• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 1x04 - "The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    332
Right Wing Star Trek fans doesn't make much sense to me. It's like saying liberal Infowars fan.
At the very strong risk of being flamed for this: The conservative mindset is nothing more complicated than a series of calculated knee-jerks. It is entirely possible -- in fact, should be expected -- for conservatives to hold multiple contradictory views on issues that affect them personally, simply because they are never required to express those contradictory views AT THE SAME TIME.

No joke. I know a lady who once went on a six minute rant about how Barrack Obama shouldn't be trusted with any real authority because being mixed meant he didn't have a clear sense of his social standing in America and that made him dangerous. When two hours later I pointed out that her husband was mixed, she looked me dead in the eye and asked "Why do you say that like it's a bad thing? That's a very negative attitude!"

I mention this because this lady is also a die-hard trekkie and has been for many years. And she, like many trekkies -- and many conservatives -- has a MASSIVE capacity for cognitive consonance that almost borders on schizophrenia.
 
Yeah, that was a great episode. It also had Precious Cargo, which is certainly in my bottom 5 worst hours of Trek. I think only Spock's Brain and Profit and Lace are worse.

Profit and Lace is so bad, and kinda offensive. I also think Voy's "The Fight" sucked.
 
Bold prediction: Burnham's and Voq's stories are paralleling one-another.

Voq was T'Kuvma's protege, Burnham was Georgiou's. Burnham was disgraced; Voq was exiled. Burnham had to get in with Lorca; Voq apparently has to get in with the matriarchs of House Mokai. They'll both "train for battle" now against one-another and they'll ultimately come to an understanding and end the season together against Kol and possibly a Federation adversary too.
 
Burnham Killed T'Kuvma, and Voq ate Georgou.

Voq was disowned and Burnham was orphaned.

Michael has a boy's name, and Voq has a girls name.
 
Humans do not enslave animals for meat any more, unless that doesn't happen for almost another century... Unless that is just something Riker says to pick up alien strange.
 
Not a lot of ecology left standing after World War III.

Although, the Vulcans would have faked some ecology while rebuilding for us.

What a bunch of stand up blokes. :)
 
feastedonit.png


"We found T'Nank's body ... by the river; it's waters red with blood. Which of us had slain him, no one could say for certain. So ... we cut out his heart and all three of us feasted on it together."

Who has a problem with Klingon cannibalism again?
 
Unless you have perfect information on the enemy you have no idea what might given them a tactical advantage.

Hence they would have scuttled the ship.

Of course this is the same show where a security chief just killed herself by refusing to turn her head six inches check and the biosign monitor to see if the creature was actually asleep.

If anyone watched Dunkirk recently, they might have remembered the Spitfire pilot shooting his flare gun into the wreck of his Spitfire, and the plane subsequently burning up, to prevent the Germans from recovering anything.

And that was just a regular fighter plane with nothing special aboard.

Scuttling your ship/plane is standard operating procedure for anyone in the military, and that the writers of Star Trek apparently didn’t know this (or address WHY it wasn’t scuttled) is a huge oversight.
 
If anyone watched Dunkirk recently, they might have remembered the Spitfire pilot shooting his flare gun into the wreck of his Spitfire, and the plane subsequently burning up, to prevent the Germans from recovering anything.

And that was just a regular fighter plane with nothing special aboard.

Scuttling your ship/plane is standard operating procedure for anyone in the military, and that the writers of Star Trek apparently didn’t know this (or address WHY it wasn’t scuttled) is a huge oversight.

So Tiger 131 shouldn't be at Bovington Tank Museum?

In any case, the scene at the ready room on Shenzhou showed that the place was pretty much stripped clean, so clearly someone made a sweep after the battle to remove anything useful. Plus the telescope made it off the ship somehow. I don't think the Klingons would mail that to Burnham. I guess Starfleet figured that it wasn't worth to scuttle an old science vessel.
 
Oh it died with Enterprise alright. And not a day goes by without me being grateful that they somehow managed to resurrect it after that steaming pile of poo killed it.

I'm loving Discovery so far. It's bold, intrepid, exciting, and concerned with inner exploration in a way that Star Trek has very rarely been. This episode was the best one yet. Can't wait for next week.
Yet you like discovery but not enterprise, you fucking haters make me want to kill myself.

enterprise is more trek then discovery, also fuck all the Voyager haters too.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top