• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Rewatching Picard...

Watching Season 2 the weakest of the Picard seasons, it started so well then got lost along the way. Best episodes were the first two. It never made sense why Q wanted Renee out of the way and helping Soong. How was that going to teach Picard about love? And the story about Picard's mother took up more than it needed to IMO.
Completely agree with all of this.

Its funny, if I was asked what I remember about the season, I feel like I'd need some prompting to remember Renee. She's intrinsic to the plot, but still not something that stands out for me.
 
Last edited:
Watching Season 2 the weakest of the Picard seasons, it started so well then got lost along the way. Best episodes were the first two. It never made sense why Q wanted Renee out of the way and helping Soong. How was that going to teach Picard about love? And the story about Picard's mother took up more than it needed to IMO.
I’ll still take it over the paper thin plot and wankfest that is Season 3.
 
I'm holding my tongue on most of the things that bugged me about S3, as Antony hasn't gotten there just yet.
 
Antony's flying right through this series! I have to get up very early in the morning, so I don't have time to post my thoughts. I'll just wait until he finishes the fourth episode. Then I'll give my input on the first act of Season 3 in one go. Just like I waited a bit on chunks of Seasons 1 and 2.

Although I wouldn't be surprised if he was on the sixth episode of the season by the time I get around to it.
 
3.04 "No Win Scenario". 🌕🌕🌕 out of five.

As Lord Garth said, I'm hurtling through. And his input on the first act of season three makes sense as the first four episodes do feel like a distinct segment.

Picard fought the Hirogen? Is that a reference to the book series Destiny? I'm just coming to the end of that, and there was Hirogen. Although book two was a few months back so can't recall if that was Picard...

On a random note to start I realised I do quite like the bridge... or specifically how they use it. Lots of reaction shots to the minor characters gives the bridge a sense of scale.

Although they don't tend to use it as hub of discussion so much.. they often then move the conversations elsewhere: quarters, the sickbay etc.

The dialogue I find increasingly a bit overwrought as they try to drive home the story narratives. "Deanna, as you know, feels everything. But she couldn't live with me feeling nothing. And neither could I, which is why I left and I came here. I was running from this, only to find it again."

It's all a little... blunt. I know Picard as a show is going to make the characters more emotional than TNG (and I can see benefits in that) but they speak with such clarity and poetry about their situation in scenes like above.

Beverly is going to verbally count down so hold on guys that's gonna be relevant! Did she just count again? Oh we're in for a biggy!

Shaw continues to amuse me a bit "Don't come!" in a shock to my system. But this episode does contain one of the conversations that sent me into a fury last time and this time... well I'm less angry but just shaking my head in disgust.

SHAW: Bait them. Steal their pot.
SEVEN: Pot? I'm assuming you're not referring to cannabis.
SHAW: Sadly, no.
I cannot describe how absurd and ridiculous this is. It's writing for teenagers at home whooping with joy as they mentioned pot. The sort that go into the cannabis shops and buy branded merchandise.

Just the sheer premise that Seven's first instinct - as a 24th century ex-Borg - is that pot would mean cannabis. It's ridiculous.

Then his "sadly no", which means he must then do drugs. Which again is not the Star Trek vibe I want. It's just puerile. And this sort of dialogue acts like a lightning rod of dissatisfaction for me as it summarises the many of the flaws of Picard in one moment. That it's playing to a certain audience and snapping you out of the moment.

As to why Seven is even speaking to him, it's the "no one knows the ship better than you" angle I wish Star Trek would bury forever. We need to get Paris out of jail, as he's the best pilot we've got! We need to reinstate Riker after he was suspended, as he's the best pilot we've got!

I mean get a damn map, Seven.

And I also take objection to the bucket - it had an in-universe name, but would avoid the teenager pot joke - it looks very similar to Odo's Bajoran bucket. Which is Bajoran as he was brought up by the Bajorans. This random changeling was not. It's also been proven they can sleep anywhere, so it's odd that this non-Bajoran changeling picked up the habit.

