• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 4x02 - "The Griffin Incident"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    176
The first third(?) was pretty interesting for me, but then it got really really really boring, except for the times when it does something shocking that makes you wince but didnt feel like much more than that. We weren't really learning anything new, just watching the characters continue to struggle. If there was no answer then the struggle should have been about what they choose to lose themselves over, but it never really went deeper than the first time all of them started struggling over the course of the episode.

The point where the crew beam in gives an illusion of a change in the story, but if you figure out early that they arent real then things kinda fall back into just being a different version of the same. I thought there was something to the idea that La'an, Spock and Fake Una were all talking about trying to excise the things that made them "not human" in some pursuit of normalcy, but it didnt really line up with Kirk/Fake Sam thinking about family instead or whatever fake Pike was doing, or really get any resolution. Which I suppose is the point. Hard to make an episode where no answer is the point, I suppose.

I thought the wrap up scene was rather nice. Really torn between 4, a 5 or a 6 for the poll, to the point I'll give it some thought before voting.
 
His name is part of the cover art.

Trade paperback copy of the first novel in the "Master and Commander" (Norton, 1990) series. Novel by Patrick O'Brian.

Would have been a nice in-joke to make it a Horatio Hornblower novel, instead. Roddenberry told Shatner to approach Kirk like he was Hornblower in Space.


Watched the episode last night; it's actually the first I've seen of SNW since early season 3. I uh, picked an interesting one to try. Thought it was very effective if confusing: the confusion helped until the end. Usually Trek's horror episodes end by explaining what happened, whereas now we're just left to wonder WTH? Wound up chasing it with "Trials and Tribble-lations" so I could get to sleep.
 
Would have been a nice in-joke to make it a Horatio Hornblower novel, instead. Roddenberry told Shatner to approach Kirk like he was Hornblower in Space.

Ah, but that was the point that made it so exciting. Yes, Hornblower was part of the template that was Kirk, but it seems that Kirk was part of the template that was Jack Aubrey. The "Master and Commander" books were conceived during the three seasons of TOS. As pointed out in the "Ups and Downs" vodcast from WhatCulture.


TOMY Robbie windup walking robot by Ian McLean, on Flickr
 
Ah, but that was the point that made it so exciting. Yes, Hornblower was part of the template that was Kirk, but it seems that Kirk was part of the template that was Jack Aubrey. The "Master and Commander" books were conceived during the three seasons of TOS. As pointed out in the "Ups and Downs" vodcast from WhatCulture.


TOMY Robbie windup walking robot by Ian McLean, on Flickr
And the 2003 film Master and Commander is a really good Star Trek film. ( and I'm only half joking here. ;))
 
And the 2003 film Master and Commander is a really good Star Trek film. ( and I'm only half joking here. ;))
Honestly, it's one of the movies I would've shown J.J. Abrams in some parallel universe where I had been tasked with preparing him to make a Star Trek movie. Along with The Enemy Below and Mario Camerini's Ulysses and Clint Eastwood's Unforgiven (imagine this movie but In Spaaaace!).

(I do think it's that latter thing that SNW really gets. People complain about "gimmick episodes": but Trek at its root was really designed to be a vehicle for "gimmick episodes." Looking at Gene's 1964 pitch document, it's wall to wall "gimmick episodes" and that's the core selling-point of the concept.)
 
Finally got around to watching it, and thought it was a bit rote for a horror entry. I liked the concept of a division twelve--the truth is out there! References to Kirk's choosing career over family was a nice beginning to flesh out his character. I already knew the rescue team was most certainly not that. La'an stabbing Kirk took me by surprise, and I'm not sure about how readily it was swept under the rug. Hopefully there will be ramifications of some kind. Pike cutting up his fingers was actually humorous to my addled mind, but I liked his account of the creepy old barn at the end. Just couldn't get too excited about the show, ultimately and unfortunately. I guess I can be generous and give it an 8? And usually I'm very easy to please when it comes to things Trek.
 
I would SO love to write a Division 12 novel.
Well there's certainly a sequel opportunity available to be written. The Division 12 origin story was published by Pocket books in 2013, that too by an avowed fan of yours, Dayton Ward, actually writing out of The Eugenics Wars universe (Roberta Lincoln, etc). The book is From History's Shadow. So in a way, you've already written the prequel to a Division 12 novel. 👍

Formally, Ward was writing about * Majestic-12 * of ufo maybe-not-just-lore fame. The SNW writers were manifestly referring to Majestic 12 with their Division 12 mentions in this episode. (as they have clearly leaned into ufology periodically ever since SNW S1E1).

