• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Omega Glory...

I understand, but watching a tv show requires suspension of disbelief that the characters themselves don't or can't have, so it's much easier to make such leaps for the viewer than the characters in the situation.
This is a powerful point I hadn't thought of! You're right. When people see some thing incongruous, they freeze. Critics of President Bush criticized him for freezing and failing to react when someone whispered into his ear that two commercial jets crashed into a buildings. If it had been a familiar mode of attack, e.g. a plane or missile, maybe he would have reacted faster.

When someone tried to break into my house twenty years ago, a neighbor confronted the would-be buglers. The police officer who investigated said that is normal. Most people see a crime and thing, "wait, two guys with a crowbar prying a window? That just can't be what it looks like!" As a cop, though, she said she sees a steady stream of them and knows it probably is just what it looks like.

So if I came across clothes with crystals in it and I were not in a scifi or horror TV show, I would not think "oh no, something must have sucked all the water out of them." I would just think "this is weird".

The best correlation I can think if is when Spock was reluctant to say the silicon nodules were Horta eggs even though he suspected right away. Bones even mocked his conclusion as impossible and a fantasy. But who didn't think Spock was 100% correct as soon as he mentioned it?
I really liked that. I thought they handled that really well in the episode, making it clear that any reasonable person would think Si monster eggs would sound crazy.


Portrayed as an excellent doctor, McCoy's first thought should have been, "Oh Oh, we're in trouble" at first sight on the uniforms with white crystals in them. I guess he also was lulled into group think that since the medical tricorder sensors did not detect the pathogen, there was no commutable danger.
I would also add that McCoy wouldn't have needed to figure out it was communicable. It could have been a burst of radiation or some chemical contaminant, not necessarily a disease. But I agree McCoy and the rest of them should have known they were at risk of whatever happened to the other crew. I think they did know, but the theory is these guys have the right stuff to explore dangerous situations and don't scare easily.
 
The difference with uniforms and crystals all over the place is that in the real world there is no such disease or force that could do that to human tissue so maybe Kirk and crew were right to not suspect anything at first! :eek:
JB
 
RONALD TRACEY RETCON ALERT:

During a previous away mission he was taken over by a parasitic life form which used him as a host to personally drain the life of his crew in the manner we've seen.

Mmm...on second thought...

Nah. He was nucking futs...
 
Like Matt Decker before him he couldn't handle the fact that his entire crew were killed up on the Exeter, so thought that one good thing to come out of it was bringing eternal life to the citizens of the galaxy, until that too was revealed to be just a figment of his imagination and then oh yeah after that he became a little nucking futs! :techman:
JB
 
Were they making a lot of noise?
It was in the middle of the day while I was at work.
My neighbor obviously knew break-ins happen, but he didn't expect to witness one on any given day. Similarly in the Star Trek universe, the characters know there is weird science fiction stuff happening all the time, but they don't expect to see it any given day.
 
It was in the middle of the day while I was at work.
My neighbor obviously knew break-ins happen, but he didn't expect to witness one on any given day. Similarly in the Star Trek universe, the characters know there is weird science fiction stuff happening all the time, but they don't expect to see it any given day.

I was actually referring to your being spellchecked: burglar/bugler.
 
Like Matt Decker before him he couldn't handle the fact that his entire crew were killed up on the Exeter, so thought that one good thing to come out of it was bringing eternal life to the citizens of the galaxy, until that too was revealed to be just a figment of his imagination and then oh yeah after that he became a little nucking futs! :techman:
JB
Matt Decker goes a little crazy after losing his crew in The Doomsday Machine. :crazy:
Ron Tracey goes a little crazy after losing his crew in The Omega Glory. :crazy:
Jim Kirk screws a beautiful babe after losing his crew in The Mark of Gideon. :nyah:
 
He did manage to penetrate its ancient gaping chasm but his shuttle couldn't handle the explosions.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top