• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Can we discuss those pesky "fixed points in time?"

If he wanted to off himself there were many options
Not exactly. The implication was that that he should have been dead, but the Daleks were keeping him alive because they needed him to complete the reality bomb. Davros figured that once the bomb was complete and the Daleks knew it worked, they'd have no reason to prevent his death and keep him alive anymore, meaning he could at last "have peace."
 
While the classic series never spoke about "fixed points" per se, Hartnell's Doctor did seem particularly perturbed whenever someone tried to change history, whether it was Barbara's attempts to reform Aztec society in "The Aztecs" or the Meddling Monk attempting to turn away the Viking invasion in "The Time Meddler." But there were other times when he seemed to get caught in predestination paradoxes, like when he inspired Nero to burn down Rome in "The Romans" or when he & the Daleks inadvertently caused the crew & passengers of the Mary Celeste to abandon ship in "The Chase."
Nobody's mentioned Adric's death. I remember when "Earthshock" was shown, fans (the ones who liked Adric) were angry with the Doctor for not going back to save him. They could have; once the ship's controls were fused so the ship would crash into Earth 65 million years ago, Adric was no longer necessary. It would have taken split-second timing, but it was doable.

Yet the Doctor refused, got angry, and told Tegan and Nyssa never to ask him again to save Adric.

Karma's a bitch: Adric's death haunted the Fifth Doctor, all the way through his regeneration. And rightfully so, in my view.
 
Nobody's mentioned Adric's death. I remember when "Earthshock" was shown, fans (the ones who liked Adric) were angry with the Doctor for not going back to save him. They could have; once the ship's controls were fused so the ship would crash into Earth 65 million years ago, Adric was no longer necessary. It would have taken split-second timing, but it was doable.

Yet the Doctor refused, got angry, and told Tegan and Nyssa never to ask him again to save Adric.

Karma's a bitch: Adric's death haunted the Fifth Doctor, all the way through his regeneration. And rightfully so, in my view.

It's true though he could have saved him, maybe that's why 12 did what he did for Clara.... Now we're stuck with Zombie Clara and her TARDIS.
 
It's true though he could have saved him, maybe that's why 12 did what he did for Clara.... Now we're stuck with Zombie Clara and her TARDIS.
That would only make sense to people who don't hate Adric. When they did that "Clara is so superduper-fantastic-wonderfully-perfect-that-no-doctor-can-do-without-her" bullshit and inserted her into every single other Doctor's timeline, they put her in Adric's place in Logopolis. There were a ton of other scenes they could have used, but they had to use one with a companion who died while saving Earth, and the actor who played him was a genuine fan of the show ages before he was cast in it.

I got the impression a long time ago that unless a character from the Classic years would really draw an audience (ie. Sarah Jane and K-9), the nuWho showrunners preferred to forget the Classic series ever existed.

The only valid reason I will ever accept for William Russell not being part of at least one episode that took place at Coal Hill School is if he was asked and said no. Yes, he was getting up in years... but even just a voiceover on the school's PA system or a mention that somebody had just talked to Ian Chesterton (or would talk to him sometime later) would have been a nice acknowledgment of the show's roots.
 
That would only make sense to people who don't hate Adric. When they did that "Clara is so superduper-fantastic-wonderfully-perfect-that-no-doctor-can-do-without-her" bullshit and inserted her into every single other Doctor's timeline, they put her in Adric's place in Logopolis. There were a ton of other scenes they could have used, but they had to use one with a companion who died while saving Earth, and the actor who played him was a genuine fan of the show ages before he was cast in it.

I got the impression a long time ago that unless a character from the Classic years would really draw an audience (ie. Sarah Jane and K-9), the nuWho showrunners preferred to forget the Classic series ever existed.

The only valid reason I will ever accept for William Russell not being part of at least one episode that took place at Coal Hill School is if he was asked and said no. Yes, he was getting up in years... but even just a voiceover on the school's PA system or a mention that somebody had just talked to Ian Chesterton (or would talk to him sometime later) would have been a nice acknowledgment of the show's roots.


Yes but I hate the idea of Clara and always wish that the Doctor had saved Adric back in the old series, even if it had been a later incarnation. it was totally doable.

Hell he saved Davros from the stupid fucking handmines, which were stupid.
 
Yes but I hate the idea of Clara and always wish that the Doctor had saved Adric back in the old series, even if it had been a later incarnation. it was totally doable.