Holodeck time. I thought amazing as they have no energy, I bet it's like Voyager "Oh it's the wrong type of energy etc." I wasn't expecting a full in-universe explanation: "We dedicate power to it, so you can create a distraction for when you die." Alrighty then!

The Picard/Jack stuff is starting to get tiring. I know they should spend time on it as it's a huge life change, but after a while it does become just a bit repetetive.

I did think Shaw was giving Sisko vibes, so that makes sense that he's got the history with the Borg and now his animosity to Seven and Picard makes more sense. Part of me feels "We've done this", but I guess I can't say just Sisko is allowed the scars and no one else...

But the malevolent part of me half wanted Picard to shout at Shaw "And I fucking loved it!"

Seven shooting the changeling... these modern changelings do gurn a lot don't they? And why she's not shooting it as it escapes is not clear.

Beverly explains it's a countdown... oh didn't see that coming. Lots of technobabble, something about waves.

I love how they're still trying to portray Jack as some sort of London creation "Bob's your uncle, Fanny's your aunt"... whereas he comes across as quite middle England with his accent.

Beverly going to Riker "Deanna. Deanna would say it's about trust" really gave me a negative reaction too. Hot off the back of her manipulative behaviour, here she is doing it again to get Riker to act in a certain way. What the hell happened to Beverly?

The La Forge changeling mentioning her father means that this must be an intentional joke now, but I wasn't sure in the early episodes.

The whole exit sequence is well executed and fun, and Riker throwing a rock at the enemy ship is silly but fun. The alien births then is very cute, and very Star Trek.

It may be very Star Trek but it doesn't mean I need this dialogue:

CRUSHER: To seek out new life.
RIKER: I think we should boldly get the hell out of here

And this I will keep coming back to with this show. They had a great action sequence, then they shit on the top of it with stupid dialogue like this. Why? Why do it? At this epic moment you could have written ANYTHING. But you go for this lazy bullshit.

It ends with Jack meeting Picard in the past, and Picard saying Starfleet is all the family he needs. Thus Jack is pissed off. But again it's Picard-blaming, and there's a difference between rationalising your position where you're at vs embracing a life that has come upon you.

It was a good episode, marred by silly things. And overall I am glad they're out of that nebular - four episodes out of ten is a big chunk to devote to it.
 
:mad:

I work in the Cannabis industry and I assure you the clientele is nothing at all like what you just described. All ages and all walks of life, from your average Joe to your highly paid executive, college student and grandparent alike. But teenagers? Really? You get carded at the door and again at the counter. In 6 years in the industry, I've seen one underage person get past the front door and they got caught at the counter.

From people who use it medicinally (me, for anxiety) to people who use it recreationally (me again because alcohol is what really sucks) to people who just want to unwind a little bit after work or need a little motivation to handle that big project. None of them deserve disdain or judgment.

All of this hand wringing over the dangers of marijuana is what's "absurd and ridiculous". Prohibition didn't come from the medical industry, it came from the American alcohol and lumber industries who saw their livelihoods threatened by people smoking the plant and using hemp to make paper. People have been using the marijuana plant for various purposes for longer than they've been using the f word, and I don't see either one of those things changing either soon. In fact, it was once seen as an extremely valuable resource over which wars were fought, and not for its intoxicating properties. It was used for sails and fabric and paper. The declaration of Independence is written on hemp paper.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Last edited:
3.04 "No Win Scenario". 🌕🌕🌕 out of five.

As Lord Garth said, I'm hurtling through. And his input on the first act of season three makes sense as the first four episodes do feel like a distinct segment.

Picard fought the Hirogen? Is that a reference to the book series Destiny? I'm just coming to the end of that, and there was Hirogen. Although book two was a few months back so can't recall if that was Picard...

On a random note to start I realised I do quite like the bridge... or specifically how they use it. Lots of reaction shots to the minor characters gives the bridge a sense of scale.

Although they don't tend to use it as hub of discussion so much.. they often then move the conversations elsewhere: quarters, the sickbay etc.

