• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Rewatching Picard...

In hindsight, and thinking about ST:IV and the parallels, maybe Elnor should've been there in 2024. I never really got a sense of any characters being a "fish out of water", certainly nothing close to how it was portrayed in the movie anyhow.

Elnor could've been the perfect weirdo for the season by not understanding the odd customs of ancient Earth, and struggling with crosswalks and cars. I could easily picture Picard trying to guide him through the 21st century, only to slip up himself.

Maybe a missed opportunity there.
 
And remember that this season was filmed entirely under covid restrictions. There was one scene where our entire crew was together at Chateau Picard and they were all spaced out around the room, and I don't think I would have even realized this if covid hadn't been so recent, but they were social distancing! Covid restrictions may have also been why Elenor and Soji didn't get larger roles. The smaller the cast, the easier to keep things contained.
 
I don't care whether they ultimately brought Elnor back (only to disappear him for S3); it still annoys me that they killed him off so early in the season and so, so casually.

I know there are plenty of folks out there who didn't care for the character, and that's fine, but I thought he brought something to the team that nobody else did, and the underlying concept was apparently interesting enough that DISCO would also make use of it (though I'm not sure which came first).
 
One other thing: for all the Social Commentary, which yes I'm for it (so we have to agree to disagree)

FWIW I'm not against it, but I don't want to be clubbed by it. And certainly not clubbed by it over the head.

There's been tons of it done well in Trek. Even Past Tense is done well. Past Tense you could say has the subtlety of a brick, in terms of its intention is ultra clear and without any prevarication of what it's tyring to say. But it tells a story, done through a somewhat diffracted view of Earth and does it through mechanisms like the districts.

With the Picard stuff it felt like it was just out of the window of the LA writers' office and they just said it. And when Raffi goes "You're killing it 2024" it feels like they're going to turn to the camera and shake their heads slowly at the viewer. That's what I hate. And not only that... that made the comments then moved on anyway and soon forgot about it.
 
Well I'm onto it already! Some preamble. As it's important for me to say it to myself, but also to contextualise this episode.

It's odd how unmoored I felt when I first watched this. I don't know where characters have gone, I don't know where characters are coming from... I put some of that down to skipping the end of season two. Actually for the most part it just drops you in it, and that's normal. Also I was coming from a place where I was pissed off with Picard and tuning in begrudgling as people said it was good. But begrudging is not a good place to start a TV show from.

I view this episode like through a dream... it was only three years ago but I remember so little. I remember fragments of the season. And I realise now looking at the dates my mum had died (I see I got my calculations wrong in that opening post) and I was in the final months of selling my parental home and moving back to London. I was not in a good place. I think most of my close friends don't know how bad I was at that point... so it's not entirely surprising I guess that it's fragmented as I was just about keeping above water.

So now with fresh eyes... here we go.

3.01 "The Next Generation". 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕 out of five.

And I've said numerous times I love the Blue Skies, Edith Piaff, the glamour of the Jurati song... you can work out my tastes. One of my favourite is the Ink Spots, so launching straight into that... well I want to give a kiss to whomever kept choosing music for Picard.

Beverly. Mystery. Shooty. She used to be so pacifist it's shocking seeing her so violent. Although I guess self defence and protecting your family can soon knock that out of you! And this is a different due to my Picard acceptance level and the group therapy I'm going through with you all in this thread! I remember not liking the violence here first time, it feeling out of character. This time I feel less concerned.

Nice to see Laris again of course, and it looks like like Picard was going through real character development. I can't recall if we see her again, at least meaningfully. But just like Picard came out of the woodwork demanding help, so now Beverly is!

"The fat ones, no one ordered those" did amuse me with its irreverence about my beloved Enterprise D. Then Riker is back and I just love the banter with him and Picard. It has that relaxed feeling that the TOS actors had in the movie, and then these two did in their movies. It just works.

Small thing: funny how Riker uses the secret message to add three to the numbers. If the virus made numbers bad, then I'd subtract them. Completely pointless observation but I wanted to keep saying "Did you check the other way too?"

After getting myself to mostly like Raffi now I was disappointed to see her back on the drugs. So then was delighted she's actually Starfleet intelligence. They got me on that one. This is also something that I can possibly buy into more with her character.

The whole plot to take the Titan on a mission feels convoluted and stretched. Can they not buy ships? Rent ships? Do the Romulans owe him no favours? But I'll live with it as a necessary evil of the plot.

Do we need another La Forge? Maybe not, but again it's like the movies with Sulu's daughter taking the helm. Again, I can live with it.

Oh and I thought the Titan looked more like the Excelsior than a new Constellation, but what do I know!