Hell he saved Davros from the stupid fucking handmines, which were stupid.
True. I didn't think about a future incarnation going back and saving him. It would have had to be Colin Baker, though, since Matthew Waterhouse wouldn't have looked anything like a teenager anymore. And Colin Baker's Doctor wouldn't have done it, not having a smidgen of sentimentality.

As for saving Davros... ghah. But for continuity's sake he had to, or there wouldn't have been the superb Genesis of the Daleks, my favorite of Tom Baker's first season.
 
True. I didn't think about a future incarnation going back and saving him. It would have had to be Colin Baker, though, since Matthew Waterhouse wouldn't have looked anything like a teenager anymore. And Colin Baker's Doctor wouldn't have done it, not having a smidgen of sentimentality.

As for saving Davros... ghah. But for continuity's sake he had to, or there wouldn't have been the superb Genesis of the Daleks, my favorite of Tom Baker's first season.

Very true, and that's also the first shot of the time war.
 
We’ve never seen a whole, adult Davros yet
A maker of DAZ based content named "JoeQuick", when he was still sculpting just for fun, made a likeness for me of the John Friedlander mask as worn by Michael Wisher.. I applied it to the intended base figure (Michael 3) and it distort the head to closely resemble the injured and withered Kaled scientist. Then I wondered, "How might it look if I only dialed it to partial strength, say, around 50 percent?" So that's what I did. I applied a more conventional skin texture (which had heavily mapped eyebrows) and I placed a simple brushed back hairstyle. This was years before Capaldi episodes, so I used black (aged to a dark grey) rather than the dirty blonde "kid" Davros had. It was just dumb luck that I gave him piercing blue eyes.

Anyway, this was the result.

FoQ5Xoo.jpg


Yeah, I went a bit heavy with the "bump maps" and this was rendered with an "engine" that could not calculate things like "subsurface" light scattering upon skin, so it's quite primitive compared to what can be done with more robust tools available today. But it does give us a "glimpse" of how he might have looked before he aged into the twisted caricature we saw in "Genesis of the Daleks".
 
We’ve never seen a whole, adult Davros yet
RTD did write a scene for Journey's End (which I think is the same scene as my previously mentioned Davros wishes for death is from) in which we would have seen a flashback to Davros's early, pre-injury days. It was removed before filming as RTD felt it served on purpose to the narrative and was only written as a means to show Julian Bleach out of prosthetics.

The scripted version of the scene is available in The Writer's Tale.
 
A maker of DAZ based content named "JoeQuick", when he was still sculpting just for fun, made a likeness for me of the John Friedlander mask as worn by Michael Wisher.. I applied it to the intended base figure (Michael 3) and it distort the head to closely resemble the injured and withered Kaled scientist. Then I wondered, "How might it look if I only dialed it to partial strength, say, around 50 percent?" So that's what I did. I applied a more conventional skin texture (which had heavily mapped eyebrows) and I placed a simple brushed back hairstyle. This was years before Capaldi episodes, so I used black (aged to a dark grey) rather than the dirty blonde "kid" Davros had. It was just dumb luck that I gave him piercing blue eyes.

Anyway, this was the result.

FoQ5Xoo.jpg

Oh God! That’s PERFECT!
 
Oh God! That’s PERFECT!

Thanks for the kind assessment! Now, if they had depicted some sort of flashback in "genesis..." itself, odds are we would have seen Michael Wisher himself without makeup and he in almost no way resembles this depiction. Or, if JoeQuick had sculpted the Terry Molloy mask or the Julian Bleach makeup and I used a different base figure, the partial strength "pre injury" morph would have looked different from what we see here. So it's still up to a wide range of interpretation how a younger "pre chair" Davros might look. This is just one of many possibilities.

But, again, I'm pleased you like it!

Just so you can decide for yourself how accurate (or not) it may be, here's JoeQuick's morph at full strength.

kyX3LmV.jpg


It's a bit of "mix'n'match" as it's the "Genesis..." features with the figure sitting in a "Stolen Earth" chair and sporting a custom bionic hand (texture and displacement map).
 
Last edited:
A maker of DAZ based content named "JoeQuick", when he was still sculpting just for fun, made a likeness for me of the John Friedlander mask as worn by Michael Wisher.. I applied it to the intended base figure (Michael 3) and it distort the head to closely resemble the injured and withered Kaled scientist. Then I wondered, "How might it look if I only dialed it to partial strength, say, around 50 percent?" So that's what I did. I applied a more conventional skin texture (which had heavily mapped eyebrows) and I placed a simple brushed back hairstyle. This was years before Capaldi episodes, so I used black (aged to a dark grey) rather than the dirty blonde "kid" Davros had. It was just dumb luck that I gave him piercing blue eyes.

