I think a season or a few eps. short of it is a fair enough chance. People know what they like and don't well enough to decide from there.How much time should you give a show that doesn't appeal to you before you're allowed to post you think it sucks?Well, and I think this the important thing - to give things a shot. If you end up not liking it, then you don't like it. No lives will be lost.No big deal.
But what really annoys me are the folks who have seen about 2 episodes of (insert any show here) and decide it sucks. And then come on these boards and go on and on about how MUCH it sucks in that show's forum.
I know I have seen alot of that foolishness in the DS9 forum over the years. And I'm quite certain you guys in VOY have seen it alot as well.
It's just easier to root out in the DS9 forum because these guys quickly reveal themselves as not knowing much about the arc of the show. Which allows us to identify them quickly and write them off as pretenders.
You guys in VOY don't have as much of that ability. You can try to nail them on the events of a particular episode, but all they have to say is "I didn't see that particular one....but I saw all the others! Really I did! And VOY sucked!"
In DS9, we can nail them much easier for not knowing much about something that was addressed for about 10 episodes.
In fact, we have become quite adept at this.![]()
I typically give the show a season, or until it's cancelled to decide. It's not fair to judge a series based on a few episodes because they could always get better. I'm not watching it, but it seems like Dollhouse is a good example of this. The first two episodes are not all that great, but as the series goes on, it is getting better, or so I've heard.
Interesting you mentioned "Dollhouse" and I agree, it's not a very strong start and I'm not sure Dusku is a strong enough actress to convey the emotional connection to carry it. However, the concept itself is interesting and might be a better show had in been on a cable network like FX or something. I think ratings based TV & FOX in general are too fickle about giving certain shows a fair shot, not to mention Friday night prime time is a questionable time slot.