holly Hunter is fine, like I said before. I don't have a problem with any of the adult characters. So, really, for me it's all going to come down to what I think of the Cadets and if I'm invested in the stories about them.

One time, when I was a college student myself, my friends went to go see the first Harry Potter movie and I got dragged along. I couldn't believe it. I was thinking to myself, "I'm 22 and I'm going to a Harry Potter movie?!" But I went. I didn't want to be left out. And I ended up liking it, even though i was twice the age of the characters. Now I'm in my 40s and twice the age of college students, but I'm hoping my experience with Starfleet Academy will be similar to my experience with Harry Potter. But we'll see.

To be brutally honest, though, whether I end up liking the series or not, I only expect it to go the two seasons. I really don't think Alex Kurtzman's contract will be renewed. I'm just being up-front with all of you about what I think. But -- if this series clicks with me -- that doesn't mean I won't make the best of it and enjoy the ride anyway, while it lasts.
 
Last edited:
To be brutally honest, though, whether I end up liking the series or not, I only expect it to go the two seasons. I really don't think Alex Kurtzman's contract will be renewed. I'm just being up-front with all of you about what I think. But -- if this series clicks with me -- that doesn't mean I won't make the best of it and enjoy the ride anyway, while it lasts.

If David Ellison is expecting people to come rushing back into the theaters, it is not going to happen.

Feature film actors are now doing streaming series (Harrison Ford, Nicole Kidman, Holly Hunter, Helen Mirren, Gary Oldman). What's more, Marvel has been having problems with the MCU films (they've been underperforming at the box office).
 
Interesting, it has made me curious enough to watch the show when it comes out.

Also, perhaps apropos of nothing, I wish the video encoding on Youtube didn't make stuff look blotchy and muddy like this.

Kor
 
Last edited:
My main concern with SFA, and it has been this way since 2017 with other Star Trek projects, is with the quality of the stories being written. They have struggled with story, plot, and characters for a while now. If they can do at least a modicum of decency with all three for this new series, it will have met the lowest number of expectations I have for any Star Trek production in the Kurtzman era.
 
My main concern with SFA, and it has been this way since 2017 with other Star Trek projects, is with the quality of the stories being written. They have struggled with story, plot, and characters for a while now. If they can do at least a modicum of decency with all three for this new series, it will have met the lowest number of expectations I have for any Star Trek production in the Kurtzman era.
Needs to go back to the basics of telling good science fiction stories.

I've been reading Harlan Ellison short stories off and on over lately, and I am now reading what I've been missing on TV.
 
I'm sure her photon can be reconfigured to look like an EV. And given some of the crazy noggins in Starfleet, they must have quite a selection of helmets.
Nope, we've seen the EV storage lockers multiple times.

Though of course, they shouldn't even be needing EV suits in the 32nd century.


Interesting, it has made me curious enough to watch the show when it comes out.

Also, perhaps apropos of nothing, I wish the video encoding on Youtube didn't make stuff look blotchy and muddy like this.

Kor
Try watching it on youtube itself, they do this weird thing now were they massively cut the quality on any embedded media.
 
Needs to go back to the basics of telling good science fiction stories.

Also science fiction:

3ccb2c5935c196a607ce34afcd82e04a.jpg


328483fbf51f04bbc76820c5664c7fe7-original.jpg
 
Nope, we've seen the EV storage lockers multiple times.
That's because the budget doesn't allow. Realistically the multispecies Federation/Starfleet would have multiple suit configurations.
Though of course, they shouldn't even be needing EV suits in the 32nd century.
I forget, why exactly wouldn't they? Can all species exist in the vacuum of space unprotected in the 32nd Century? Or is this a programable matter thing?
 
That's because the budget doesn't allow. Realistically the multispecies Federation/Starfleet would have multiple suit configurations.
No it isn't, because the EV suit lockers in Lower Decks were the same.


I forget, why exactly wouldn't they? Can all species exist in the vacuum of space unprotected in the 32nd Century? Or is this a programable matter thing?
Because the same forcefield technology that allows mobile emitters to work could just as easily protect someone from vacuum.

Though yes, also programmable matter.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top