• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 2x01 - "Brother"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    316
same here, when they came up with gay couples in tv-ads they weren't nice they just had found out that gay couples are nearly always dinks, and dinks got more money than traditional families.

the few cro-magnons who stopped buying stuff they had bought for 20 years were easily replaced by people delighted to be finally recognized.
What does dink mean?
 
The silly thing about the complaint about PC casting is that naysayers seem to think CBS is only doing that out of trying to appear altruistic for liberals and SJW, when the truth is that it's really just all about money. If diverse casting has proven anything, it's that it appeals to a larger group of audiences, thus more people are likely to watch it. It's a huge part of why THE FAST AND THE FURIOUS franchise has become so big internationally because of its diverse casting.
Money was the reason we got Sulu and Uhura in the first place. Someone figured out non-whites spend money, too!
 
Didn't I read somewhere that it was the network's idea to have a black character, not Gene? Or am I thinking of something else?
 
Heaven forbid they try to appeal to more people and grow their fanbase, thereby increasing their sales. Heaven forbid they move with the times and acknowledge diversity and representation in their new products. Heaven forbid they stop solely catering to only a certain group of people that want to gate-keep things.

I'm glad the film and TV industry are finally getting it, that they'll attract more revenue and more viewers if they don't ignore what women, PoC, and LGBTQ viewers might prefer to see in their entertainment media.
 
Didn't I read somewhere that it was the network's idea to have a black character, not Gene? Or am I thinking of something else?
IIRC it was the the sponsors who requested the studios and networks add people of color to their shows. Not just Star Trek, but many others as well. There is a pretty large uptick of nonwhite characters in Star Trek's "classmates" in the mid sixties. The Cage is pretty white. WNMHGB has at least one non-white character and by the time we get to TOS proper there's Uhura, Sulu and many background characters of color.
didn't he 'know' her before?
Well I'm sure it was Gene who came up with making the character female and casting an "old friend" in the part.
 
Have we seen Burnham's quarters since she got her rank back? She's not still bunking with Tilly?

The quarters were the same she shared with Tilly last season, although in Runaway, Tilly seemed to have her own quarters, which was a redress of the same one. Burnham had holographic candles in her quarters and was visited by Sarek in the episode.

Maybe Burnham kept the old quarters, or moved to a similar sized quarters so as not to bump anyone despite her rank. They were expecting a new Captain, so Lorca's old quarters were probably kept empty and will now be used by Pike.

Unlike the Enterprises, the Discovery is a pure science vessel and might not have extra quarters for dignitaries and such.
 
I honestly think the heavy action spectacle of "Brother" was just the effect of wanting to do the traditional "big splash" of a premier event, combined with setting the tone for S2.

I doubt the rest of the season will regularly follow-suit. Even if they WANTED to make every episode like "Star Trek Into Darkness..." the budget wouldn't support it. They'll be looking to do a fair amount of smaller stuff in the support of the overall arc I'd guess.

That's pretty much it.
Remember the big battle in "Battle at the binary stars" that kicked off the Klingon war? Yeah, who'd have thought that would be the ONLY big battle of the war we would ever witness!

In fact, I hope they spread the money much better around this time - I treat this entire episode like the usual "pre-title sequence" teasers all the 90s show had. That was very often the most expensive and exciting sequence of the episode as well. But I DO hope that both
  1. There will be (sparingly) some other, comparable action sequences, and
  2. The actual "plot" and story will be better handled and more coherent than in season 1
They got a very nice teaser for the upcoming season there, and I'm really invested in it so far! Now hope the rest turns out to be actually good.

is there anything more trekie than killing off random redshirts (in whatever coloured uniforms)? when i saw tos as a kid i soon found a nice hobby - which of the crew on a away mission i had not seen before won't make it back alive?

To be fair to the friggin' 60s though: They couldn't kill any recurring characters! In many episodes, they built the designated redshirt up, established his personality and his connections to the main character, to sell the impact. But nevertheless, this was purely the result of the narrative limiations of the time. Copying THAT seems very... foolish.

I didn't like it in ST09 - it was already too much treated as a meta-joke that it undermined the seriousness of the situation. But here? It felt like 60s television again. Just not very clever.

Ironically, this is a thing season 1 actually did better: Cmdr. Landry was also a designated redshirt. But since they build her up the previous episode as a recurring character - her death came actually as a surprise. Even though it was equally dumb as here. (Man, DIS really has a thing with commanding officers being dumb to get themselves killed, right?)

I also felt it came at the wrong place narrative-wise: That was the start of the mission! The fun action part! It would have had a much stronger punch if he died later, when things got wrong. The part where they were trying to beam up, and Burnham got cut off? If he had died there, it would have actually made the situation much more serious!
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top