I'm going with a 7. It was a balls out actions episode, lots of really good effects and the cast was excellent. Still bothered by how much this "new Gorn" is ripped straight from the Alien franchise. Using other Trek's unoriginality is not a deflector for SNW. It's still lazy. The hibernation aspect was good, though.
Somehow Scotty will grow confidence and his taste for alcohol at the same time. And yeah, still like Doohan better, but the new guy is second best, above Pegg.
Ortegas' disfigurement was pretty quickly brushed off with an barely heard "we'll take care of this when we get back to the ship." She's the freaking pilot, this should have been a major traumatic moment. And fine, I get they can heal her, but after this episode we get the time jump and all is well. Wasted opportunity and a pointless moment of horror. Especially since the implication was that they were being absorbed or digested. This part actually bothered me because the moment I saw her hand, my mind went to the implications of such an injury to the character. Womp womp.
They portray her as practically on her last breath with blood seeping into the console, a classic "last words" exit line and then... "she'll be okay."
I can't wait for the explanation of how Chapel goes from this brilliant medical professional to a nurse who hands McCoy instruments and isn't an actual doctor. She probably has a cousin Christine who will take her place when this one dies in the series finale.
For everyone who says "they can't make more episodes because these are so expensive" - the whole time I was watching this thinking "this is entertaining but when did Star Trek become a huge effects, action extravaganza?" I'm not invested in the spinning, weaving, eye popping visuals and breakneck pace. Maybe if they spent less time making a 48ish minute blockbuster film, they'd have a few more bucks to make longer seasons and let this series breathe - and more time to go into those moments they set up, like Ortegas' missing fingers.
But then again, they'd probably just make more episodes like the next one... which....naaah.
It was fine.