• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 3x05 - "Imposters"

Engage!


  • Total voters
    256
Terry said that shot of the Intrepid raising back into frame after Ro crashes her shuttle was inspired by similar shots in shows/movies where someone would get punched and just get right back up again.
 
The real question on my mind is...
Why did Ro hand Picard Kira Nerys's ear ring and not her own?

Things that make you go...hmmmm.

Another surprise appearance, perhaps?
Possibly just an earring Ro used to store all that info. Would Picard have recognized the original earring?
 
And saying that NYC is not the entire East Coast is exactly my point. The original post said Earth was on the edge of the Alpha Quadrant and therefore the edge of the Alpha quadrant can’t be that far away.
I thought our Sun, "Sol" was the demarcation for the border between the {(α = Alpha) & (β = Beta)} Quadrants

Earth and the rest of our Solar system just orbits our sun and moves back & forth between parts of the (α & β Quadarants)
 
I thought our Sun, "Sol" was the demarcation for the border between the {(α = Alpha) & (β = Beta)} Quadrants

Earth and the rest of our Solar system just orbits our sun and moves back & forth between parts of the (α & β Quadarants)
Yes but the point is that the Alpha Quadrant also has a border with the Gamma Quadrant and a border with the Galactic Barrier so saying they’re on the edge of the alpha quadrant doesn’t mean they are near earth (which was the original complaint I was addressing).
 
Good episode. I get a bit tired of the Worf battle thing. He's the worst pacifist I've ever seen.

Also, am I the only one who wasn't really fazed by Ro's sacrifice?
 
Last edited:
She had more to do and more character development before the credits of episode one than she had had in all the TNG movies combined. Shocking.

Yeah. Much as I love First Contact the moment where Beverly says "He's the captain" and Lily has to go into the ready room to tear Picard a new one literally makes me want to scream every time I see it (and I get it from a narrative point of view but grr!)
 
Good episode. I get a bit tired of the Worf battle thing. He's the worst pacifist I've ever seen.

Also, am I the only one who wasn't really phased by Ro's sacrifice?
I don’t think the pacifist thing made it into the show. Was a comedy trailer bit.
 
Good episode. I get a bit tired of the Worf battle thing. He's the worst pacifist I've ever seen.

Also, am I the only one who wasn't really phased by Ro's sacrifice?
He is not a pacifist. I took that to be a joke, but threads are running all over the place like he is. He prefers not having to fight. That's it.

I didn't really care that she died. I was pumped to see her and have her and Picard have a talk. She and Picard got closure because of it and that was the part that was good. Everything about her scenes were good except for the goofy bomb that gave Picard just enough time to tell her he sees her and for her to blow up a nacelle.

To the people who have been posting about the Vulcan gangster and how they think it is wrong. Do you think their logic is genetic? With a population the size of of the Vulcan civilization, isn't it likely that parts of it would evolve in different ways or a Vulcan kid gets separated from his parents due to something awful happening and ending up on the streets? No species is uniform in their beliefs and experiences. There are an infinite number of ways that a single Vulcan could have come to be a gangster.
 
Phased how? Like completely unbothered.

I felt slightly moved, but I wasn't angry or sad. I was taken by the impressive scene.

"Phased" as in "fazed" (i.e. brain fart typo). Yeah, it did nothing for me. Everyone is all over Twitter saying how much of a tear-jerker it was. I guess Ro just wasn't that kind of character for me.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top