For shite and giggles I asked 2 different A.I this exact question: Whats the public general consensus of Paul Wesley "s performance of James T. KIRK?
response 1
Paul Wesley's portrayal of James T. Kirk in "Star Trek: Strange New Worlds" has received mixed reviews. Some fans appreciate his fresh take, while others feel he lacks the quintessential "Kirk-like" qualities. William Shatner praised Wesley's performance, calling it "brilliant".
response 2
Paul Wesley’s performance as James T. Kirk in Strange New Worlds has received mixed reactions. Some viewers appreciate his fresh, more grounded take on a younger Kirk, while others feel he lacks the iconic charisma and presence of past portrayals.
All I'm saying is that the general consensus on his Kirk is mixed. And it's likely TPTB would factor that in doing a new show. Now it's possible as Wesley continues to play Kirk , he will receive more momentum . But I don't think we are there yet