(by the way re. The Eugenics Wars inspiration, in his book's Acknowledgements, Ward writes
"I’d always wanted to tell a story in a vein similar to what Greg Cox accomplished in The Eugenics Wars: The Rise and Fall of Khan Noonien Singh, with its blending of real history and “Star Trek history.” They are among my very favorite Star Trek novels, and I’m grateful that Greg gave me his blessing to try my hand at a story that sort of dovetails with his books." )

Anyway this is my comment on it from r/startrek ;
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
Pleased to share that this + parallel comments in trek-themed subs have gotten over 8,000 views:.
One of the parallel ones, on r/strangenewworlds , offers a little more background about snw executive producer Rod Roddenberry's awareness of the topic.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

So to echo other fans here- I certainly would also love to see a Division 12 novel of yours...: a sequel to Ward's In History's Shadow. And I wouldn't want to stifle creativity (or jeopardize anyone's future copyrightability! =) ) by suggesting a frame, but I feel it's safe enough to say that the name discrepancy between a 20th-century "Majestic-12" and 22nd century Starfleet "Division-12" inevitably invites intriguing historical continuity-building questions from prospective readers' minds 🙂
 
Previously mentioned in "Terrarium", but there's no Memory Alpha article about them, presumably due to some sort of conspiracy/cover-up.

EDIT: And weirdly the line about Division 12 was omitted from the subtitles for "Hegemony":

Subtitle: this region is legendary for
Subtitle: its tales of strange phenomena.
Audio only: The kind of thing Division 12 usually looks into
Subtitle: Ghost stories at sea.
Hi - I'm not aware of Hegemony (I or II) mentioning Division 12. Seems the quote you mentioned is Terrarium's; Can you localize which Hegemony episode and timestamp someone mentions Division 12?
 
Well there's certainly a sequel opportunity available to be written. The Division 12 origin story was published by Pocket books in 2013, that too by an avowed fan of yours, Dayton Ward, actually writing out of The Eugenics Wars universe (Roberta Lincoln, etc). The book is From History's Shadow. So in a way, you've already written the prequel to a Division 12 novel. 👍

Formally, Ward was writing about * Majestic-12 * of ufo maybe-not-just-lore fame. The SNW writers were manifestly referring to Majestic 12 with their Division 12 mentions in this episode. (as they have clearly leaned into ufology periodically ever since SNW S1E1).

(by the way re. The Eugenics Wars inspiration, in his book's Acknowledgements, Ward writes
"I’d always wanted to tell a story in a vein similar to what Greg Cox accomplished in The Eugenics Wars: The Rise and Fall of Khan Noonien Singh, with its blending of real history and “Star Trek history.” They are among my very favorite Star Trek novels, and I’m grateful that Greg gave me his blessing to try my hand at a story that sort of dovetails with his books." )

Anyway this is my comment on it from r/startrek ;
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
Pleased to share that this + parallel comments in trek-themed subs have gotten over 8,000 views:.
One of the parallel ones, on r/strangenewworlds , offers a little more background about snw executive producer Rod Roddenberry's awareness of the topic.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

So to echo other fans here- I certainly would also love to see a Division 12 novel of yours...: a sequel to Ward's In History's Shadow. And I wouldn't want to stifle creativity (or jeopardize anyone's future copyrightability! =) ) by suggesting a frame, but I feel it's safe enough to say that the name discrepancy between a 20th-century "Majestic-12" and 22nd century Starfleet "Division-12" inevitably invites intriguing historical continuity-building questions from prospective readers' minds 🙂
I've been catching up on recent decades' lit history & NuTrek production.

And now I actually feel that the weaving of the majestic-12 narrative into the Star Trek universe, even by way of beta canon, carries historical value. To that end, I wanted to catalog those developments here. Therefore this post is less of a reply, and more of a reference point (for the benefit of the next person).

Following DS9's "Little Green Men" (LGM) episode of course, both @Greg Cox and @Dayton Ward have by turns contributed to integrating the majestic-twelve concept into Star Trek, initially by way of LGM characters Wainwright and Carlson.

• The Aliens Are Coming! (DW 2000) [from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds III] [Wainwright]
• The Eugenics Wars volume 1 (GC 2001) [Area51, Carlson]
• The Eugenics Wars volume 2 (GC 2002) [Area51, S-4, Carlson, O'Donnell, references The Aliens Are Coming]
• From History's Shadow (DW 2013) [MJ-12, Carlson, Wainwright, Marshall, references The Eugenics Wars]
• Elusive Salvation (DW 2016) [MJ-12, Carlson, Wainwright]
• Hearts and Minds (DW 2017) [MJ-12, traces the majestic offshoot unit __31 through the mid-21st century, Heffron, Wheeler]

Key protagonists associated with the majestic narrative:
Wainwright, Prof. / Dr. Carlson , also: Shannon O'Donnell, Heffron, Wheeler

This would all seem like it would remain in an obscure corner of the Star Trek beta lit universe, were it not for the following developments:
• The coterie of authors Cox, Ward, David Mack, Una McCormack, & Kirsten Beyer (not intended to be an exhaustive list), has representation to the screen franchise (alpha canon) producers in the form of Beyer.

• As of 2021, Ward serves as a 'contract consultant' to CBS with the stated purpose of reviewing advance Trek scripts and feeding back notes as regards Star Trek canon (no doubt distinguishing alpha and beta canon) , even once servicing a podcast out of Alex Kurtzman's wine cellar:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

On the writers' manifest influence on on-screen canon:
• the concept of Section 31's 'Control' (David Mack) became a dedicated DIS episode. https://memory-beta.fandom.com/wiki/Control_(novel)
• Number One's naming as Una came from David Mack.


