• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 3x04 - "A Space Adventure Hour"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    132
We might assume that they not only rounded the bases, some producer ten years from now will use the moment to argue that Spock has another relative we have never heard of before.
 
Deleted scene from the episode

(a shuttle lands on Vulcan and M'Benga comes out).

M'Benga: Live Long and Prosper.

Hooded Vulcan: Welcome home, Doctor M'Benga. You have done well.

M'Benga: I have good news for you, my friend Stonn. Thanks to my holodeck manipulation, La'an is now dating Spock.

Hooded Vulcan: Excellent. Everything is going as planned.
 
Last edited:
It was mentioned very quickly, but Ortegas' slap on the wrist from last week got even weaker as its said that she was put back on active duty before her rehab training was finished.
 
I actually have a treknology question:
Did we ever have had the situation before, that a character was "fooled" about a real person being actually a hologram instead?

E.g. in "Insurrection" the Son'a were fooled by the holographic simulation of the mcguffin device. But they didn't mistake actual people, and they were in a high-stress situation.

But off the top of my head I can't remember anyone (who knows about holograms) mistake one for a real, breathing human being with emotions, expressions, smell, personal backstory, etc.
In my headcanon holographic people were only as "realistic" to Trek characters as present day HD video-game characters would be to someone from the 18th century.
Like I never thought Riker was "fooled" by the hologram. I thought he was "impressed" by it, the way my grandad would be playing "Red Dead Redemption 2".
Could me my memory though.

Only thing I can remember is Barclay's "end program?". But that was more a joke about his nervosity (and MORIARTY - a hologram himself - not being able to spot the difference!)
 
I actually have a treknology question:
Did we ever have had the situation before, that a character was "fooled" about a real person being actually a hologram instead?

E.g. in "Insurrection" the Son'a were fooled by the holographic simulation of the mcguffin device. But they didn't mistake actual people, and they were in a high-stress situation.

But off the top of my head I can't remember anyone (who knows about holograms) mistake one for a really, breathing human with emotions, expressions, smell etc.
In my headcanon holographic people were only as "realistic" to Trek characters as present day HD video-game characters would be to someone from the 18th century.
Like I never thought Riker was "fooled" by the hologram. I thought he was "impressed" by it, the way my grandad would be playing "Red Dead Redemption 2".
Could me my memory though.

Only thing I can remember is Barclay's "end program?". But that was more a joke about his nervosity (and MORIARTY - a hologram himself - not being able to spot the difference!)
Ship in a Bottle:Laforge?
 
Episodes like this would land better if there were more normal episodes around them. I really miss the science fiction in this science fiction TV show.

(I don't know enough about murder mysteries to know if this was a good example of the genre or not, but it felt kind of simple. So not?)

Anyway. I liked the retro Enterprise design. One of my coworkers built the model, it was a pretty quick one-week job. Design supplied by the SNW art department.

There was a nice long The Cage-style pullback from the saucer & fading into the magazine cover that we did but got cut. I'm sad to see it removed because it was probably the best look at the design given it's limited appearance.
How long before that design turns up in the Trek Art Forum?
 
Loved it. Agent Uhura’s speech really nailed it.
I loved her speech as well. Overall I loved the episode! Thought it was a lot of fun, had a lot of in jokes about TOS' production history (and to me, Mount did a good approximation of Roddenberry's voice and style here and there, and he must have loved having that bit of a gut added in makeup when he rested his hands there when he was packing to leave)

For me, just a fun episode to take a break from the heavy atmosphere of the opening of the season. Sometimes that's needed to not bog things down in being too dramatic.
 
They could have been a little more explicit, but the audience is supposed to be able to connect some dots ourselves after all. The gizmo La'an was wearing on her neck was why the computer was able to tailor the program to her so well. Later holodecks don't have that. Also the people were one of the reasons the computer was so stressed, so early production versions have no interactive holograms, and then just simple ones, before the TNG upgrades allow the top of the line ones with less computer stress.

I did like the connection to Voyager's Holodeck incompatibility. It makes sense that the computer is designed to draw energy and computational power as needed, and the best way to prevent a runaway nonessential program is to air gap the system.
 
Btw I think it would have been way better if the fictional sci-fi show was "Captain Proton".

For how much of a (self-)TOS insert it was, IMO they clearly didn't go far enough - certainly "Wormhole X-Treme" this was not.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top