Kurtzman Out?
- Thread starter Long Syntax
- Start date
So, I'm confused. Is he in or is he out? Asking for a friend.
Doc: Go in and order a Pepsi and wait for a guy named Griff.
Marty: Griff?
Doc: Right. Griff's going to ask you about tonight. "Are you in or out?" Tell him you are out! Whatever he says, whatever happens, say "no!", you're not interested. Then leave, come back here, and wait for me.
Last edited:
... and we all know how that went...
It’s 2019, more like 10 every minute
Has anybody actually said NO in this thread yet?
If not, then NO, Kurtzman has not been fired and is Not OUT.
"Jetson! YOU'RE FIRED!!!!"
the pessimist and realist in me suspects the real reason they don't like Kurtzman isn't going to make them like Chabon any better.
They like him for not being Kurtzman. When he releases his Star Trek they will hate him.
The spin is kurtzman out. Chabon in. Even though kurtzman was never showrunner of Picard
Every indication is that Chabon is every bit the "SJW," "libtard," identity-politicking guy that Dumbcock and the like fear.
In other words, he could be the very type of guy who tends to make great Star Trek.
In other words, he could be the very type of guy who tends to make great Star Trek.
I'd dread the day new Star Trek is made that they actually like. Then I'd know something is wrong.
Not something you have to worry about.
That kind of person seldom creates.
I don’t want to do the math, but how much of Berman era Trek was “good”?
Not that Kurtzman is going anywhere anytime soon, but I also don’t think he’s going to get as a long a leash as Berman did.
Hmmm... My opinion only...
TNG-1... Mixed
TNG-2... Okay
TNG-3... Good
TNG-4... Good
TNG-5... Mixed
TNG-6... Great
TNG-7... Mixed
DS9-1... Okay
DS9-2... Good
DS9-3... Good
DS9-4... Great
DS9-5... Great
DS9-6... Great
DS9-7... Great
VOY-1... Okay
VOY-2... Mixed
VOY-3... Mixed
VOY-4... Good
VOY-5... Mixed
VOY-6... Mixed
VOY-7... Okay
ENT-1... Eh
ENT-2... Zzzzz
ENT-3... "Good" (not my cup of tea, but even I can see it's better than S1 and S2)
ENT-4... Okay
Good to Great Seasons: 11
Okay: 5
Mixed: 7
Forget It: 2
So, basically, when it comes down to the combination of what I think is good and I like, it's:
TNG-3
TNG-4
TNG-6
DS9-2
DS9-3
DS9-4
DS9-5
DS9-6
DS9-7
VOY-4
Last edited:
Is Kurtzman shit-canned? Let's ask Jonathan Frakes:
Guess that settles it.
Guess that settles it.
Is Kurtzman in the soup line yet?!
Problem being that ratings went down every single season. We even lost a portion of DS9 during the tail end of its run because the cost was more than the local station could reel in from commercial time.
Problem being that ratings went down every single season. We even lost a portion of DS9 during the tail end of its run because the cost was more than the local station could reel in from commercial time.
Similar threads
