• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Strange New Worlds 1x02 - "Children of The Comet"

Rate the Episode

  • 10 - Excellent

    Votes: 68 26.9%
  • 9

    Votes: 96 37.9%
  • 8

    Votes: 48 19.0%
  • 7

    Votes: 26 10.3%
  • 6

    Votes: 7 2.8%
  • 5

    Votes: 4 1.6%
  • 4

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • 3

    Votes: 2 0.8%
  • 2

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 1 - Terrible

    Votes: 1 0.4%

  • Total voters
    253
  • This poll will close: .
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Alien.jpg

ALIEN: Quick! It's that photographer from National Geographic! Look mysterious. We'll get the cover for sure!


fau.jpg

UHURA: Did you give Ortegas that non-regulation haircut?

card.jpg

ORTEGAS: A Cardassian warship just dropped out of warp. Gul Dukat is requesting permission to come aboard. I recommend we launch photon torpedoes and blow his shuttlecraft to shit!

pike.jpg

PIKE: Who???
 
For all the Vulcan telepath talk, they're strong enough telepaths that Sarek was able to cause significant emotional issues amongst the D's crew when he came onboard.
 
View attachment 27852

"Hey...that guy just flipped me off!"

"Are you sure?"

"His hands are clearly from another race and world but YES!!"

View attachment 27853

HEMMER: "No, Cadet, I don't know what a Bagel Bite is."

SPOCK: "Consider yourself fortunate."

View attachment 27854

Where will you be when your first plate of Saurian spice pie comes back to haunt you?

View attachment 27855

"Would this be a bad time to tell everyone Hemmer left the emergency brake on?"
 
alien-jpg.27852


ALIEN: Quick! It's that photographer from National Geographic! Look mysterious. We'll get the cover for sure!
Well done.
X4a9lHb.jpg
 
After the canon defying first episode with Spock and T'Pring almost hitting it off, a new doctor instead of dr Boyce just because and Chapel in the crew, I couldn't finish the second episode of this garbage. The Fakeprise with its bright, white corridors are annoying as it is and the miscast actress for Uhura aside, the Prime Directive was introduced in the first episode but now they was about to break it before they realized what the comet really was.

I do like Anson Mount as Pike and the new Spock is good, but I decided to put on some real Star Trek instead.
You are in the elite 0.5% Club in the "Rate the Episode" poll. Congratulations! It's gotta be lonely there, but Gene would be proud that someone is taking on those "bright, white corridors" that so brazenly shine against his vision of the future! :lol:
 
That's how I hope to feel when I finally see this. DISCOVERY turned out to be such a disapointment. I hope this show is better.
I like a lot about Discovery, especially now that they've leapt forward, and S4 seems to be ending really nicely. But there's so much persistent grief-filler that it saps my morale. A more positive iteration is welcome. Hell, I'm finding LD more likeable than DSC.
 
That's how I hope to feel when I finally see this. DISCOVERY turned out to be such a disapointment. I hope this show is better.

As someone who doesn't like Discovery and feels it pretty much fell over its own pants right out of the gate (episode reference!) and continued to fall over them, am not crazy about LD and only take Picard because of, well, Picard. (Haven't watched Prodigy) SNW feels like home, in the ballpark, and just a Trek I've wanted since ENT ended.
 
I am liking this new show a lot more than I though I would so far. It’s kind of giving me what I want without my realizing that I wanted it.

  • The characters and chemistry have hit really well right out if the gate
  • I love Pike. Fantastic stuff from Anson Mount. He has a weird way of being an “everyman” Captain who also commands absolute respect in a very believable way. I also really like the leftover fear and confusion he has to deal with after his premonitions on Boreth.
  • The new Uhura is absolutely magnetic. This was a great showcase episode for both the beloved legacy character and the new actress.
  • Everything looks amazing. The sets, props, uniforms, makeup, vfx….it’s all a feast for a Trekkie’s eyes.
  • I have to admit that I’ve quickly come to embrace Ethan Peck as Spock. I always tried to convince myself that Quinto was a good Spock, but Peck has it nailed down pretty tight.
It’s waaaaay too early to declare SNW in a particular ranking with other franchise series. That said, it’s like they took some of the best things about TOS and modernized it just enough to still have the right feel but not over-do it…and I am admittedly really digging it right now. Both of these episodes have been highly enjoyable, I like all the characters so far, and the music and visuals are just too much awesomeness.

8.5/10
 
As someone who doesn't like Discovery and feels it pretty much fell over its own pants right out of the gate (episode reference!) and continued to fall over them, am not crazy about LD and only take Picard because of, well, Picard. (Haven't watched Prodigy) SNW feels like home, in the ballpark, and just a Trek I've wanted since ENT ended.
I feel fortunate that I've managed to appreciate all five current Trek shows, in their own way, but only SNW so far really feels like classic Trek. Let's see where this goes.
 
The TOS-like music in some scenes of the premiere episode almost had me giddy. They really did their homework going into this series.
 
SNW-S1E2-94.jpg

UHURA: I speak thirty-seven languages. Asspay eethay altsay eesplay. Do you want me to translate for you?

SNW-S1E2-97.jpg

SNW-S1E2-284.jpg

THE SHEPHERD: Our sensors detected mesquite. Do you have any extra ribs? We want ribs. We're sick to death of Shepherd's Pie.

SNW-S1E2-575.jpg

SPOCK: Remember, Cadet Uhura, before you open any hailing frequencies, you must first know the exact location of the mute button.



SNW-S1E2-547.jpg

ALIENS: He is the Kwisatz Haderach!
 
I feel fortunate that I've managed to appreciate all five current Trek shows, in their own way, but only SNW so far really feels like classic Trek. Let's see where this goes.

I love DSC and PIC for not being classic Star Trek. And I think I love SNW for being very much classic Star Trek.

It’s like I can appreciate all of them because they ARE different. If we had 3 series that were all like SNW, we’d be back in the burnout mode of the late 90’s.
 
I love DSC and PIC for not being classic Star Trek. And I think I love SNW for being very much classic Star Trek.

It’s like I can appreciate all of them because they ARE different. If we had 3 series that were all like SNW, we’d be back in the burnout mode of the late 90’s.

Well put! It would also make SNW stand out less if every show had the same tone, vibe and style. IDIC is alive in the Star Trek franchise more than ever before.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top