• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 3x08 - "Surrender"

Engage!


  • Total voters
    243
Survey says...

Yes.

Yes, and then Picard will release her, ala the end of "The Pegasus."

Yes. His next wine order is due.

Probably. The enemy clearly doesn't trust Vadic so that she failed is more an annoyance than anything else. Typical villain behavior.

Jesus wept. Good lord. Are you on drugs?
 
I've said it on multiple occasions that I don't give a shite about the old stuff; all I want is good storytelling. I don't give a crap about a few plot holes... that's a given in storytelling... just accept it cuz you're having fun. This show haas so many plot holes ..
Are you here to discuss things or just argue and insult. This is very close to trolling.
 
:guffaw::guffaw::guffaw::guffaw::guffaw::guffaw:

I LOVE THIS!!!!

I've never actually seen 'beating a dead horse' shown literally in a post before. How did you do that?

(I would certainly use it in several instances.)
Many thanks! :)

However, I cannot take credit for them, sadly. I've lurked on hundreds of BBS's for the past 2.5 decades and each one had its own collection of animated emoji's in the thread posting area, just like this one. Knowing how finite all sites are in Teh Interwebz, when I find one (or more) that appeals to me, I download them all and archive them on my Imgur account for their inevitable later use. I also have a vast collection of animated & static memes. In this particular thread's context with a certain set of posts, for example, this one comes to mind:
sSifHPn.gif


When a picture is worth a thousand words, an animated meme is worth a thousand words times the number of frames in the animation. It allows me to speak hundreds of thousands of words in a single post without hitting the character count ceiling! :D
 
It’s a shame that Spock was executed for mutiny in The Menagerie and Picards Starfleet career ended so early for stealing a shuttle on the Stargazer.

Remember how Worf was subjected to a court martial for disobeying orders and murdering Duras, and then was arrested for desertion when he went to fight in the Klingon civil war?

man TNG was a hardass about actions having consequences.

If only this new show showed the spine of consistent consequences TNG did
 
Caught up in a few days and I have mixed feelings though it feels more Star Trek than Picard s1 & s2 + seeing the cast together is heart-warming - Especially as i'm in the middle of a TNG rewatch. Assuming this isn't a DS9 story being told with TNG characters, i'm going this is The Borg.

Now while everything couldn't be further from the tactics of the Borg, I've noticed hints along the way...

* Shaw being a character with PTSD from Wolf 359

* Vadic tractor beam was Borg esq.

* Voices being whispered like the collective we know.

* The voice sounding like a Borg Queen.

* Vadic telling Seven - It's fitting you're here.

* Even the Virus - we assume there on about the Changeling one but Vadic saying the cure was taken not given. The Borg Queen took the pathogen and I guess eventually the cure from Admiral Janeway that allowed the Borg to adapt but not after they were decimated.

* The fact we saw both USS Voyager and got a cameo from a Voyager character in Tuvok.

However - Why would the Borg use changelings? Why red eyes when Borg colour is green? and is this something to do with the end of season 2 and the cataclysm that nearly destroyed the Alpha Quadrant but was prevented by the other Borg collective.

Also surely the Borg should be more p*ssed at Janeway, not Picard.
 
It’s a shame that Spock was executed for mutiny in The Menagerie and Picards Starfleet career ended so early for stealing a shuttle on the Stargazer.

Remember how Worf was subjected to a court martial for disobeying orders and murdering Duras, and then was arrested for desertion when he went to fight in the Klingon civil war?

man TNG was a hardass about actions having consequences.

If only this new show showed the spine of consistent consequences TNG did
My personal favorite was when Jadzia Dax was forced to separate from the Dax symbiote as punishment for murdering the Albino. Ezri Dax was a much better replacement and settled in with the crew after that for the rest of Season 2.
 
