• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Rewatching Picard...

I am watching this episode now with a bit of illogical anger that Season 3 disrespects the Troi-Rikers choice to live on the planet to save their son, with the throwaway line I don't like Nepenthe/living in the countryside. You mean this empathetic couple never sensed that the other partner prefered living the UFP urban life instead of Country living? And what happened to the planet of endless youth from Insurrection, why didn't they move there instead? Which parent would not move heaven and earth and live anywhere to save their son? Apart from all this one of the better episodes of S1.
You're not alone in this. Way to take one of the few generally agreed upon really good episodes from S1 and spit on it.
 
2.09 "Hide and Seek"🌓 out of 5

Oh dear. Oh dear oh dear oh dear.

Firstly, why is La Barre just so dark and misty all the time? It gives the whole place a weird, ethereal vibe. Which I guess may be the intention.

Jurati/Borg Queen... seeing them both together in a scene it does make me miss when they were just bantering. They're better as seperate entities than one. I wasn't overly keen on the direction of this hybrid. It also feels very familiar. Characters like Evil Willow. And a trope that if writers get bored with an actress they dress her up and make her crazzzzyyy (see Fred in Angel). I was obviously a big fan of Scorpius and Jurati but not happy where it ended up.

The fact that they need to re-Borg Seven but has the exact same Borg prosthetics which was a result of her being de-Borged once is very special. *slow claps*

Elnor is back again. He's been hallucinations, memories, and now a hologram. It's hard to see his character just defiled in this way. And I feel a good conclusion for him now seems very thin with just one episode left. As I thought Soji was one of the strongest point of season one it's also sad to see the two youngest actors introduced in season one largely put on the scrap heap in season two. Also did he say he had Elnor's memories... how?!

Green beams. Soong. Waffle. Filler. Amazing how Q, Soong and all these people can't just kill an astronaut. They had so many opportunities. Instead we have to have this grand theatre. And Soong trying to kill Picard is another long drawn out waffle fest in order for someone to turn up and save them. Soong throwing the exploding phaser and scarpering felt very Loony Tunes.

English maman is back. Baltar is back (wasn't expecting to see more of him). And how old is Picard there? Eight or nine? And she has to explain what hide and seek is to him?!

I said previously I didn't get the relevance of the tunnels, but I now get they were a long drawn out metaphor over many episodes to get to the point of Picard's mother killing herself.

I just cannot believe this future and will not accept it. I cannot accept in four hundreds years that we haven't made progress in mental illness treatment. Or at the very very least that there is adequate care if there isn't a 'cure'. The fact that she can be so ill yet bouncing around mansion's tunnels with no care, and her husband having to lock her up is not a future I will not accept in Star Trek.

It's grotesque. And to use this woman's suffering - when many people in today's world will be going through this - as some sort of development exercise for Picard's character is disgusting.

It reminds me of someone on LinkedIn once who was talking of his mother's cancer and how it was going to be a development experience for him going back to care for her.

The writers are also very tricksy. They know full well we've seen an older Renee so they explain it away with this entirely unsubtle dialogue. "I used to imagine seeing her older, offering me a cup of tea... and asking for a chat."

Fuck right off. It's patronising the viewers. I know Trek plays loose with continuity sometimes, it has to. But the smug way they write this in and reverse engineer "Where No One Has Gone Before" as if to say "gotcha" is something else.

Actually, writer. This is the dialogue you wanted:

"I used to imagine seeing her older, offering me a cup of tea... and asking for a chat. I would imagine her with a French accent, because the English never really worked? Then she disappeared from the corridor, on another game of hide and seek..."

Can I give this episode zero moons? On to the season finale, where no doubt Zefram Cochrane's great grandmother will be gang raped so she can instil a need to escape from Earth into her family.
 
Last edited:
AntonyF said:
The fact that she can be so ill yet bouncing around mansion's tunnels with no care, and her husband having to lock her up is not a future I will not accept in Star Trek.
double negative.
 
The fact that they need to re-Borg Seven but has the exact same Borg prosthetics which was a result of her being de-Borged once is very special. *slow claps*
Man, that annoyed me more than anything else. They went with the typical cliché 'learn to accept yourself for who you are' resolution to her arc, even though it required instantly giving her the exact same look she used to have. Even though two Borg never look the same. But she didn't didn't get the full Borg look, instead she got the post-Borg one from after she got most of her implants removed.

And the cherry on top is that she did it to heal a gut wound.

It wasn't even needed for future episodes because she's in her alternate timeline body!

Elnor is back again. He's been hallucinations, memories, and now a hologram. It's hard to see his character just defiled in this way. And I feel a good conclusion for him now seems very thin with just one episode left. As I thought Soji was one of the strongest point of season one it's also sad to see the two youngest actors introduced in season one largely put on the scrap heap in season two. Also did he say he had Elnor's memories... how?!
I guess the ship just scans everyone's brains and copies all their thoughts without permission or concern about security issues* just in case it needs to make a (totally not sentient we promise) holographic clone.

*Don't ask why they couldn't just interrogate the memories of the Borg Queen copied into the computer.
 
I gave "Let He Who Is Without Sin" a 0 in my DS9 Re-Watch Thread, so why not?
If an episode deserved it, it's that one. It also have that "death is character building" mentality to boot that I hate above.

I'm going to save the rest of my thoughts about Season 2 for when you finish all of it, so I don't have to worry about holding back or keeping track of what happened when.
One more to go. Unlikely today, but will be tomorrow.

I have come to peace with some of Picard and certainly enjoyed some of it more than I did the first time. However season two is now repaying me with treachery.
 
Season 2's saving grace is that it brings the fractured fanbase together. We all have different opinions on what Star Trek should be and what good Trek is, but when it comes to Picard season 2 we can actually agree on what bad Trek is!

(But then Section 31 came out and did a better job of being awful).
 
(But then Section 31 came out and did a better job of being awful).
I think the key difference between Picard Season 2 and Section 31, for me, is everything else surrounding them.

Section 31 has DSC, SNW, and SFA surrounding it. I didn't connect with SFA and, on top of that, the 32nd Century has now lost me (I'm not going to get into any of that here), which in turn not only did in SFA but also retroactively knocked out DSC S3-S5. Aside from the 32nd Century, I already wasn't a fan of SNW either. So, in addition to S31 being a terrible movie, Disco Trek has taken a massive fall in general. From my POV.

Picard Season 2, OTOH, is surrounded by Picard Seasons 1 and 3, which I like for different reasons. And it's still a continuation of TNG/DS9/VOY. So, much like Insurrection and Nemesis, I look at Picard Season 2 as, "It's trash, but it's our trash!" If that makes sense.

Not to mention Picard Season 2 actually had things going for it, the potential was there, but they stumbled at several points unfortunately.
 
Last edited:
There were just too many stories in S2. Things weren't given time to breathe, and some were definitely not needed/far too depressing.

Regarding Picard's mother, yeah, the early 24th century must've been a dark time for healthcare.
Unfortunately the one thing given time to breathe in S2 (Our Heroes being stuck in the 'present'), was the one thing I quickly tired of. I really thought they'd be in their past for 3-4 episodes and then we'd go Back to the Future(tm), but nope!
 
Unfortunately the one thing given time to breathe in S2 (Our Heroes being stuck in the 'present'), was the one thing I quickly tired of. I really thought they'd be in their past for 3-4 episodes and then we'd go Back to the Future(tm), but nope!
I expected more episodes in the Confederate timeline, in honesty.

Im not sure how they could've padded it out without it being more 'Mirror, Mirror', but it could've been interesting to see who else was there.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top