• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Walking Dead Season 6 Discussion

The fact that we were supposed to view the negotiations from the point of view of Maggie out-smarting Gregory also makes me wonder.

Is it possible that Gregory got absolutely everything he wanted from these people?
 
There's a phrase for this: Preemptive Strike.

They know that Negan is a threat. They have been attacked by Negan's forces. And they know that if Negan was aware of their settlement, he'd be doing the same sorts of things to them as he's done to Hilltop.

With that knowledge at hand, only a complete fool would just sit around twiddling their thumbs waiting to be attacked themselves. Doubly so when they've have to face several similar villains in the past. Their encounter with the Governor alone practically demands that they go on the offensive while the advantage is still theirs.

Hux explained it well enough:

I doing think anyone is suggesting they don't deal with Negan; its more the nonchalant manner of just assuming they can deal with it without any serious consequences. Alexandria is still hugely vulnerable but they're happily inviting danger.

Exactly. If this seek and destroy mission fails to do anything--other than send Negan on the rampage, most of the ASZ residents are still sheep / target practice. The few experienced members cannot assume they can just handle everyone, or if some of their best are killed off, there would not much left to prevent the rest of ASZ from being wiped off the map.

I'm saying the characters need to embrace their never-too-far-away mortality, since in the past, they have almost lost everyone on more than one occasion. many times they almost lost everyone. Think of their dealing with Terminus--if not for Carol and Tyreese just happening to come across Martin, no plan, amount of bravado, or anything else would have prevented the Termites from slaughtering Rick's group.

If the next few episodes involve planning, reconnaissance and a general sense of battening down the hatches at Alexandria before beginning, then fine. But Rick didn't seem to be suggesting that though; he seemed to be suggesting... We just go in and kill Negan. Easy.

True--and only two months after the Wolves and mass zombie attack, the residents are no closer to being seasoned combatants ready for the kind of people working for Negan. Their walls are not even secure yet, but they are willing to open up a large conflict? Or assume its going to be something they are guaranteed to win?
 
It hasn't been seen clearly, but I think the idea is that the walls have been repaired and extended to new areas. The free standing bits we've seen in recent episodes are parts of the old wall that haven't been repurposed.
 
It's the design. Anyone is free to walk right up the wall.

I would like to see Negan and the Wolves delt with and trade routes starting to get made with the surviving communities. Maybe bring those cops back in the fold or even those held up at the old folks home back at the start of the series.
 
It's the design. Anyone is free to walk right up the wall.

I would like to see Negan and the Wolves delt with and trade routes starting to get made with the surviving communities. Maybe bring those cops back in the fold or even those held up at the old folks home back at the start of the series.
Those 2 groups are several states away at this point and the gang in the old folks home is dead.
 
Those 2 groups are several states away at this point and the gang in the old folks home is dead.

I heard that about the Vatos...but I was hoping that the leader made it out...and possible meet up with the Fear group. Speaking of Fear...do we do a separate thread for it?
 
Why are people assuming Rick and company are all just going to ride into Negan's camp, whooping and hollering and firing off their guns like something out of Blazing Saddles? We've already seen that they're smart and capable enough to recon places and make tactical plans, so why not this time? There are four episodes left. Plenty of time to gather intel.

Obviously it's going to go tits up regardless, but that doesn't mean they'll just go running into battle without figuring out who they're dealing with first. They're overconfident, sure, likely after they hit the high score on Left4Dead in the mid-season premiere, but also Daryl has them convinced (somehow) that Negan's numbers are exaggerated. Plus, they probably think the only reason Negan was so successful in intimidating Hilltop is because they're not really fighters, and have nothing in the way of ammo to fight back with.
 
Why are people assuming Rick and company are all just going to ride into Negan's camp, whooping and hollering and firing off their guns like something out of Blazing Saddles? We've already seen that they're smart and capable enough to recon places and make tactical plans, so why not this time? There are four episodes left. Plenty of time to gather intel.

Obviously it's going to go tits up regardless, but that doesn't mean they'll just go running into battle without figuring out who they're dealing with first. They're overconfident, sure, likely after they hit the high score on Left4Dead in the mid-season premiere, but also Daryl has them convinced (somehow) that Negan's numbers are exaggerated. Plus, they probably think the only reason Negan was so successful in intimidating Hilltop is because they're not really fighters, and have nothing in the way of ammo to fight back with.
It feels like the objections are like wishful thinking, like just worrying ourselves to death over the possibility of losing a main cast member will keep it from happening.
 
Why are people assuming Rick and company are all just going to ride into Negan's camp, whooping and hollering and firing off their guns like something out of Blazing Saddles?
Because they've all but directly said that's precisely what they're planning to do. Zero fucks were being given by Rick, doubly so when he stated he was going in to get the guy.
 
True, but sometimes that sort of speech is just made for the drama. Then we see the characters doing something only partially related to the speech (and sometimes smarter).

On the other hand, it's certainly possible that Rick really will ride straight in and get a lot of people killed.
 
I'm not disagreeing with you, as I'm sure his intent was to go in stealthy and do some recon to try and rescue the guy. But that's definitely not what the stated plan was, which is why people are assuming otherwise.
 
I heard that about the Vatos...but I was hoping that the leader made it out...and possible meet up with the Fear group. Speaking of Fear...do we do a separate thread for it?

Regarding the Vatos, in the season 2 opener--"What Lies Ahead"--the heroes discover the entire Vatos community executed, but it was cut, so its not canon in-series. In other words, they should be considered among the living until the shows says something else.

True, but sometimes that sort of speech is just made for the drama. Then we see the characters doing something only partially related to the speech (and sometimes smarter).

On the other hand, it's certainly possible that Rick really will ride straight in and get a lot of people killed.

...and I have a feeling it will not be limited to the "big, single comic event," but other important characters, too.
 
The plan: seemed doomed to fail--how did they fail to think Negan's crew would scout the surrounding area or watch? Did they learn nothing from the Terminus patrols, who knew they were coming?

Several characters being unsure about the plan screams "disaster - dead ahead." The photos of crushed heads should have been the biggest tip off of all, but this group is a little slow.

Carol: So, as I've always thought, Carol is not the heartless monster some WD fans believe her to be, as she keeps a list of the humans she's killed, left a cookie at Sam's grave and she's trying to live a different life. She's still the most layered character in series history.

Carol smoking seems like a psychological crutch--like the beginning of some sort of negative step to a down slide, in the face of her trying to change.

Oh, and I guess the "Caryl" shipper's universe just crumbled. So, Daryl's ready for....

Abraham:
his rough break-up was an asshole move. Rosita was shattered with his "you're not" (the last woman on earth) line.

I feel someone will die--not for any sort of "balance," but to add insult to injury.

Sasha: she's a killing machine, yet she repeatedly stabbed the torso of the Savior, instead of going for the head, which would have prevented his pulling the fire alarm.

Gabriel: Very interesting turn. I hope he's only placing the enemies in the context of scriptural references, and does not turn that on the heroes.

Morgan: Somehow, many seem to think his peacenik stand will lead him to be an example at the hands of Negan, but I think he would need to see the next wave of brutality himself, before he modifies Eastman's philosophy.

Is he building a jail cell? Will he try to lock Rick up?

...aaand we have more kidnapped members.
 
And one of them is Carol, who is obviously not the super woman us fans of hers think she is. Oh, well, maybe now she won't get ragged on quite so much.

This attack wasn't a failure. They achieved the main objective and caused severe attrition to the enemy's side. They experienced a setback, but no military action goes perfectly.

The episode itself was done well.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top