• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

USS Enterprise (eventually) on Discovery?

Now that is interesting, Timo ... I just went back to watch the sequence in question and there's no appearance of a secretary anywhere in that scene. There's a male officer at communications. A yeoman who comes to Pike's side with a form that Pike refuses, crewmen at navigation and helm, a male crewman at engineering, and a security officer next to the turbolift.

Spock moves to his console (which seems closer to the main viewer than it should be) and is looking directly at the slides from the side and doesn't appear to acknowledge any kind of assistant.

Do you have a source indicating the existence of this secretary? Or did you mean that the scene was shot with a production member off-camera, watching Nimoy's gestures, and changing the slides accordingly?
I've seen a photo. It was supposedly filmed with her in shot, then cropped when someone realised it looked more mysterious and high tech if we just saw his gestures.
 
Just yer standard Vulcan expression of serene confidence in one's superiority...

I wonder if this makeup job wasn't one of the reasons Fontana decided there would be multiple Vulcans aboard the ship at this time?

Timo Saloniemi
 
I'm a little surprised they gave it the same registry # as the Connie model in Marcus' office. They had to know we would eventually see both of them.

Well it was a deleted scene, the name and registry could have been temp, or they moved it from the TOS Connie to the other ship.

We don't know when in development they decided to remove it.
 
I suppose an interesting scenario is what if they do one of those episodes which they've done in everyone of the spin-off shows set in the 'near future' relative to the show's present. There were the future scenes in 'All Good Things', there was the holodeck scenes on 'These are the Voyages' and so on. Imagine if they did one of those for DSC? Of course they'd probably set it post TMP.
 
When they did it in ENT, they showed exact replicas of TOS interiors (technically dragged to the show's present from said near-future, but still). Perhaps redoing that would be too repetitive to start with?

Milking TMP interior themes for greater visual worth without doing 1:1 replicas, the way they toyed with TOS elements on the Kelvin, might be cool. Especially if they dared do the moustaches and hairdos, just like Rogue One had the guts to do. (Mind you, the regulation sideburns look amazing on Chris Pine. Good call.)

Timo Saloniemi
 
I suppose an interesting scenario is what if they do one of those episodes which they've done in everyone of the spin-off shows set in the 'near future' relative to the show's present. There were the future scenes in 'All Good Things', there was the holodeck scenes on 'These are the Voyages' and so on. Imagine if they did one of those for DSC? Of course they'd probably set it post TMP.

I think that gimmick's time has passed. It was always kind of cheesy when other shows did it, anyway.
 
I suppose an interesting scenario is what if they do one of those episodes which they've done in everyone of the spin-off shows set in the 'near future' relative to the show's present. There were the future scenes in 'All Good Things', there was the holodeck scenes on 'These are the Voyages' and so on. Imagine if they did one of those for DSC? Of course they'd probably set it post TMP.
I wish they'd do 'Yesterday's Enterprise' style alternative future story and get Shatner as old Kirk. Not gonna happen, but it would be glorious!
 
I really want to see Pike's Enterprise. I like Bruce Greenwood but wish they didn't cast Pike older so that a whole gen thinks of him as Kirk's father figure. I think Hunter's Pike and is one of the best characters in Star Trek. Like a younger, more flawed Picard. Number one opens up a whole world of Spock/Data behavior. There's also something about having a completely different "family" walking the same decks of ol' 1701.
 
I really want to see Pike's Enterprise. I like Bruce Greenwood but wish they didn't cast Pike older so that a whole gen thinks of him as Kirk's father figure. I think Hunter's Pike and is one of the best characters in Star Trek. Like a younger, more flawed Picard. Number one opens up a whole world of Spock/Data behavior. There's also something about having a completely different "family" walking the same decks of ol' 1701.
I'd also watch this. Maybe Number One is Spock's lost sister ;)
 
I'd also watch this. Maybe Number One is Spock's lost sister ;)
I was really hoping Burnham was Number One. She still could be. They do have to explain how a human got into the Vulcan SA. She'd have to have a brain like a computer to keep up with the more advanced Vulcans. :bolian:
 
I was really hoping Burnham was Number One. She still could be. They do have to explain how a human got into the Vulcan SA. She'd have to have a brain like a computer to keep up with the more advanced Vulcans. :bolian:
One does not keep information from a Mentat :vulcan:

:techman:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top