• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Thor: Love and Thunder grade and discussion thread

How do you rate Love and Thunder?


  • Total voters
    88
idk, shows Ethan's independent and likes a challenge, shows when things get tough he becomes focused, and as the franchise becomes more action oriented establishes him to be very athletic.

I get free climbing but I've never understood how they get back down, I don't really get the "free descent", I think I'd need that helicopter to get me down if I could ever somehow manage to get up there lol.
 
Now I wilm end this with a franchise that HAS gotten it right for over 30 years. The mission impossible films have been solid all the way through. :techman:
[/QUOTE]
For me, Mission Impossible is one of the few movie franchises that has actually gotten better as it's gone on.
 
For me, Mission Impossible is one of the few movie franchises that has actually gotten better as it's gone on.[/QUOTE]

Yes they have indeed gotten better. But I like all of them. They aren "solid" to varying degrees for me.
 
idk, shows Ethan's independent and likes a challenge, shows when things get tough he becomes focused, and as the franchise becomes more action oriented establishes him to be very athletic.
Which means jack to the film itself. "Ethan is tough" is not why I watch these films. So, sorry, it doesn't hold up as "Hey, this is exciting. You should keep watching." Because, all I am at the end of it is bored.
 
^ You said the scene doesn't tell you anything about the character, I laid out my case, feel free to disagree. I guess I can't argue that it didn't tell YOU anything about the character but nonetheless.
 
^ You said the scene doesn't tell you anything about the character, I laid out my case, feel free to disagree. I guess I can't argue that it didn't tell YOU anything about the character but nonetheless.
I can only go by my feelings on the film. I have no doubt that I could sit down and break it a part and analyze each movement. No doubt the cinematic language will give hints as well.

However, since I approach film in that I am watching this and want to learn something about the character and how that informs them going forward in the film. In that instance, in the moment, it did not resonate for me on a character level. There's nothing there for me to feel like I can grab on to and go, "Yes, I understand this character and wish to see more."
 
I thought the goats were mildly funny at first then started to get a bit annoying. But the scene of them crashing the longship through Zeus' skylight to Guns N Roses was absolutely hilarious and completely won me over again.
Goats were the overused gag as the joke gag. I love that gag. More goats plz.
 
I can only go by my feelings on the film. I have no doubt that I could sit down and break it a part and analyze each movement. No doubt the cinematic language will give hints as well.

However, since I approach film in that I am watching this and want to learn something about the character and how that informs them going forward in the film. In that instance, in the moment, it did not resonate for me on a character level. There's nothing there for me to feel like I can grab on to and go, "Yes, I understand this character and wish to see more."
I basically watch Tom Cruise movies for the stunts. And that was a good stunt, since he actually did that (but with a rope).
 
3 was the rest since the majority hated 2. It was necessary, and quite good on its own. It also made the later ones possible, and they are all great.
3 was more interesting than 2, but when I rewatched it I found it to be very unsatisfying and more than a few holes that I did not like.
I basically watch Tom Cruise movies for the stunts. And that was a good stunt, since he actually did that (but with a rope).
And that's the difference-I don't care about stunts. They are good for in the moment "WOW" factor, which is fine for first viewing. After that, more meat is preferred from the characters. MI 2 loves it's stunts...and I don't.
 
And that's the difference-I don't care about stunts. They are good for in the moment "WOW" factor, which is fine for first viewing. After that, more meat is preferred from the characters. MI 2 loves it's stunts...and I don't.
So that scene did tell you what needed to know about the movie. ;)
 
Not sure if serious...:shrug:
kKOlEaH.jpg


And if so I just had flash backs to discussions I had in high school with a friend obsessed with Woo and over the top stunts. All I can say is there has got to be a character for me to grab on to for a stunt to sell.
The film has a diverse stable of compelling characters worthy of grabbing on to. Ethan Hunt, Naya Nordoff Hall, Sean Ambrose, Hugh Stamp, John C McCloy. I find your comment about a lack thereof simply astounding
 
Last edited:
The film has a dearth of compelling characters worthy of grabbing on to. Ethan Hunt, Naya Nordoff Hall, Sean Ambrose, Hugh Stamp, John C McCloy. I find your comment about a lack thereof simply astounding
Well, I like to astound at least once person a day. Congratulations!
 
kKOlEaH.jpg



The film has a dearth of compelling characters worthy of grabbing on to. Ethan Hunt, Naya Nordoff Hall, Sean Ambrose, Hugh Stamp, John C McCloy. I find your comment about a lack thereof simply astounding

I'm not 100% sure what you're going for. Are you defending the film? Because a "dearth" of compelling characters is literally a "lack of." Which, honestly, would be my feeling. It's easily my least favorite of the franchise, from the style through the score. But everyone's mileage varies.

I get free climbing but I've never understood how they get back down, I don't really get the "free descent", I think I'd need that helicopter to get me down if I could ever somehow manage to get up there lol.

Or Spock to show up in gravity boots to distract you.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top