• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 3x05 - "Imposters"

Engage!


  • Total voters
    256
That's fine... it's just odd that she doesn't protest when she finds out Shaw called Starfleet and that another ship has arrived to meet them. In fact, she just ignores it for the most part.

Yea, that's a fair point and a thought I had while watching. I guess now that Picard is with her she feels safer - rather than Picard telling Starfleet Beverly was in trouble before he got to her.
 
How does Shaw know that he “snogged” a woman on Baku? That doesn’t seem like the sort of information that would be public.
 
It seems like Jacks ability to go "Jason Bourne" might be linked to him detecting Changelings nearby.

That could be why they want him.

However Jack's doing it, it's a genuine threat to the Changelings operation.

How does Shaw know that he “snogged” a woman on Baku? That doesn’t seem like the sort of information that would be public.
Could've been from a report from somebody else who was on the same mission
It's not like JLP accomplished "Insurrection" by himself, he had a team with him.
 
How does Shaw know that he “snogged” a woman on Baku? That doesn’t seem like the sort of information that would be public.

Ehhh...sometimes you just gotta make up your own head canon for small things like this. The Baku incident would have been known and at the end of the movie Picard said he had some leave coming up to be with her. Maybe he spent some time with her on the planet and it was somewhat known they were in a relationship if he took an extended leave there after the incident. Maybe it was just some gossip Shaw heard over the years.
 
How does Shaw know that he “snogged” a woman on Baku? That doesn’t seem like the sort of information that would be public.

Same as my point about the Devron system events that literally never happened. There's no reason for a random Captain to know these things... unless he was hate-reading up on Picard the same way some Trek fans continue to hate-watch their least favorite shows :D
 
It seems like Jacks ability to go "Jason Bourne" might be linked to him detecting Changelings nearby.

That could be why they want him.

However Jack's doing it, it's a genuine threat to the Changelings operation.

The fake security team seemed to be talking to Jack like they expected he'd want to go with them.
 
Another 10.

It seems that these rogue Changelings have spent so much time acting/hiding as Humans, that they have apparently begun to evolve into them.
I suppose if one holds the same form for overtly extended periods of time, thing start to stick.

It didn't occur to me that Jack might have Borg nanites built into his system from his father, until this episode and he hears Beverly's voice in his head.
I guess he's a brand new kind of Borg and the Changelings want to use him to be their foundation for a new kind of Collective.

A Borg/Changeling King ???
:shrug:
 
They also attacked federation ships and interests during DS9.
That doesn't mean he holds a grudge, at least not with the maquis. They had border conflicts with the Federation before TNG. Picard probably lost a couple good friends during these days. And he didn't seem to hold a grudge or acted like an ass like O'Brien did in that episode.


The Borg on the other hand....
 
The fake security team seemed to be talking to Jack like they expected he'd want to go with them.
There's rumor that Jack's connected to the pah wraiths, and the changelings are looking for their own Sisko, so to speak. Doesn't explain why Jack kills the changelings if the supposed pah wraith takes control--like you mentioned, one would think the pah wraith would join them.
Same as my point about the Devron system events that literally never happened. There's no reason for a random Captain to know these things... unless he was hate-reading up on Picard the same way some Trek fans continue to hate-watch their least favorite shows :D
Starfleet could make Picard's Q encounters mandatory reading for captains. I think Voyager indicated they did.
 
We are forgetting that the Changelings have the ability to force one of their own to take on a permanent solid form with fully functioning organs, as they did to Odo.

Maybe they found a way to parley this ability into their normal ability set, at the same time maybe this ability was always present but was seen as abhorrent by the Changelings or has a big downside, like making them act animalistic when emotional or eventually becoming permanent or something.
 
^Nah, Something was done to them....not a natural ability of their species. The question is by who, themelves? The Borg? The Pah'Wraith?
 
As good as both actors were, Picard nursing a grudge over the Maquis knowing that the Cardassians eventually go to war with the Federation for much the same reason the "terrorists" do is a stunningly massive case of hypocrisy. Especially given the episode cites all the times Picard went against Starfleet including Insurrection.
Of course it's hypocrisy but it make sense in character. A personal betrayal is a blind spot for Picard.
I think the show was surprisingly clear that the antagonist's grasp on Vulcan logic is complete nonsense.
You can use logic to justify anything...Admiral Janey....or something.
It's all subjective of course, but I do think the writing is better this season even if the tone and style are similar.
Again, my larger point is not that this season is better or worse (obviously subjective) but that claims that Season 3 is "real Trek" or similar buzz words, and therefore more worthy is superficial at best. That it appeals to many is great and I appreciate how this season is going on, especially in a way that is generating interest. That it is used as a perfection stick to bash past seasons with is less appealing and will go a long way in spoiling the milk, as it were.
 
We are forgetting that the Changelings have the ability to force one of their own to take on a permanent solid form with fully functioning organs, as they did to Odo.

Maybe they found a way to parley this ability into their normal ability set, at the same time maybe this ability was always present but was seen as abhorrent by the Changelings or has a big downside, like making them act animalistic when emotional or eventually becoming permanent or something.

Eh, I dunno. Beverly seemed to imply that Jack's had bad dreams since childhood, and I would have to think she would have done a DNA scan of him some time in the last 15+ years.
 
That would certainly explain the 'flashing red eye' thing.
I don't remember the growing tentacles being a part of them though.
I have to go back and watch the DS9 episodes with them and see if I forgot something.
That's in Jack's head. I don't think Keiko or Jake ever revealed what they saw in their head when they were possessed.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top