• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 3x08 - "Surrender"

Engage!


  • Total voters
    243
If it looks like a Duck, quacks like a duck, and we are told it is a duck I'm not going to sit there and go "Well, technically the original D was destroyed and so only parts of it are genuine."

The intention is there and call me shallow but I think that's good enough for the story being told. The rest is technicalities.
Without the saucer the D looks a little like a duck. ;)
 
i hate you so damn much

Hawkeye-Pierce-Gif.gif
 
He's also won Hugo and Nebula awards.

They probably should have hired him to do something completely new with Star Trek. Even though originally Stewart had zero interest in revisiting TNG, that's what the fans wanted, so anything that wasn't Season 8 was doomed to be complained about on the internet.

Season 3 in a nutshell. I'm an old school TOS guy, so reuniting the TNG crew doesn't have the same impact for me, so I still see a lot of the same issues from S1/2 occuring this season.

I felt the same about episodes 7-8 and 2-3-4, there was a lot of redundant farting around in that nebula.

Then oddly enough, episode six feels unnecessarily crammed together, I think it would have worked better expanded into two episodes.

Honestly, they could have destroyed Vadik and the Shrike in the nebula, moved some of the character development beats from a condensed two episode 2-3-4 into a museum/Daystrom two-parter, as well as uncover what they did to Picard, the modified Changeling origin and the Data/Lore stuff in those episodes. This would tighten things considerably, and more importantly an eight episode season would have freed up a bunch of budget. Money that could have been spent to get off of Titan and have some location shooting by making Daystrom a planetside base or something.


At this point, they all feel like they're playing themselves, which I'm actually ok with. Of all the Trek casts, the TNG crew seems like they get along the best with each other, but that chemistry rarely came through on screen until this season.


Yeah, their whole affair should have been left in the "running out of ideas towards the end of a series' seventh season" dustbin next to Chakotay/Seven's.
Chabon made the difference for me I think. Season 3 just doesn't quite reach that level of influence or writing. It really wants to club you over the head by comparison. Not much subtlety.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top