I'm not a fan of TOS-R due to the CGI looking so out of place compared to 60s style, but I would like to see this one. The starships in fourmation are just lame.
Plynch:
There are a couple CGI shots that look bad in the Remastered Version. In fact, there is even a special effect of an enemy ship firing in one of the episodes (can't remember which one) and it looks like some kid drew a green smear across the screen with fluorescent paint. However,
overall I think the majority of the effects actually enhance the Original episodes, though. And I own and have watched the Original Versions many times over.
I mean, it's the option of watching a model (which is sometimes on a string) or a really cool looking CGI shot.
And by the way, I actually hate the overuse of CGI most of the time in movies, too. Like "I Am Legend", "Die Another Day", "Van Helsing", and the Mummy sequels. It just looks absolutely fake and ridiculous to me.
I mean, for me it is totally a jaw dropping experience to watch the Remastered Version. But everyone has their own unique tastes I suppose.