Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 5x03 - "Jinaal"

[Phoenix219]

6. This one was fairly dull. The Akira and Gray stuff was dull. The Saru and the Vulcan lady was boring. The stuff with Michael, Book, and the Symbiote was ok--not particularly compelling but slightly less dull than the rest. It felt like this episode was just marking time. A bit worrying given that it's only the third episode.

The best part was Tilly putting Raynar in his place.

By best, you mean worst?

 

[Phoenix219]

Prepare for revived Shatner Kirk!
(Would fit with the 1701 appearance!)

AHH!! Thanks for putting an idea in my head that I am now in love with, and will be disappointed with it never happening! lmao. (which 1701 appearance are u referring to?)

Progenitor tech bringing back Kirk while Shat is still alive..... ending Discovery on the highest note imagineable? Yes Please!

 

[Phoenix219]

Am I a bad person if I want this to happen solely so I can watch the fan reaction?

(yes)

Just seeing a reference to him in PIC made me forgive TNG.

If Disco did this, I would never criticize anything about it ever again.

 

[NCC-73515]

AHH!! Thanks for putting an idea in my head that I am now in love with, and will be disappointed with it never happening! lmao. (which 1701 appearance are u referring to?)

Progenitor tech bringing back Kirk while Shat is still alive..... ending Discovery on the highest note imagineable? Yes Please!

You'll see

 

[Phoenix219]

It's the weakest of season 3 but I wouldn't go that far.

I love that you referred to it as season 3 and not 5, since the jump to the future is basically a new show.

 

[fireproof78]

Am I a bad person if I want this to happen solely so I can watch the fan reaction?

(yes)

Can someone tell me what Kirk would add to this show? Besides fan squees?

 

[137th Gebirg]

You mean that's not enough?

 

[fireproof78]

No.

 

[137th Gebirg]

 

[El Maestro]

Can someone tell me what Kirk would add to this show? Besides fan squees?

See? It hasn't even happened and I get to see the drama and hand wringing!

 

[fireproof78]

See? It hasn't even happened and I get to see the drama and hand wringing!

So...that's a "No," then?

 

[Quantum21]

AHH!! Thanks for putting an idea in my head that I am now in love with, and will be disappointed with it never happening! lmao. (which 1701 appearance are u referring to?)

Progenitor tech bringing back Kirk while Shat is still alive..... ending Discovery on the highest note imagineable? Yes Please!

I'd rather have programmable matter stuck in my eyeball than see Shat in modern Trek.

 

[Kzinti]

not much to say about this one other than Rayner is a pretty good character hope they don't kill him like shaw not that it matters since it's the last season but eh they could always bring him back as guest star for academy if he remain that strong of a character

7/10

 

[Mr. Laser Beam]

Maybe he makes it to the finale, and takes over for Burnham as captain.

For what it's worth, CKR has said that he would have been part of Season 6 if the show had not been cancelled.

 

[hbquikcomjamesl]

I liked it. Lots of character and relationship development. Lots of callbacks.