Anyway, this was the result.

FoQ5Xoo.jpg


Yeah, I went a bit heavy with the "bump maps" and this was rendered with an "engine" that could not calculate things like "subsurface" light scattering upon skin, so it's quite primitive compared to what can be done with more robust tools available today. But it does give us a "glimpse" of how he might have looked before he aged into the twisted caricature we saw in "Genesis of the Daleks".

That is excellent, i now what to see Davros before the chair, possible working as a kaled cook in some Skaro resturant, and one day while making some home made soup he mistakenly makes a kaled mutant, and while pondering what to do with it his eyes are drawn to the kaled salt and pepper shakers on one of the tables(EUREKA!) he cries, as he races back into the kitchen but slips on a banana peel and dives head first into one of the deep fat fryers, and with agonizing screams he pulls himself out, but the damage is already done...............i mean this story writes itsef..............well it should. lol
 
Last edited:
OK here's one that bugs me more because of the new who. They didn't really do this stuff in the old series but the whole "fixed points" stuff. I don't think they ever made a big deal of that in the classic series. However I am happy to be proven wrong if there were examples given of this notion in the old show.

But moving on why it bugs me is its very nature. A fixed event can be anything including a person. I think there was mention of a Dalek not killing someone because according to the Doctor "somewhere deep down it knew they were a fixed point in time" and I think that was the child version of Adelaide Brooks from Waters Of Mars.

What exactly stopped the Dalek from shooting her beyond "she's a fixed point in time" which I really do feel sometimes is all bollocks.

How does that work? Is there some supernatural force stopping the Dalek?

"Remembrance of the Daleks" indirectly alludes to it, if anything, as the Doctor goes on and on about how they're ruthless but would think twice before making radical alterations to the timeline. But that's a grasp; Daleks knowing there's a fixed point in time somewhere would just create a predestination paradox. Or the Daleks would not try to change such a fixed point because of a far worse outcome... but is such an event truly fixed, among all multiverses and so on? In which case one has to subtract that number of possible events from... infinity.

But the reality bomb is a really stupid plan..... Blow up everything and nothing is left to rule

Pretty much. If there's dialogue that states "everything non-Dalek"... then again, Davros is an insane nutter...

It wipes out anyone who isn't a Dalek. Stupid, but consistent with their mindset.

When it comes to Daleks, anything even the teensiest bit non-Dalek is only good for being exterminated, if not for being good disposable thralls before being exterminated. Whether the story was rolling on that assumption or needed to acknowledge that...

But the script tells us all we need to know:

DAVROS: Electrical energy, Miss Tyler. Every atom in existence is bound by an electrical field. The Reality bomb cancels it out. Structure falls apart. That test was focused on the prisoners alone. Full transmission will dissolve every form of matter.
...
DAVROS: Across the entire universe. Never stopping, never faltering, never fading. People and planets and stars will become dust, and the dust will become atoms, and the atoms will become nothing. And the wavelength will continue, breaking through the Rift at the heart of the Medusa Cascade into every dimension, every parallel, every single corner of creation. This is my ultimate victory, Doctor! The destruction of reality itself!

So what will all the Daleks do, if the bomb leaves them intact, float in the middle of absolute nothingness as nekkid tentacled things and chatter? Their casings aren't Dalek, they just house them. But they'd still exist throughout the universe, but be more difficult to get at because nothing's left that's capable of traversing such distances quickly. And I thought the trip to the bathroom could be agonizingly long at times...

So, yeah, Davros is merely insane beyond recognition, with too many cognitive neurons turning to dust. :eek:
 
But I also thought that Adelaide Brooke's suicide never made much sense. Originally, she was an inspiration to her granddaughter because of the mystery and romanticism of dying in space. But when she kills herself, how is that supposed to inspire anyone? If anything, I'd think that it would make her granddaughter go, "Space? Oh, you mean that thing that made my grandma go crazy and kill herself? No thanks. I'll pass." I mean, I expected there to be some kind of UNIT cover-up at the end of the episode to conceal the Doctor's involvement in the whole thing. Like, they would just pretend that Adelaide had died on Mars and keep the surviving astronauts in seclusion for a few months, then pretend that they had used the rocket to return to Earth.
Really what the Doctor should have done was just take everyone to a different time or planet. As far as the public knows they all died in the explosion and history continues unchanged.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top