Now Captain Shaw I despise, and there are various scenes that I remember down the road that make me despise him. His treatment of Seven is appalling. But I have to accept he is written this way. This is meant to be a vile, insecure man and well they achieve that. I don't see myself warming to him like the other Picard cast that I have revaluated.

Great to see Seven again, and already a good story arc starting to form there as she's stuck between lives once again. And Shaw not helping. Also I loved her telling Riker to pipe down - Picard has new friends now. Of course Riker soon acknowledges she's great.

Raffi has Rios's ship, which makes me think again couldn't Picard have borrowed this? And the Red lady is a Captain Garret statue. Why her, why now? Well fank wank. If season two had heavy handed social commentary in the first few episodes, then now I know I need to convert my klaxon to a fanwank klaxon I know.

That leads us to the terrorist attack on Starfleet. And it's the way they dump the remains back onto the planet that gives a real sense of "fuck you!" It's the sort of thing again I would have likely complained about as being too dark but Picard has acclimated me.

Also I was always better at accepting external influences (see also Dominion War) threatening the good people of the Federation vs trouble from within. It's how the good guys deal with the threats that is the interesting part of Star Trek. Especially Sisko.

I don't recall the threat. I know changelings are involved. I *think* the other party is the Borg, but didn't we put the Borg on a new trajectory with Jurati? It's amazing how I've seen this but will watch not knowing what's going on entirely.

Then the end... and Beverly has a son. I have misgivings, but I'll end this episode with "A son?!" and leave the surprise there until I watch more.

But it felt sci-fi, it felt cool, it felt interesting, it felt Star Trek... and it's five moons for me. Then the beautiful music of First Contact is a lovely denouement.
 
Well I'm onto it already! Some preamble. As it's important for me to say it to myself, but also to contextualise this episode.

It's odd how unmoored I felt when I first watched this. I don't know where characters have gone, I don't know where characters are coming from... I put some of that down to skipping the end of season two. Actually for the most part it just drops you in it, and that's normal. Also I was coming from a place where I was pissed off with Picard and tuning in begrudgling as people said it was good. But begrudging is not a good place to start a TV show from.

I view this episode like through a dream... it was only three years ago but I remember so little. I remember fragments of the season. And I realise now looking at the dates my mum had died (I see I got my calculations wrong in that opening post) and I was in the final months of selling my parental home and moving back to London. I was not in a good place. I think most of my close friends don't know how bad I was at that point... so it's not entirely surprising I guess that it's fragmented as I was just about keeping above water.

So now with fresh eyes... here we go.

3.01 "The Next Generation". 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕 out of five.

And I've said numerous times I love the Blue Skies, Edith Piaff, the glamour of the Jurati song... you can work out my tastes. One of my favourite is the Ink Spots, so launching straight into that... well I want to give a kiss to whomever kept choosing music for Picard.

Beverly. Mystery. Shooty. She used to be so pacifist it's shocking seeing her so violent. Although I guess self defence and protecting your family can soon knock that out of you! And this is a different due to my Picard acceptance level and the group therapy I'm going through with you all in this thread! I remember not liking the violence here first time, it feeling out of character. This time I feel less concerned.

Nice to see Laris again of course, and it looks like like Picard was going through real character development. I can't recall if we see her again, at least meaningfully. But just like Picard came out of the woodwork demanding help, so now Beverly is!

"The fat ones, no one ordered those" did amuse me with its irreverence about my beloved Enterprise D. Then Riker is back and I just love the banter with him and Picard. It has that relaxed feeling that the TOS actors had in the movie, and then these two did in their movies. It just works.

Small thing: funny how Riker uses the secret message to add three to the numbers. If the virus made numbers bad, then I'd subtract them. Completely pointless observation but I wanted to keep saying "Did you check the other way too?"

After getting myself to mostly like Raffi now I was disappointed to see her back on the drugs. So then was delighted she's actually Starfleet intelligence. They got me on that one. This is also something that I can possibly buy into more with her character.

The whole plot to take the Titan on a mission feels convoluted and stretched. Can they not buy ships? Rent ships? Do the Romulans owe him no favours? But I'll live with it as a necessary evil of the plot.

Do we need another La Forge? Maybe not, but again it's like the movies with Sulu's daughter taking the helm. Again, I can live with it.

Oh and I thought the Titan looked more like the Excelsior than a new Constellation, but what do I know!

Now Captain Shaw I despise, and there are various scenes that I remember down the road that make me despise him. His treatment of Seven is appalling. But I have to accept he is written this way. This is meant to be a vile, insecure man and well they achieve that. I don't see myself warming to him like the other Picard cast that I have revaluated.

