• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 3x07 - "What Is Starfleet?"

Eat it!


  • Total voters
    136
Is it me, or does the 203 crew count feel kind of low for the USS Enterprise being that big @ 442.6 meters?
Well, 203 is the crew count that Pike first gave in "The Cage". And the secondary hull is mostly taken up by Engineering and the cargo and hangar bays. So the saucer has to not only house the crew in their gigantic quarters, but also contain all the science labs, recreational and training spaces, the brig, and Sickbay. I'd say 203 is about right.
 
Have you forgotten Picard's Romulan-Irish housekeeper/girlfriend? That was arguably even more jarring.
I think they explained that she had first settled in Ireland but maybe that was a behind the scenes explanation.

Most jarring of all is the most Dublin of men Colm Meaney being cast as a Kerry person.
 
Yes, the intro segment basically says that someone filed an FOI request for the footage that was declassified, presumably as part of that request.

Which is ironic because governments today would just black bar everything... although I don't know what that would look like for videos. Maybe they just leave in a black screen for parts of a video they'd want to keep classified.
The security cam footage contained information that was classified. As were parts of the mission. But the mission itself self, transporting “livestock” to Lutani, was not. And the nature of the mission changed as events unfolded.
I think they explained that she had first settled in Ireland but maybe that was a behind the scenes explanation.

Most jarring of all is the most Dublin of men Colm Meaney being cast as a Kerry person.
To be fair, he was cast as “conn officer.” Didn’t get a name or background until later. ;)
 
I think they explained that she had first settled in Ireland but maybe that was a behind the scenes explanation.

Most jarring of all is the most Dublin of men Colm Meaney being cast as a Kerry person.
Hmm, I hadn't watched the BTS stuff but the Picard: Countdown comic gave no indication of that. That being said, that comic can't really fit now anyway as Laris and Zhaban met in adulthood in that comic but were said to have met in childhood in the show (in an episode made after the comic was published)
 
Hmm, I hadn't watched the BTS stuff but the Picard: Countdown comic gave no indication of that. That being said, that comic can't really fit now anyway as Laris and Zhaban met in adulthood in that comic but were said to have met in childhood in the show (in an episode made after the comic was published)
Well, it's a comic. So...
 
Yes... It was shown in Star Trek: Prodigy.

Everyone was speaking different languages and we are just hearing English because of the Universal Translator.
I don't think it's ever explained how someone temporarily "turns off" the universal translator when they want to be heard in their own language. Is it a telepathic thing where they think hard for it to be turned off? Because we never see anyone say "Computer, deactivate my Universal Translator for the next 1 minute" or whatever before speaking in a non-English language.
 
I don't think it's ever explained how someone temporarily "turns off" the universal translator when they want to be heard in their own language.
UniversalTranslatorDS9.jpg
 
I gave it an 8. It was a good, solid episode but not extraordinary. Some of the parts were a bit tedious where the interviews didn't add much. It actually reminds me of several old M*A*S*H episodes where they had a reporter interviewing the cast. The cast ad libbed many of their responses and those episodes were fairly effective.

I thought the answer to whether Starfleet was military or explorers was a good one.
 
The whole 'flagship' thing in this era is bad writing. At this stage the Enterprise (under April AND Pike) and her crew have done absolutely nothing to warrant such a distinction. This is the result of writers 'looking back' to a LATER era. (TNG)
Starfleet must use a different definition of "flagship" than modern (and older) navies. In the real world, a flagship is simply the ship that the commanding officer of a group of ships uses. It flies that officers flag--hence "flagship." It often will have special areas and features for coordinating a fleet.

By that definition, none of the Enterprises in ST are flagships.

Hence, Starfleet must use a different definition.
 
I was a bit perturbed by why Beto kept asking the crew policy questions about a planet they were, at best, peripherally aware of before being assigned a mission there. Isn't it really a Federation President/Commissioner of State question? There must be a news article on why the Federation is aiding planet Wherever in their war despite their historical links to the Klingons.
I wasn't perturbed by Beto asking the questions. After all, journalists are going to journal!

I was bugged that some of the lower officers were actually trying to answer those policy questions. In the real world, lower members of an organization are generally given specific instructions for how to handle media interview. One common instruction is to not speculate beyond "their paygrade" and to refer those types of questions to their superiors.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top