The scene where Sisko knocked Q's ass to the floor was pretty good.
What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?
- Thread starter Amasov
- Start date
That's why I only watch TOS off VHS.
Mine Is I'm ok with discoprise being the new canon representation of a pre Motion picture constitution class
"Fury" of Voyager is an underrated episode. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Kes might've deserved a better send-off, but this episode also has valid points and fun time-traveling quandaries. It shows how the passage of time can sour even the fondest memories and turn one against one's closest allies. The script is, in a way, a tribute to the vagabond, the solitary and the aging, whom uniformed memebers of society forget and neglect.
Nice zinger dude! I mean, if it wasn't in a thread called Controversial Opinions it probably would have made a lot more sense to post this, but good job anyway you little scamp.
No need to be huffy and get bent out of shape, dawg! Fill your heart with joy. Peace and tranquility be with you!
Thank you, laughter is a great way to start the day!VOY and DSC are better than TOS and DS9.
I completely forgot about that scene! Thanks!
That's how it's done!VOY and DSC are better than TOS and DS9.
Some opinions that come to mind:
Star Trek IV, while not bad, is extremely overrated.
Star Trek Beyond is excellent, easily both the best Kelvinverse movie and the best Trek movie since First Contact. Its tone/style is what the Kelvinverse should have been from the beginning
Star Trek Into Darkness is "so bad its good". Its objectively terrible in many ways, and as someone who considers TWOK to be not just their favorite Trek film but their favorite film period I should hate it, but I find it unintentionally hilarious and enjoy Cumberbatch in it (even if they really, really shouldn't have whitewashed Khan).
Star Trek Insurrection is the worst non-reboot film, TFF and TMP are nowhere near as bad.
Star Trek 2009 is the worst piece of official media with the Star Trek name slapped on it.
Enterprise had some really good episodes to go along with the shit, and Season 4 is actually kind of overrated.
I probably have more, but this is what comes to mind immediately.
Star Trek IV, while not bad, is extremely overrated.
Star Trek Beyond is excellent, easily both the best Kelvinverse movie and the best Trek movie since First Contact. Its tone/style is what the Kelvinverse should have been from the beginning
Star Trek Into Darkness is "so bad its good". Its objectively terrible in many ways, and as someone who considers TWOK to be not just their favorite Trek film but their favorite film period I should hate it, but I find it unintentionally hilarious and enjoy Cumberbatch in it (even if they really, really shouldn't have whitewashed Khan).
Star Trek Insurrection is the worst non-reboot film, TFF and TMP are nowhere near as bad.
Star Trek 2009 is the worst piece of official media with the Star Trek name slapped on it.
Enterprise had some really good episodes to go along with the shit, and Season 4 is actually kind of overrated.
I probably have more, but this is what comes to mind immediately.
I don’t count the reboot films as canon.
Controversial opinion: Canon status means nothing to personal enjoyment.
For me TOS is pretty much the only canon. The rest is a whole lot of fun.
For me TOS is pretty much the only canon. The rest is a whole lot of fun.
A-fkn-men!
I agree that Voyager is better than The Original Series. But only if we ignore the time travel episodes.
I've come to have similar feelings about Discovery. There are absolutely some unintentionally funny moments in it.
Similar threads
- Locked