Great to see Seven again, and already a good story arc starting to form there as she's stuck between lives once again. And Shaw not helping. Also I loved her telling Riker to pipe down - Picard has new friends now. Of course Riker soon acknowledges she's great.

Raffi has Rios's ship, which makes me think again couldn't Picard have borrowed this? And the Red lady is a Captain Garret statue. Why her, why now? Well fank wank. If season two had heavy handed social commentary in the first few episodes, then now I know I need to convert my klaxon to a fanwank klaxon I know.

That leads us to the terrorist attack on Starfleet. And it's the way they dump the remains back onto the planet that gives a real sense of "fuck you!" It's the sort of thing again I would have likely complained about as being too dark but Picard has acclimated me.

Also I was always better at accepting external influences (see also Dominion War) threatening the good people of the Federation vs trouble from within. It's how the good guys deal with the threats that is the interesting part of Star Trek. Especially Sisko.

I don't recall the threat. I know changelings are involved. I *think* the other party is the Borg, but didn't we put the Borg on a new trajectory with Jurati? It's amazing how I've seen this but will watch not knowing what's going on entirely.

Then the end... and Beverly has a son. I have misgivings, but I'll end this episode with "A son?!" and leave the surprise there until I watch more.

But it felt sci-fi, it felt cool, it felt interesting, it felt Star Trek... and it's five moons for me. Then the beautiful music of First Contact is a lovely denouement.
I hope that you've found yourself in a much better place now.:)

I admit, when I heard that the TNG crew was returning for the final season, I wasn’t completely thrilled. In fact, I was terrified.

I didnt know who would die, who would have a total personality change, who would be a glorified cameo etc etc.

Starting off the first episode, I felt like my worst fears had been confirmed with Beverly blasting away and vaporising aliens left, right and centre. Fortunately, even Riker thought it odd, which means the writers knew it was odd! OK, ok, not so bad.

I didn't know what to make of Shaw, I was surprised that Seven was in Starfleet, but damn did I love the new spacedock and overall feel of what I was seeing on the Titan.

And yes, the criminally underused First Contact theme was wonderful to hear.
 
My initial reaction upon learning that we would see the entire TNG crew was excitement tempered by disappointment with the realization that the season 1 crew was essentially done. The announcement was actually made while Picard season 2 was still on the air and I didn't know the fates of the characters that had been established in the finale yet. Even then, there would have been potential for Soji and Elenor in a non-fanwank season 3.

That said, I would rate this first episode of season 3 probably about as high as you did. I did realize with this first episode that the story was going to be a "let's get the band back together" type story so I was expecting them to play a few of the greatest hits along the road. The train is still well and firmly on the tracks at this point.
 
Last edited:
I hope that you've found yourself in a much better place now.:)

I didn't know what to make but damn did I love the new spacedock and overall feel of what I was seeing on the Titan.
Thank you. And I forgot to say that. The space dock scenes had grandeur, something I haven't seen in a while.
 
Even then, there would have been potential for Soji and Elenor
That being said, I think Elnor is in a good place being at the Academy and Soji is in a good spot advocating for Android Rights.

Unless they did a four-year time skip, I think the Academy is where Elnor should be. Not only to receive formal Starfleet training but to also be around people his own age and learn how to socialize with other people besides the equivalent of Romulan Nuns.

Soji, she was already cast aside in Season 2, so it's not just a Season 3 thing. I'm not quite sure how advocating for Android Rights would fit into the story they were telling for Season 3, so I don't think she needed to be a regular in the season. But, and I mentioned this before, I think there should've been a scene with Data and Soji. At least one with "father" and "daughter".
 
Sorry for the double-post but this is completely unrelated to the above and I just thought about it after hitting submit. Season 1 and Season 3 both continue where things left off two decades earlier but go about it in different ways.

Season 1 looks at where things left off with the 24th Century in general. It uses Picard still grieving the death of Data after Nemesis, it partially uses the setup of the "All Good Things" Future with Picard at the Vineyard and with Irumodic Syndrome (or a Terminal Illness, since it wasn't named as such in S1), and it uses the destruction of Romulans as mentioned in Star Trek (2009) all as a jumping off point to tell its story.

Season 3 looks at where Nemesis in general, "What You Leave Behind" (DS9), and "Endgame" (VOY) left things, and projects forward two decades later. The difference being, unlike in Season 1, Picard is no longer grieving over Data and is no longer afflicted by his illness. And like the "All Good Things" Future, it also has a full TNG Crew Reunion. So, it incorporated the finales of TNG, DS9, VOY, and the TNG Movies into its starting point. That's all I'll say about that while Antony's still fuzzy. I don't want to get ahead of him.