The dialogue I find increasingly a bit overwrought as they try to drive home the story narratives. "Deanna, as you know, feels everything. But she couldn't live with me feeling nothing. And neither could I, which is why I left and I came here. I was running from this, only to find it again."

It's all a little... blunt. I know Picard as a show is going to make the characters more emotional than TNG (and I can see benefits in that) but they speak with such clarity and poetry about their situation in scenes like above.

Beverly is going to verbally count down so hold on guys that's gonna be relevant! Did she just count again? Oh we're in for a biggy!

Shaw continues to amuse me a bit "Don't come!" in a shock to my system. But this episode does contain one of the conversations that sent me into a fury last time and this time... well I'm less angry but just shaking my head in disgust.


I cannot describe how absurd and ridiculous this is. It's writing for teenagers at home whooping with joy as they mentioned pot. The sort that go into the cannabis shops and buy branded merchandise.

Just the sheer premise that Seven's first instinct - as a 24th century ex-Borg - is that pot would mean cannabis. It's ridiculous.

Then his "sadly no", which means he must then do drugs. Which again is not the Star Trek vibe I want. It's just puerile. And this sort of dialogue acts like a lightning rod of dissatisfaction for me as it summarises the many of the flaws of Picard in one moment. That it's playing to a certain audience and snapping you out of the moment.

As to why Seven is even speaking to him, it's the "no one knows the ship better than you" angle I wish Star Trek would bury forever. We need to get Paris out of jail, as he's the best pilot we've got! We need to reinstate Riker after he was suspended, as he's the best pilot we've got!

I mean get a damn map, Seven.

And I also take objection to the bucket - it had an in-universe name, but would avoid the teenager pot joke - it looks very similar to Odo's Bajoran bucket. Which is Bajoran as he was brought up by the Bajorans. This random changeling was not. It's also been proven they can sleep anywhere, so it's odd that this non-Bajoran changeling picked up the habit.

Holodeck time. I thought amazing as they have no energy, I bet it's like Voyager "Oh it's the wrong type of energy etc." I wasn't expecting a full in-universe explanation: "We dedicate power to it, so you can create a distraction for when you die." Alrighty then!

The Picard/Jack stuff is starting to get tiring. I know they should spend time on it as it's a huge life change, but after a while it does become just a bit repetetive.

I did think Shaw was giving Sisko vibes, so that makes sense that he's got the history with the Borg and now his animosity to Seven and Picard makes more sense. Part of me feels "We've done this", but I guess I can't say just Sisko is allowed the scars and no one else...

But the malevolent part of me half wanted Picard to shout at Shaw "And I fucking loved it!"

Seven shooting the changeling... these modern changelings do gurn a lot don't they? And why she's not shooting it as it escapes is not clear.

Beverly explains it's a countdown... oh didn't see that coming. Lots of technobabble, something about waves.

I love how they're still trying to portray Jack as some sort of London creation "Bob's your uncle, Fanny's your aunt"... whereas he comes across as quite middle England with his accent.

Beverly going to Riker "Deanna. Deanna would say it's about trust" really gave me a negative reaction too. Hot off the back of her manipulative behaviour, here she is doing it again to get Riker to act in a certain way. What the hell happened to Beverly?

The La Forge changeling mentioning her father means that this must be an intentional joke now, but I wasn't sure in the early episodes.

The whole exit sequence is well executed and fun, and Riker throwing a rock at the enemy ship is silly but fun. The alien births then is very cute, and very Star Trek.

It may be very Star Trek but it doesn't mean I need this dialogue:



And this I will keep coming back to with this show. They had a great action sequence, then they shit on the top of it with stupid dialogue like this. Why? Why do it? At this epic moment you could have written ANYTHING. But you go for this lazy bullshit.

It ends with Jack meeting Picard in the past, and Picard saying Starfleet is all the family he needs. Thus Jack is pissed off. But again it's Picard-blaming, and there's a difference between rationalising your position where you're at vs embracing a life that has come upon you.

