The transition from Hunter to Mount....Mount's expression was almost as if Pike felt something. Kind of a 'What just happened here?' moment. Reminded me of Guinan in Yesterday's Enterprise.
Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 2x08 - "If Memory Serves"
- Thread starter Commander Richard
- Start date
My first 10. Loved it. Still dizzy from my Trek high. I knew it would be special based on that great intro with scenes from the Cage. The writers love Star Trek as much as I do.
TOS Stardates? No they didn't. They were random the entire run.
Probably the later.
It's where ever the writers say it is.
I never thought of that, but you're right, it's possible she only thinks she wiped them out in her Universe. That said, Talosians Illusions weren't 'All Powerful as evidenced in te Discovery Shuttle landing sequence; and in the original TOS "The Cage/The Menagerie" episodes Pike manages to hold on to a Talosian who's projecting the illusion of being a powerful alien creature and then there's the line from Pike of:
http://www.chakoteya.net/StarTrek/1.htm
So yeah Talosian illusions came be overcome. I do like to believe if she did wipe them out, it was NOT as easy as she seems to claim in this episode, and a lot of ships/lives were sacrificed.
Last edited:
He didn't lick his lips when talking to Saru, so no.I find it continuing to be fascinating how Pike is just as a 'Context is King' as even Mirror Lorca was. One minute he's giving his newly cheekily snarky first officer a dressing down and telling him to 'go by the book' in future and by the end of the ep he's disobeying a direct order. Are we sure this isn't Mirror Pike.
Too much nostalgia for me to properly judge this. Burnham and Spock's estrangement was a bit of a let down. Expected they could think of something more. They used Kirk's Enterprise during the flashback at the beginning. The music was too TOSy too. They could have edited a more serious flashback from 'the Cage'.
He logged a trip to Starbase 11 for repairs and had some engine trouble along the way - what's so strange here?
Think logically, would not it be dangerous for a society based on logic to share the same planet with emotional beings? Vulcans can always twist the logic any way they want
TOS Stardates were decided in the writing stage, and generally stagger upwards as the series progresses. There's some wonkiness, as some scripts were held over and some rushed into production.
TAS Stardates were a little more crazier, with one date in the 1000s and one in the 7000s, but outside of these unexplained extremes, follows the TOS style.
The TOS movies are pretty sequential, going from the 7000s to the 9000s over the course of six movies.
The TNG era was when they came up with a pretty solid system that is somewhat decipherable. These are the stardates used in all 24th century shows and movies and most online calculators.
Enterprise didn't use stardates, just regular Gregorian dates.
The Kelvin movies also use Gregorian dates, just in a Stardate format, which is by far the easiest way to convert.
Discovery, though, goes back to a TOS style, but is much more randomized than TOS ever was. METMTSMGM was in SD 2137, but next week, SVPPB, was in SD 1308. The show began on SD 1207, but Point of Light a few weeks ago was SD 1029. The show is written and produced in sequential order, and could have had a solid clad system, but chose a more chaotic, indecipherable one to "match" TOS.
Indeed. I think the reason this opening resonated so much, was precisely because of how much a statement it is. The direct, hard cut from Jeffrey Hunter's Pike to Anson Mount has probably done a more effective and better job at putting this entire show into the larger Star Trek tapestry than all the previous episodes and references before combined. We now know exactly how this show relates to the other ones - not just on a story level, but even it's approach to canon and aesthetics.
Also - it's completely bonkers and unexpected. The absolute opposite of "playing it safe". And I like that. Now let's have a musical episode down the line.
As for the future - I still have a hard-time reconciling Burnham as a "real" step-sister with Spock. When re-watching TOS, this part will probably not go into my larger head-canon considerations - Nimoy-Spock will for me stand on it's own, not connected to Burnham (even though Burnham clearly exists). But everytime we see Pike and Vina? I'll absolutely include this episode into their larger history. Head-canon is weird, and I make my own rules.
Rules, or Rahuls, as the case may be...Head-canon is weird, and I make my own rules.
Hey, I'm sure not everyone in the MU finds Kelpian tasty, just as not everyone on Earth enjoys the taste of goat.
I did think the TOS theme became jarring as the recap went along. I'm a sucker for anything TOS, but the jazzy theme wasn't really the right tone for clips from a serious episode. Kinda undermined the drama. (And could give people who haven't seen the Cage the wrong idea about what it's like.)
So, does showing the TOS Enterprise in her original glory put the whole "DSC has to be 25 percent different because of reasons, the Illuminati and chem trails" thing to rest?
That said, I'm usually reluctant to award a 10, but this was a solid 10. When an episode pivots me so much between screaming, tears and laughter ... well, just take a bow, DSC.
This 70s-era Trekkie was very happy.
That said, I'm usually reluctant to award a 10, but this was a solid 10. When an episode pivots me so much between screaming, tears and laughter ... well, just take a bow, DSC.
This 70s-era Trekkie was very happy.
Last edited:
They only used 75% of the screen space.
Similar threads
- Poll