Had Seven blown the turbolift with Vadic and Shaw in it, she would've been court martialed for killing her Captain! :eek:

My God, the man does not think! :rolleyes:
 
Had Seven blown the turbolift with Vadic and Shaw in it, she would've been court martialed for killing her Captain! :eek:

My God, the man does not think! :rolleyes:
I want a series of entirely federation acquisitions committees arguing about starship design for 5 seasons and absolute savage attention to any and all inconsistencies
 
Man, they're going all in on the red vines/neurons/lattice things. I kinda hope the reveal is as "Ah, okay" as rumor has it, because I do not want to have to drink from the hose of new lore with 120 minutes left in the show.
 
My personal favorite was when Jadzia Dax was forced to separate from the Dax symbiote as punishment for murdering the Albino. Ezri Dax was a much better replacement and settled in with the crew after that for the rest of Season 2.
To be fair, she was portrayed as not much better... conferring with a former Dax host who was a psychotic serial killer through a dubious ritual that made it impossible to verify whether she was of sound mind and thus would've rendered any information she collected inadmissible as evidence in a proper criminal investigation, best exemplified that under his influence, she extralegally murdered a Vulcan suspect instead of reporting him to the proper authorities. She deserved the forced separation and being sent to a prison colony for vigilante justice all the same.
 
To be fair, she was portrayed as not much better... conferring with a former Dax host who was a psychotic serial killer through a dubious ritual that made it impossible to verify whether she was of sound mind and thus would've rendered any information she collected inadmissible as evidence in a proper criminal investigation, best exemplified that under his influence, she extralegally murdered a Vulcan suspect instead of reporting him to the proper authorities. She deserved the forced separation and being sent to a prison colony for vigilante justice all the same.
Yeah, but that was in Season 7 and everyone knows that the 7th season doesn't count*



*except when it totally does.
 
I never attack the person who's replying to me, always talk about the show. If you don't like my posts, good luck. Otherwise actually respond to what I've stated.
Again, attacking the poster rather than the post. I haven't posted that much of late.
You had the right idea here.
Jesus wept. Good lord. Are you on drugs?
Too bad you didn't keep to your word. Do something like this again and you'll get a warning for flaming.

Are you here to discuss things or just argue and insult. This is very close to trolling.
I see nothing actionable in the post you were responding to.

Obvious troll is obvious.
Knock this shit off.

I'm not normally one to advocate the Ignore feature, but I think several posters here maybe need to use it if they're going to get so wound up about one poster posting negative opinions, which is perfectly valid and not actionable trolling.
 
Exactly. By all accounts a typical Star Trek torpedo has a higher yield than anything else that exists today. Nothing dumb about it. Nothing.
well, let's forget for a moment that the shrike should have had its shields up. And these don't look like quantum torpedoes, just wallmart torpedoes. Or is it torpedos. So how would I know how many? it just seems like shrike was supposed to be a battleship they were scared poopless of but once it was convenient, bangety bam, they are gone. I mean after Riker smacked that baby with a rock, did he not realize he could have just hung around and destroyed them then and there. Now Commander Seven said give em borg hell and it didn't even look like they fired phasers. Sigh, I suppose if there was more money in the budget and they showed the shrike getting a lightening bug blood bath from phasers and another spread of torps then i would have been able to believe it. that is all. Oh and I stand by the JJ hate LOL
 
Last edited:
That doesn't contradict what @SJGardner said earlier. Before 2000, there was a lot of inconsistency about how colors were used to denote the political parties. Different networks had their own schemes. But starting around 2000, it become more standardized.

And, no, the parties didn't switch in the 80s. As this article discusses, the switch occurs between the 1860s and 1936.

When Did Democrats and Republicans Switch Platforms?

Sorry for the tangent but couldn't let the inaccuracies stand!
No one said it contradicts anything.
No one said they switched in the 80s.
:shrug:

:guffaw::guffaw::guffaw::guffaw::guffaw::guffaw:

I LOVE THIS!!!!

I've never actually seen 'beating a dead horse' shown literally in a post before. How did you do that?

(I would certainly use it in several instances.)
A version of it was very popular on the Star Trek Movie Forum back then :D
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top