• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

So name a Star Trek moment that you just didn't "get".

I don't get why even on Voyager they still bring padds containing data ON FOOT, instead of say, send the 24th century equivalent of an email? That seems kinda stupid, like, I don't know, people dropping their guns and starting to fight with swords, fortunately we never see that kind of stuff, do we?

the worst example I can think of is in Good Shepherd
sure seeing the lower bowels of the ship is kind of neat, but they didn't need to manually carry a padd there to show that part of the ship. I message sent via the console and then we see the crewman down there respond to his console beeping that there is a message would have worked just as well
 
We had a thread around here not too long ago about the PADDs being silly. It gets even worse when we see the characters lugging around multiple PADDs or even a crate full of them. Or a desk filled with PADDs plus an active computer terminal.

Of course, you really want to get picky, why does Starfleet have different separate devices? Today, a smart phone can serve as a communicator, tricorder, and computer pad, all in one, yet in the 23rd and 24th centuries there are separate devices dedicated to each function.
 
Why does Data even speak to the computer, when he could communicate about a million times faster through a wireless connection, the way my computer is doing now with the internet? For the same reason we should never see Data tap consoles keys or look at a screen. Anything appearing on a screen could be sent much faster to his brain through a connection. Of course Data could also pilot the ship all by himself but that's another story.
 
He's trying to be more human by emulating the way humans interact with the computer. As to why the Borg ever have to press buttons on their console-columns is never explained, though.
 
He's trying to be more human by emulating the way humans interact with the computer. As to why the Borg ever have to press buttons on their console-columns is never explained, though.
They had better never explain it. Something tells me that the explanation would be completely stupid.
 
The Borg using consoles was something that started in Voyager, anyway. Well, technically First Contact, but at least that can be explained away as a by-product of the Enterprise only being partially assimilated. In Voyager we actually see Borg drones leaving their alcoves to man stations, complete with red alert alarms and everything.
 
The Borg using consoles was something that started in Voyager, anyway. Well, technically First Contact, but at least that can be explained away as a by-product of the Enterprise only being partially assimilated. In Voyager we actually see Borg drones leaving their alcoves to man stations, complete with red alert alarms and everything.

I never understood why the Borg had any small equipment separate from their bodies. Didn't they have hand weapons in TNG, in Descent? These are atypical Borg--but if the shields they have can be generated from their implants, why not weapons fire?


This one always bugged me. It's from TOS, The Deadly Years:


KIRK: He was scared! He saw the dead body and he ran out of the building and he was scared to death.
MCCOY: Yes, yes. Now that could be. Right. Scared. Heart beats faster, breathe gets short, and there's cold sweats and adrenaline flows. Adrenal activity. Now hold on Just a minute. There was something that I read once. It was ancient history, just after the atomic age. Used for radiation sickness. Adrenaline.
WALLACE: Doctor, hyronalin is the specific accepted for all radiation sickness.
MCCOY: Yes, yes. Now. But before, adrenaline. Highly promising. Early research, but they abandoned it when hyronalin was discovered.



What...The....F?

McCoy has JUST named the compound/agent he wants. Then, in the next breath, he clearly struggles to remember the word he had just said in the previous sentence. When he says the name "adrenaline" in the second place, he says it as if he hadn't just said the word (plus a variant of the word) moments before. I suppose we COULD say that this is an unusually good portrayal of the short-term memory loss and idea unconnectedness we see with senile dementia and Alzheimer's, but somehow it just doesn't feel that way to me. It's as if the writer had Alzheimer's for a moment!
 
Why use a proper digital camera when you have a mobile phone?

Well, it's possible that a given digital camera is better than the camera on a given phone.

Indeed.

There's an ages-old expression about photography that's just as valid today: "It's all about the glass".

Meaning, the lens (glass) plays a critical role in the quality of the image. You could have an eleventy-jillion-pixel pick-up device, but if the light is passing through crappy glass, the image suffers.

it's not uncommon for the lens itself to cost more than everything else in a camera set-up. I shoot video for a living and the Zeiss lens on my Sony production camera is longer than the camera body. I also have a couple of small consumer Sony camcorders I use as loaners, also with Zeiss lenses but I wouldn't think for a moment to use them, they just can't compare.

no matter what the phone makers want you to believe, I don't believe their glass isn that good.
 