----
All this combined with
1) Rod Roddenberry's aforementioned longtime friendship with Jeremy Corbell, over which he invited Jeremy to STLV 2023 to speak on "real UFOs", and
2) DIS & SA director Olatunde Osunsanmi acutely expressed awareness of the post-Grusch UAP 'Legacy Program' disclosure era: https://trekmovie.com/2024/11/05/in...g-a-fun-spy-adventure-in-star-treks-lost-era/ ,
then we have the recipe for expansive receptivity on part of on-screen production for weaving Majestic-12 / Legacy Program narrative into on-screen Trek.

The Trek fanbase writ large tends to compartmentalize (ruthlessly, if I may say) the meticulously-conserved science-fiction alpha canon from a possibly-occluded-but-tabooed contemporary history. Therefore shunting awareness-building of an under-disclosed 20th-21st century 'Legacy Program' through the Star Trek universe's alpha canon - but in a way that is overt, like by breaking the fourth wall in referencing it - should have the effect of shaking the fanbase alive to the possibility of undisclosed real-world governmental study of UAP.
Dayton's "Hearts and Minds" traces an in-universe continuity from Majestic twelve to Section 31 - the common thread being an undisclosed clandestine agency free from oversight and run amok, presenting an affront to democratic accountability (a concept, as we know, that is applicable both in- and out- of universe). Given how many well-placed real-world scientists & engineers with grass-roots advocacy potential lie within the Trek fanbase, a disclosure campaign of something once tabooed - but laundered through the Trek universe & said well-placed fanbase - would go a long way toward restoring that missing democratic accountability.

Which isn't to say it wouldn't be an enormous challenge - my own rather unscientific survey of trekbbs itself of whenever the topic came up, mostly via these two threads:
yielded 20 users with the following opinion breakdown:
6 'debunkers - this topic is bunk' , 5 'may be worth looking into an occluded history side' ; and 11 'aware but on the fence' - (my own posture is particularly aligned with user @Zachary Smith 's :
The frustrating thing with Rosewell is this though: if there is NO truth to it (and I'm not advocating there is particularly) someone went to a HELL of a lot of trouble and performed serious in-depth research to hoax up the Majestic-12 documents. The sheer amount of research required to make them historically credible with all the of various members and their histories dove-tailing and making sure that many little-known or previously unknown meetings cited in the documents could be corroberated by unimpeachable sources (the fact that meetings occurred--not the subject of those meetings) is phenomenal.

Whatever Rosewell may or may NOT have been, the normal slip-shod, hook-or-crook kind of research normally done by UFO "researchers" didn't happen here. If such documents are fakes, someone must have spent hundreds of man-hours digging through archives to make sure every detail jived because there has been, after twenty years of searching, not a single smoking gun found proving that the events recounted in the papers did NOT happen (ex. some member of the group being out of the country when the papers said he was in a meeting in DC or such).

If the MJ-12 documents are a hoax, it's first rate and I wonder who had the time, means and motive to do that. That would be a story by itself.

That was about money. AND it was proven to be a hoax in pretty short order.

The MJ-12 stuff does NOT have a direct path to anyone with a monied interest in the matter and a hoaxer would have no obvious way of ensuring a return on the investment made on the effort of manufacturing the hoax. Sure, he could put the stuff together, get it into the public arena, write a UFO book about it and hope to get paid. I doubt though UFO books are THAT lucrative a field and, again, it would be a crap shoot. Some first-rate, VERY high-quality research was conducted to "hoax" these papers. Research which would be time-consuming and expensive and would have tobe done by examining archives in DC and various presidential libraries and several universities. A LOT of time and a LOT of money was spent to falsify these papers, if they are not valid. The detail is such that you just don't get it from cracking open a couple encyclopedias. If you haven't studied the Majestic-12 documents AND, much more importantly than the documents themselves, the RELATIONSHIPS of the people cited to be participants, you probably cannot begin to appreciate the incredible quality of any "hoaxing" done here.

I have a BA in History and I can appreciate the masterful job that was done to "hoax" the MJ-12 documents--IF they are a hoax. The internal consistancy of the histories of the "participants" is extremely well-researched and can be corroberated by many unimpeachable resources. Again, the fact that NO ONE, in 20+ years since those papers appeared, has managed to find an inconsistency demonstrating a flaw in the relationships of over a dozen people, any event to disrupt the time-line and/or the interactions of the "participants" over course of several years indicates a hoax of incredible quality.

Or, there's more to the MJ-12 papers.

SOMETHING very strange went on here. I'm not at all sure it has anything to do with aliens. But there's more than the obvious.
). So if the fanbase is at all reflective of vocal trekbbs users, then that's a lot of contestable territory with 30% of the base expected to push back hard, and 25% to offer tacit support, with 55% falling along the spectrum in between.
I bet a lot of social issues the Trek universe has confronted over its long history have demonstrated a comparable spread at the time they were addressed.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top