It was a good episode, marred by silly things. And overall I am glad they're out of that nebular - four episodes out of ten is a big chunk to devote to it.
This level of devotion would've been perfect for season 2's (here I am, banging the same old drum) first 4 episodes.

The use of language and terminology is one thing i'll always struggle with, but its a show that was birthed in this era and its just one of those things.

I was happy with this episode, it was fun to watch.
 
I think it comes to the contrast between TNG presenting a future largely characterised by post-scarcity idealism and an almost parental attitude against drug use. A sort of "In the future, you won’t need it" mentality. Well-meaning, if a bit puritan.

Picard reflects a more nuanced, cynical reality where some characters navigate the availability and necessity of substances to cope with trauma and a less than utopian galaxy. Rios and Cigars, Raffi and a space-vape of some description, Seven and alcohol..its all a result of a horrid time in Federation history.

I dont like how the Federation became the way it was, but I can understand why the optics of a less than approachable galaxy made people develop new coping mechanisms.
 
Can't you just make replicators create as much drugs as you want?

Trauma or no trauma there would be a lot of drug use going on.
 
What a very narrow minded and ignorant view.
🥱but it's mine to have.

I think I have more elevated humour. That said I was just discussing what I liked in the new Naked Gun movie so perhaps not.

But it is crap, out of place humour IMO and I ain't going to change on that.

It is going to to appeal to people who have cannabis key rings and the like.
 
In Vermont, it's more uncommon not to have a cannabis keyring...

...that's the stereotype of Vermonters, right?
 
3.05 "Imposters". 🌕🌕🌕🌕 out of five.

I have been out all day, back very late but had to sneak one more in. That's an overall good sign. And I think this episode may be the clearest indication of how past me's view of Picard and current me's verdict have diverged significantly.

This episode you can clearly see they have had a demarcation between the last four episodes and this. Daddy talk between Picard and Jack and talk of Riker's loss are all gone - new stories now. And I'm okay with that, it's nice to give some other story elements time to breathe even if it does feel like a bit of a cliff edge.

Let's start with Raffi and Worf. this feels like a combo that works to me. There's almost an Odo/Jem'hadar vibe, with Worf trying to help give Raffi guidance and purpose and to manage her impulses.

Raffi the first time around I didn't like, but the second time around I largely do. The odd scene, particularly in season one (remember JL JL JL JL JL) rubbed me up the wrong way but overall I like her. And humour/dialogue that I would have one likely hated I now buy into. "Terrorist goo freaks" may have pissed me off in early season one, but now I quite like it. It's irreverent, and it fits. Similarly Worf going "That's a question only Sneed can answer" and her riposte of "Had you not cut off his head" amused me.

Shaw - I'm going to get the one real negative out of the way: turbolift dialogue. There were two lines that were seared into my memory of loathing him and turning me against the show. One was the pot line (who knew my opinion on that would be the spiciest thing in these reviews!) but also "hot dropped the saucer section of the Enterprise D". It makes me just incalculably angry. And I don't even know what it means, I google the term and it doesn't come up but it just sounds fucking stupid. I had forgotten he used the word "snog" in his next sentence. Lord.

But aside from the infantile dialogue, it also doesn't make a lot of sense to me. That a captain in Starfleet with thousands of ships knows about the kissing activities of another captain 25 years ago. I mean I'd love to ask someone in the navy "What was your flagship's captain up to 25 years ago? Who did he kiss?"

On the plus side, those were the two really negative things I remembered about him and they are done. And aside from that, I still find myself liking Shaw which I think has to be the biggest revelation by a country mile in my rewatch.

Ro. Dear Ro... this was the bit I was prepared to be angry about. Bringing Ro back, killing her... what a disgrace, insult to TNG etc. But... I don't kind of feel that. The scenes between her and Picard were really good. Really good. And her death maybe is a really good gutpunch to underscore this story.
I mean I may feel slightly nicer knowing she's gone off to eat some hasperat, but for a final TNG story and probably her final involvement with the franchise I guess it was an effective use of her.

