• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

I probably feel very "off" to people who knew me in my teens or twenties. And that's nowhere near seventy something years.
Off as in, he stopped giving a shit. He doesn't look, sound or act like Kor. There's no Kor core to grab on to that makes him connected to TOS beyond the name.

I probably feel off too but I still have something people recognize.
 
Kang & Kor: "How did Kirk die? Was it a glorious death befitting such a warrior?"
Me: "A
rusty bolt broke, squashing Kirk with a metal walkway.
"
Never meet your heroes or your aged opponents.
 
Kang & Kor: "How did Kirk die? Was it a glorious death befitting such a warrior?"
Me: "A
rusty bolt broke, squashing Kirk with a metal walkway.
"
Never meet your heroes or your aged opponents.

I think that's unfair. Kirk's death was very heroic. He'd just nearly fallen off the bridge to his death, only barely gotten off it alive, but he unhesitatingly went back out onto the bridge that had just almost killed him, because he still had a job to do and people to protect. That's profoundly heroic and profoundly in character, but in such a casual, matter-of-fact way that people tend to overlook it.
 
I think that's unfair. Kirk's death was very heroic. He'd just nearly fallen off the bridge to his death, only barely gotten off it alive, but he unhesitatingly went back out onto the bridge that had just almost killed him, because he still had a job to do and people to protect. That's profoundly heroic and profoundly in character, but in such a casual, matter-of-fact way that people tend to overlook it.

And Kirk left an eternity in paradise to save 230 million people who will never know he even existed.

That’s pretty fucking heroic.

The bridge thing doesn’t matter.

That’s what really happened.
 
Kirk's death is fine, save for the bridge falling. Show an explosion, Picard has to follow up on the mission, then finds Kirk.

Boom. Scene is so much better.
 
Kirk's death is fine, save for the bridge falling. Show an explosion, Picard has to follow up on the mission, then finds Kirk.

Boom. Scene is so much better.

Why would Kirk com back as a fat old man?

I don't think he did.

But every time he came back as a version of himself younger, smarter and faster, he failed, and everyone died, or got eaten by the Nexus.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top