Off to see "Doctor Bashir, I Presume" now for my own Re-Watch!
 
Last edited:
That being said, I think Elnor is in a good place being at the Academy and Soji is in a good spot advocating for Android Rights.

Unless they did a four-year time skip, I think the Academy is where Elnor should be. Not only to receive formal Starfleet training but to also be around people his own age and learn how to socialize with other people besides the equivalent of Romulan Nuns.

Soji, she was already cast aside in Season 2, so it's not just a Season 3 thing. I'm not quite sure how advocating for Android Rights would fit into the story they were telling for Season 3, so I don't think she needed to be a regular in the season. But, and I mentioned this before, I think there should've been a scene with Data and Soji. At least one with "father" and "daughter".
Absolutely, it would've brought things full circle for Data.

And, in way, repaired an ancestral wound that we saw in S2 with Adam Soong and Kore. As usual, Data is the one Soong descendant who is the most humane despite not being human.
 
I think a major issue for me was I didn't realise that one scene with Soji would be her last at the beginning of season two. It dangled she'd feature in season two, then didn't do so. I almost need go back and rewatch that scene to properly absorb it.
 
3.02 "Disengage". 🌕🌕🌕🌕 out of five.

Another solid episode and one that it feels like it follows on coherently from the first – something season two struggled with.

The big part of this episode is Jack Crusher. As a character, I don’t hate him but also find it hard to like him. That sort wise cracking, rogueish character I just feel we’ve seen so much in TV and film that I find it hard to be excited by him. Well I am excited by him in an entirely carnal way, but story wise… he's nothing terrible but it’s nothing revolutionary either.

The whole battle for them to leave the ship and get back to Titan is entertaining, and does the job it needs to do. Although the shuttle is Saavik – fanwank klaxon. That said as I’ve got older I got more annoyed that every ship and Federation location is so Earth centric, and very English-language centric… so I perhaps should say it’s nice to see Vulcan represented as they are a founding member after all. It would make sense that every member civilisation gets to name things.

Raffi going off the rails again makes you wonder why Starfleet would keep giving her chances. But that implausibility aside, this story does seem quite fitting for her still. It combines that she’s inherently a good person working for the good guys – but she’s also capable of delving into the darker side of the universe. The forced family stuff felt that though: forced. Her ex is back and oh look at that can he talk about the main storyline!

Now: Vadic. I love Amanda Plummer and she chews scenery with aplomb. Or should that be aplum? Ha ha ha (I’ll show myself out). For me she has stuck with me for 30 years since she appeared in the Outer Limits. I was enthralled by her in “A Stitch In Time” and when she came back for a sequel loved that too. I think that may have been the first Outer Limits sequel, or one of the few. It’s been a long time but she is instantly recognisable to me.

What sort of actor and/or character sticks with you decades later? That’s pretty special.

Her throwing another ship at the Titan is an epic set piece. And really her entire character and the cat and mouse over the view screen evokes many of the Trek movies in a good way. This season feels a bit movie-like so far.

I did wonder why is she giving them an hour to chat about it, she could carve them up and take it. Of course they had a lot of dialogue and backstory to deliver, that’s why…

La Forge going “If my father taught me anything…” acting all precocious and Shaw going “Thank you, Ensign” as if to say “Shut up Wesley!” was great.

Which I guess segues me to my shock moment. I didn’t hate Shaw. I saw dry humour. I saw a weariness with all the bullshit of Riker, Picard and Seven acting like disobedient children. That he's tired that they think they’re a bit elite, with their crazy backgrounds and secret rangers etc. I saw someone that did actually step up when needed (the warp burst into the tractor beam was also epic). And he accepted his fate when Picard took over.

Who would have thought it I have anything positive to say… but again it comes back to if you come in angry with a show you’re going to look for the worst. Come in with a better view, and you get a better outcome.

The Ferengi scenes, this probably where it starts to buffer again against my Star Trek worldview. It's a bit too dark, a bit too gruesome at times. Although I find myself amused by him producing a Romulan head as a surprise, but then feeling Worf decapitating him is too much.

Talking of the Ferengi head, it felt like his mouth area was very human and he had a Ferengi skullscap. It looked a little odd.

When I saw the sword my first thought it was Elnor, then I was a bit sad it wasn't. This proves how the TNG crew has displaced the Picard crew – as this was an Elnor scene through and through. Even down to him being the appropriate one to save Raffi.

