Don't forget Doctor Who, You gotta' include Doctor Who to make it the decisive (or maybe it should be divisive) angst trifecta!
Spoilers Star Trek: Prodigy 1x03 - "Starstruck"
- Thread starter Commander Richard
- Start date
Don't forget Doctor Who, You gotta' include Doctor Who to make it the decisive (or maybe it should be divisive) angst trifecta!
Who?Don't forget Doctor Who, You gotta' include Doctor Who to make it the decisive (or maybe it should be divisive) angst trifecta!
Give a hoot, don't pollute!
Be Kind & Rewind!
If the van's a-rockin', don't come knockin'!
I thought this was a decent episode, and had a more episodic feel...which I love.
I finally watched this today, and I really enjoyed it.
It was fun getting to see more of the Protostar, and getting to see more of Holo Janeway. The vehicle replicator was a pretty cool new addition to a Starfleet ship, and could be useful given how often the shuttles crash or are destroyed.
Dal's refusal to ask Janeway for help was a little annoying, but he is a cocky kid, so it isn't totally outrageous for him to act that way. I gave it an 8.
It was fun getting to see more of the Protostar, and getting to see more of Holo Janeway. The vehicle replicator was a pretty cool new addition to a Starfleet ship, and could be useful given how often the shuttles crash or are destroyed.
Dal's refusal to ask Janeway for help was a little annoying, but he is a cocky kid, so it isn't totally outrageous for him to act that way. I gave it an 8.
It’s cute. I love the animation. It’s so colorful and has a nice energy to it. The storyline so far is ok. The characters are likable. My kids seem to enjoy it. We’ve made a point of having Thursday night be “Prodigy family night” like we did with The Mandalorian on Fridays. That in itself is cool.
Good times.
Good times.
"She sniffed. “This is the post-nerd-closet world, Harry. It’s okay to like both.”" Ghost Story, Jim Butcher
7/10.
A lot of this show depends on the characters. I wouldn't say Dal's egotistical attempt to blindly fake his way through captaincy is entirely out of character, here -- but it's a lot more grating when there are other lives than his own at stake. And given how much of the episode is shaped by this, I found myself kinda gritting my teeth. That said, everything else here works.
Dal is definitely the weak link so far of the series but they have time to tone him down.
My favorite character so far is Rok-Tahk.
Unlike most of the others, she's not an annoying little shit. And I can definitely see her joining Starfleet.
Plus, who knew that a huge imposing rock creature could be so damn...CUTE?
Unlike most of the others, she's not an annoying little shit. And I can definitely see her joining Starfleet.
Plus, who knew that a huge imposing rock creature could be so damn...CUTE?
You know what I meant. Twice now they played the Janeway on a soapbox speech about the virtues of the Federation. True or not, enough is enough. Put the club away.
It's not propaganda if it's true.
Or, to rephrase: Janeway's "propaganda" about the Federation is infinitely more tolerable than Dal's propaganda about being an immature little twerp.
Or, to rephrase: Janeway's "propaganda" about the Federation is infinitely more tolerable than Dal's propaganda about being an immature little twerp.
This is a show introducing people to the concept of the Federation. It's going to be repeated, especially since these characters have no reason to trust the hologram.
It's not propaganda if it's true.
Or, to rephrase: Janeway's "propaganda" about the Federation is infinitely more tolerable than Dal's propaganda about being an immature little twerp.
The most effective lies are the ones that are mostly true. In fact, it's even more effective if you only say true things while omitting some important detail, or give disproportionate importance to some parts while minimizing others.
IOW, you can propagandize without saying a single outright lie.
Any particular reason you think the Federation is so evil now?
Similar threads
- Poll