Now, in an ideal world I'd liked to have had Ro all season. That would have been fantastic.

Then I also thought wouldn't it have been great to give her and Picard an entire episode. And I mean an ENTIRE episode alone. No cutaways, no B stories. Two people in a room talking it out. That would have been powerful and brave, and a missed opportunity.

Michelle Forbes is just a fantastic actress and it was great to have her back even for a little bit in the Star Trek sandpit.

Picard does one thing reasonably well and that's portraying life out of Starfleet, that Starfleet is not the only option. And I like when they pull at those threads here. Picard saying to Jack pretty much straight away he should join Starfleet, the moments later he has a uniform to wear. It feels a little cultish almost if you stood back and analysed it. A bit like the game... "You should try it." And Ro even back in TNG offered a chink of confrontation and rejection of the Starfleet homogeny. So it's good to have her back as a reminder of that.

I wish Ro had some time with Seven, as they are both one-foot-in and one-foot-out of Starfleet, outsiders yet not. It could have been interesting.

Oh and also on the Ro front she says turn the music on as the walls are thin, then proceeds to walk out into the corridor discussing plans.... what's that about?

The criminal scenes with Worf and Raffi are less appealing. Mostly again as it feels a bit 'seen this before'. And when she stabs Worf you know there be trickery. It does feel like they just went "something something something heartrate Kahless" as if you add the word Kahless it's legitimately Klingon of course don't ask any questions.

The changeling autopsy scenes are... confusing. Firstly that Beverly would have La Forge come up and say that the body is not hers. Why would you make her do that and what would it prove? I mean a changeling could come up and say "That's not me" with the real La Forge's dead body there.

Also the say Changelings don't have internal organs. Really? If that's the case in DS9 why didn't get get simple x-ray scanners at every door? They act with shock that it undermines a blood test, but as Joseph Sisko said they could just suck some blood and drop it out anyway.

Finally Jack kills four changelings, turning into a synth-style killing machine. Haven't we seen this? And Beverly is concerned by Jack not knowing they were four changelings that he killed. But to be honest they stood there with phasers aimed at him, we know they were likely dodgy. I don't think it's quite the dramatic moment Beverly makes it out to be.

But yeah.. I don't hate Shaw, I'm not full of rage that Ro is dead... maybe I'm the changeling. I don't recognise me!
 
Jurati starting her new Borg collective is the only bit of real interest in an episode of filler and stories that are done with little conviction. The whole story feels like one big shoulder shrug.
Just watched this, the experienced ex Special forces hard men/woman standing there like rabbits caught in the headlights watching Jurati do strange things to their colleague smdh. She should have been shot, there were more them than there were of her and yet they stood there and took their assimilation like good soldiers. I doubt ex military personnel are that dumb.
 
3.05 "Imposters". 🌕🌕🌕🌕 out of five.

I have been out all day, back very late but had to sneak one more in. That's an overall good sign. And I think this episode may be the clearest indication of how past me's view of Picard and current me's verdict have diverged significantly.

This episode you can clearly see they have had a demarcation between the last four episodes and this. Daddy talk between Picard and Jack and talk of Riker's loss are all gone - new stories now. And I'm okay with that, it's nice to give some other story elements time to breathe even if it does feel like a bit of a cliff edge.

Let's start with Raffi and Worf. this feels like a combo that works to me. There's almost an Odo/Jem'hadar vibe, with Worf trying to help give Raffi guidance and purpose and to manage her impulses.

Raffi the first time around I didn't like, but the second time around I largely do. The odd scene, particularly in season one (remember JL JL JL JL JL) rubbed me up the wrong way but overall I like her. And humour/dialogue that I would have one likely hated I now buy into. "Terrorist goo freaks" may have pissed me off in early season one, but now I quite like it. It's irreverent, and it fits. Similarly Worf going "That's a question only Sneed can answer" and her riposte of "Had you not cut off his head" amused me.