Picard looking at Beverly then instantly seizing the ship l… well maybe Shaw does have a point on this lot. He’s perhaps the professional maybe and they’re not…when Shaw goes “Goddamnit it”, sighs then falls into line is quite special. Argh did I say something special about Shaw? What is going on.

I can't remember if Beverly spins a tale of WHY she has kept Picard in the dark, but the immediate impression is it makes her look terrible. Especially as the real Picard is dead, and he died never knowing he had a son. Then calling the kid after your first dead husband is both creepy and a further fuck you to Jean Luc. What did he do to deserve that?

Then to end a good old fashioned Star Trek hide in the cloud. I genuinely don’t remember what happens next, but I expect messing around in a cloud so they can do some more character building before the enemy finds a way to flush them out…
 
This was also the point where Shaw was growing on me. I had assumed they'd off the antagonistic starfleet officer who dared to speak ill of our heroes, but then you're really do start to see his point. He knew though, he genuinely knew when to step up.

The M'talas Prime stuff remains quite a weak and dismal spot in the season. I don't like too much grimdark in my Star Trek, so this a grit-yer-teeth and see it through, kind of situation.

Plummer's Vadic? She's interesting. But in honesty, I've never liked the look of the Shrike. Its intimidating, but then so was the Scimitar, another ship I've never been too fond of.

Two episodes in, I distinctly remember not having that sinking feeling like I did with previous seasons. It was refreshing, to say the least.
 
3.03 "Seventeen Seconds". 🌕🌕🌕 out of five.
The flashback... they seem to be doing funky things to Riker and Picard's face. Previously we just bought into it, it's a few years ago we can cope. Now they need to make them look very odd, which snaps you out of it. The little cameo from Deanna is fun though.

La Forge: "My father is one of the greatest Starfleet engineers that ever lived." Again banging on about her father. Is that her thing? Is it meant to be funny or endearing? It's also a bit exaggerated. He was an engineer on a starship, it's not like he's invented warp drive or anything.

Beverly comes across as bad as I thought, and likely worse. At least they don't portray it as okay - Picard calls her up on it. But I liked Beverly and he we have a nasty and manipulative bitch quite frankly here. It really was bad what she's done.

Blame Jean Luc for people wanting to hurt him, and blame his daddy issues... it's horrific. And I'm glad Picard doesn't' mince words about it.

Framing it as she lost her husband, and Wesley to the "stars" like he's responsible. Also she didn't lose Wesley. He's out and about as we saw. If he hasn't visited her that's on him, but he's giddy ganting about not dead.

And the worst thing is when she's in a corner she calls Picard. So I guess he's not all bad and the danger isn't so definite?

And the need to explain why he's English is a bit odd... couldn't they just get an American actor? Or have a Brit do an American accent?

The episode is largely as I expected. They hide in the nebula so they can all talk a lot and catch up. It's not particularly exciting and it is three episodes now in largely the same place. That sense of inertia creeps in.

We do have the Raffi/Worf counterpoint, which is okay but nothing amazing. Michael Dorn feels off. More than the fact that Worf is now a peaceful person with decapitations on cheat days.

I do find it funny that the shapeshifter is Thomas Dekker aka "Papa, help me build my castle!" from Star Trek Generations and Picard's dream of having children. Funny given the themes of this season. But as a changeling why didn't he just zoom out of the handcuffs and attack them?

"You're insane" I bet this is meant to make people chortle when Seven says this when Jack punches someone... but it's very modern language (or I guess old language, in their time). Seven would once upon a time understood that punching someone is not an indication of insanity. I'm sure she's also seen far worse.

I remember being interested in that red door and stuff and being a bit disappointed. I also remember I think this is Borg stuff, as they passed stuff down in Picard's semen or something... I guess I'll see when that times comes.

I was annoyed the changelings were used last time I watched as I perceived it as them meddling with DS9 too. But the shapeshifters are cool and I love the paranoia they can cause, so I'm interested to see where they go with them.

Picard going to sickbay as Jack is dying obviously mirrors Riker's speech earlier... except Jack is a main character so of course he lives. Your son was off camera, Will... not important.

I do like the Portal weapon... taking someone's own torpedoes and firing them as their own arse I quite devious I have to say. Riker's reaction to Picard feels a bit OTT. I know he's facing imminent death, but it still feels off...

It's an okay episode. They need to do the legwork on Picard and his son I know, but it does feel a bit stuck and despite some big reveals like changelings it feels a bit static.
 
Watching Season 2 the weakest of the Picard seasons, it started so well then got lost along the way. Best episodes were the first two. It never made sense why Q wanted Renee out of the way and helping Soong. How was that going to teach Picard about love? And the story about Picard's mother took up more than it needed to IMO.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top