• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 1x03 - "Ghosts of Illyria"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    223
Weird that La’an kept the name. It would be like keeping the name Hitler.

It's possible that they didn't let her change the name.

She is "infected".

It's possible that every one with DNA from Khan were marked with that name specifically so that regular people would think about it before they fucked a superperson and made another generation of augment babies.

The choice would be Take the name of we sterilize you.
 
Denobulans, according to Phlox, practiced generic engineering all the time. Does that mean they never joined the Federation? I doubt they'd just give it up...

I think the early Federation let a lot of things slide to expand their membership and didn't double down on certain hard and fast rules until many years later. They likely joined not long after 2161 but the whole genetic engineering thing didn't become a real issue until later.
 
Boy, everyone on that ship has a deep dark secret!

This episode was a bit weaker than the previous two, mostly, for me, because they failed to create a lot of suspense.

That said, some very good points were raised, particularly by Una in her last scene. It's true, in fiction, the outcast often manages to save the day, then everyone realizes they've misjudged them.Pity for those who can't, or don't get the opportunity to prove themselves "worthy".
 
This did have a very strong TOS vibe to it. "Infection carried by light waves!" Without ten pages of technobabble to explain it at that. That's such a TOS and even pre-VOY way to handle a problem on a starship that I really appreciated that the problem was discovered, analyzed and solved in about 50 minutes.
 
I understand the concept is to build season, perhaps multi season long character arcs, but to what end? Una said it well in the idea that Pike keeping this secret could jeopardize his career. Same for Una keeping M’Benga’s secret. And at some point, both secrets will come out. And it won’t be good for anyone. Court martial episode coming up? Appearance by Samuel T. Cogley perhaps?
The answer to what end is likely what I said earlier. They're setting up why Kirk ultimately ends up in command of the Enterprise, when the dust clears, instead of Number One.
 
Two genetically-augmented officers on one ship would definitely be an issue for her Captain. I can see both women being a serious problem down the road for Pike and hasten his promotion to Fleet Captain and replacement as commanding officer.
 
I think the early Federation let a lot of things slide to expand their membership and didn't double down on certain hard and fast rules until many years later. They likely joined not long after 2161 but the whole genetic engineering thing didn't become a real issue until later.

Pulaski made superhumans, which turned into a plauge that tried to kill all the baseline humans.

PS

Last week, they used genetic engineering to disguise themselves as an alien.

Doh?
 
I enjoyed it.

Yeah, M'Benga was an ass, understandable but an ass. Would he ever tell her daughter what happened?

I bet if it happened on Voyager, B'Elanna would have made Doc glow....
 
Shades of both McCoy having to pull the plug on his father in the years before TOS and Dr. Emory Erickson trying to get back his own son, lost during early transporter testing.
 
Two genetically-augmented officers on one ship would definitely be an issue for her Captain. I can see both women being a serious problem down the road for Pike and hasten his promotion to Fleet Captain and replacement as commanding officer.

Shame would have made use that the Khans only made babies with baseline humans, the name may still be there, but the super powers were cut in half every generation since the 1990s.

If Una loses her human rights because Supermen are not people, that may explain why her voice is used for ships computer libraries for years to come without remunerating her heirs.
 
This one will get a 10 from me.
I was quite entertained even though the pacing seemed a bit slow at times.

I think Chief Kyle's line about 'who knows what I would have beamed back' or whatever the exact quote was, was meant to be a wink wink to Mirror Mirror. Beaming through an ion storm and all that.
It's a lot closer to the line from TMP...

Kirk: "Star Fleet do you have them?"
Star Fleet: "Enterprise..., what we got back didn't live long... Fortunately."

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top