Shaw - I'm going to get the one real negative out of the way: turbolift dialogue. There were two lines that were seared into my memory of loathing him and turning me against the show. One was the pot line (who knew my opinion on that would be the spiciest thing in these reviews!) but also "hot dropped the saucer section of the Enterprise D". It makes me just incalculably angry. And I don't even know what it means, I google the term and it doesn't come up but it just sounds fucking stupid. I had forgotten he used the word "snog" in his next sentence. Lord.

But aside from the infantile dialogue, it also doesn't make a lot of sense to me. That a captain in Starfleet with thousands of ships knows about the kissing activities of another captain 25 years ago. I mean I'd love to ask someone in the navy "What was your flagship's captain up to 25 years ago? Who did he kiss?"

On the plus side, those were the two really negative things I remembered about him and they are done. And aside from that, I still find myself liking Shaw which I think has to be the biggest revelation by a country mile in my rewatch.

Ro. Dear Ro... this was the bit I was prepared to be angry about. Bringing Ro back, killing her... what a disgrace, insult to TNG etc. But... I don't kind of feel that. The scenes between her and Picard were really good. Really good. And her death maybe is a really good gutpunch to underscore this story.
I mean I may feel slightly nicer knowing she's gone off to eat some hasperat, but for a final TNG story and probably her final involvement with the franchise I guess it was an effective use of her.

Now, in an ideal world I'd liked to have had Ro all season. That would have been fantastic.

Then I also thought wouldn't it have been great to give her and Picard an entire episode. And I mean an ENTIRE episode alone. No cutaways, no B stories. Two people in a room talking it out. That would have been powerful and brave, and a missed opportunity.

Michelle Forbes is just a fantastic actress and it was great to have her back even for a little bit in the Star Trek sandpit.

Picard does one thing reasonably well and that's portraying life out of Starfleet, that Starfleet is not the only option. And I like when they pull at those threads here. Picard saying to Jack pretty much straight away he should join Starfleet, the moments later he has a uniform to wear. It feels a little cultish almost if you stood back and analysed it. A bit like the game... "You should try it." And Ro even back in TNG offered a chink of confrontation and rejection of the Starfleet homogeny. So it's good to have her back as a reminder of that.

I wish Ro had some time with Seven, as they are both one-foot-in and one-foot-out of Starfleet, outsiders yet not. It could have been interesting.

Oh and also on the Ro front she says turn the music on as the walls are thin, then proceeds to walk out into the corridor discussing plans.... what's that about?

The criminal scenes with Worf and Raffi are less appealing. Mostly again as it feels a bit 'seen this before'. And when she stabs Worf you know there be trickery. It does feel like they just went "something something something heartrate Kahless" as if you add the word Kahless it's legitimately Klingon of course don't ask any questions.

The changeling autopsy scenes are... confusing. Firstly that Beverly would have La Forge come up and say that the body is not hers. Why would you make her do that and what would it prove? I mean a changeling could come up and say "That's not me" with the real La Forge's dead body there.

Also the say Changelings don't have internal organs. Really? If that's the case in DS9 why didn't get get simple x-ray scanners at every door? They act with shock that it undermines a blood test, but as Joseph Sisko said they could just suck some blood and drop it out anyway.

Finally Jack kills four changelings, turning into a synth-style killing machine. Haven't we seen this? And Beverly is concerned by Jack not knowing they were four changelings that he killed. But to be honest they stood there with phasers aimed at him, we know they were likely dodgy. I don't think it's quite the dramatic moment Beverly makes it out to be.

But yeah.. I don't hate Shaw, I'm not full of rage that Ro is dead... maybe I'm the changeling. I don't recognise me!
The reappearance of Ro makes this probably easily my favorite episode of S3. Mixed feelings about her death here, but at least it's more meaningful and well-executed than what Elnor or Hugh got.

I'm still disappointed that I thought this season might actually involve the Dominion, but not so much. It's like TPTB opened the DS9 toybox, but only long enough to pull out a single toy, and that one without all of its pieces.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top