• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 4x02 - "The Griffin Incident"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    161
To say nothing of how many "teenagers" we see in movies that are actually closer to 30.

Once again, this isn't a Kurtzman-specific boogeyman, just another thing that's been bog-standard in the industry for, oh, at least a century or so.
Sitcoms about high schools have often cast actors in their twenties or thirties. There's no way those classrooms had that many kids who looked like they'd been held back about a decade due to failing, well. everything, but that's how Hollywood has worked. The talent pool of believable actors who are the precise ages of your characters can be very limited, and sometimes you just want the best performer, not the most believable looking.
 
I love his bobbed hairline from Season 3. Out of nowhere, not explained and then just went away after a while. "Jimmy Doohan with bangs? Nah, we're not doing that next year. Play around with his hair."
 
Loosely based on Robby the Robot from "Forbidden Planet", this little 1970s toy turns up in "The Griffin Incident". (I noticed the price jumps on eBay after the episode began streaming!)

The “Ups & Downs” episodes of the “What Culture” vlog are hosted by Sean Ferrick. In this week's entry, Sean was going to discuss how James T Kirk was partly inspired by the hero of the novel, "Master and Commander" (as well as Horatio Hornblower, of course), but then he realised that the first "Master and Commander" book was from 1969, so probably Kirk inspired Captain Jack Aubrey instead!

I remember going to the movie ("Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World") and noticing that its Kirk/Spock/McCoy "triumvirate" dynamic to its story would have made a great "Star Trek" episode.


TOMY Robbie windup walking robot by Ian McLean, on Flickr


The little robot and a copy of the novel, "Master and Commander" (1969), are seen in James T Kirk's bag by Ian McLean, on Flickr


"Master and Commander" by Patrick O'Brian by Ian McLean, on Flickr. Can still be found in the wild!
 
Shouldn't the future have more high tech toys than that robot? Why if he wanted Kirk could have probably given David a real robot as a gift.
 
"The Enterprise Incident." "Day of the Dove." "For the World Is Hollow..." "The Tholian Web." "The Empath." "Requiem for Methuselah." "All Our Yesterdays." All good or great episodes worthy of Seasons 1 and 2 and/or woefully underrated.
See, I really don't like the Empath or Requiem for Methuselah. I do like Is There Truth in No Beauty. Miranda is a great example of a woman just trying to do her job, constantly being sexually harassed by men, and politely declining while wishing they would all get lost. She's a heroine for our modern age! Enterprise Incident is a great episode that just needs its gaping plot holes plugged.
 
Way too young for scotty. Another bad cast.
They could easily make him look older. The point is more that they are also making him act young and unsure. He's spent years working on freighters cutting corners to keep them functioning. He might be an inexperienced officer, since we don't know when he joined Starfleet, but it is odd that he's being played as unsure and over-cautious as an engineer. I like the actor but the portrayal is definitely off.
 
This episode was an embarrassment to all those involved in making it.

If I want to watch Scifi horror I could just put on Event Horizon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bgt
Sitcoms about high schools have often cast actors in their twenties or thirties. There's no way those classrooms had that many kids who looked like they'd been held back about a decade due to failing, well. everything, but that's how Hollywood has worked. The talent pool of believable actors who are the precise ages of your characters can be very limited, and sometimes you just want the best performer, not the most believable looking.
It also has to do with labor laws. Casting actual teenagers comes with a limit in how many hours they can film in a day so they can also continue to get mandated school time.
 
Another question ... the closing shot of the Griffin being towed away while zooming in on Harper with a "ssshhh" as La'an looks on. Does that scene indicate an ongoing problem for La'an? Or is it a simple "gotcha" trope used in various horror shows/films?
 
ongoing...I mean she punched a dinosaur, and almost went Romulan last season!
 
Meanwhile, on the "boy scout" front, this also strikes me as a non-issue. It's clear in context that Carol was using the term colloquially as opposed to establishing "canon" as to whether Jim Kirk once officially belonged to a certain specific youth organization.

As in telling someone, "Don't be such a boy scout," or calling Superman a "big blue boy scout" compared to Batman. Etc.

Not every casual bit of dialogue or idiom is meant to be taken literally -- or treated as Memory Alpha fodder.
The more pertinent aspect of the line is that it confirms Jim was in David's life long enough for David to remember and have an impression of him, even if he didn't know that the guy who was visiting was his father.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top