I only use my iPhone camera to take 'emergency' pics if I've forgotten to bring my camera along. I wouldn't think of using it to take permanent ones I want to save. Real cameras are so much better.
 
The Borg using consoles was something that started in Voyager, anyway. Well, technically First Contact, but at least that can be explained away as a by-product of the Enterprise only being partially assimilated. In Voyager we actually see Borg drones leaving their alcoves to man stations, complete with red alert alarms and everything.

I never understood why the Borg had any small equipment separate from their bodies. Didn't they have hand weapons in TNG, in Descent? These are atypical Borg--but if the shields they have can be generated from their implants, why not weapons fire?


This one always bugged me. It's from TOS, The Deadly Years:


KIRK: He was scared! He saw the dead body and he ran out of the building and he was scared to death.
MCCOY: Yes, yes. Now that could be. Right. Scared. Heart beats faster, breathe gets short, and there's cold sweats and adrenaline flows. Adrenal activity. Now hold on Just a minute. There was something that I read once. It was ancient history, just after the atomic age. Used for radiation sickness. Adrenaline.
WALLACE: Doctor, hyronalin is the specific accepted for all radiation sickness.
MCCOY: Yes, yes. Now. But before, adrenaline. Highly promising. Early research, but they abandoned it when hyronalin was discovered.



What...The....F?

McCoy has JUST named the compound/agent he wants. Then, in the next breath, he clearly struggles to remember the word he had just said in the previous sentence. When he says the name "adrenaline" in the second place, he says it as if he hadn't just said the word (plus a variant of the word) moments before. I suppose we COULD say that this is an unusually good portrayal of the short-term memory loss and idea unconnectedness we see with senile dementia and Alzheimer's, but somehow it just doesn't feel that way to me. It's as if the writer had Alzheimer's for a moment!

It seems to me like they wanted to portray senility.
 
The Borg using consoles was something that started in Voyager, anyway. Well, technically First Contact, but at least that can be explained away as a by-product of the Enterprise only being partially assimilated. In Voyager we actually see Borg drones leaving their alcoves to man stations, complete with red alert alarms and everything.

I never understood why the Borg had any small equipment separate from their bodies. Didn't they have hand weapons in TNG, in Descent? These are atypical Borg--but if the shields they have can be generated from their implants, why not weapons fire?


This one always bugged me. It's from TOS, The Deadly Years:


KIRK: He was scared! He saw the dead body and he ran out of the building and he was scared to death.
MCCOY: Yes, yes. Now that could be. Right. Scared. Heart beats faster, breathe gets short, and there's cold sweats and adrenaline flows. Adrenal activity. Now hold on Just a minute. There was something that I read once. It was ancient history, just after the atomic age. Used for radiation sickness. Adrenaline.
WALLACE: Doctor, hyronalin is the specific accepted for all radiation sickness.
MCCOY: Yes, yes. Now. But before, adrenaline. Highly promising. Early research, but they abandoned it when hyronalin was discovered.



What...The....F?

McCoy has JUST named the compound/agent he wants. Then, in the next breath, he clearly struggles to remember the word he had just said in the previous sentence. When he says the name "adrenaline" in the second place, he says it as if he hadn't just said the word (plus a variant of the word) moments before. I suppose we COULD say that this is an unusually good portrayal of the short-term memory loss and idea unconnectedness we see with senile dementia and Alzheimer's, but somehow it just doesn't feel that way to me. It's as if the writer had Alzheimer's for a moment!

The adrenaline was confirmed as the probable solution from two different angles: from it being in Chekov's system, and it being what was used to treat radiation sickness in the atomic age. As kirkfan essentially pointed out, McCoy here was his senior and degrading version. McCoy was probably just trying to be sure that he was remembering his "ancient history" correctly, while suffering memory lapses. Not a problem, and in fact appropriate.
 
Yes, what I find actually more incredible is that a declining McCoy was able to do any progress at all before it was too late. But I guess we have to suspend disbelief there.
 
Christopher Pike getting mowed down like cattle for no good reason in STID. Just kill a main character needlessly, why don't you?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top