• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers The Ships of Lower Decks

Rick Sternbach has stated that the Intrepid class has Type 10 phaser arrays – the same as the Galaxy class. One might therefore reasonably imagine that shot for shot Voyager could match the Enterprise-D for firepower – the Enterprise-D was just capable of more shots simultaneously though having much larger arrays.
It almost looks like the number of arrays are irrelevant in the case of this new ship, as we saw multiple simultaneous beams emitting from the same strip along the length of the primary hull. Can't remember if either the E-D or E-E could do that. The advantage comes from the actual power the ship can generate and send out through the strip. Arguably, the Galaxy and Sovereign classes, having larger warp cores, should be able to put out a lot more energy than smaller ships, but then we've seen how "overpowered" smaller ships like the Defiant could bring the larger Lakota to its knees in combat. The experimental nature of this ship (curiously, why doesn't it have an "NX" designation if it's supposed to be experimental?), it having two warp cores and the extra unidentifiable "thing" in the engineering section, could conceivably be one of the most powerful ships in the fleet - certainly the fastest. Kind of weird they would have sent it out to hide on some distant rock somewhere. Definitely a lot of mysteries being set up with the Protostar alone.
 
Then again, that's not mentioned on screen. And while the E-D makes big craters on the side of a Borg Strategic Cube, the Voyager barely dents a mere Tactical Cube...

In addition to the previously mentioned armor, the Borg have had time to adapt to that style of attack, so identical weapons from Voyager should have less damage years later.
 
It almost looks like the number of arrays are irrelevant in the case of this new ship, as we saw multiple simultaneous beams emitting from the same strip along the length of the primary hull. Can't remember if either the E-D or E-E could do that. The advantage comes from the actual power the ship can generate and send out through the strip. Arguably, the Galaxy and Sovereign classes, having larger warp cores, should be able to put out a lot more energy than smaller ships, but then we've seen how "overpowered" smaller ships like the Defiant could bring the larger Lakota to its knees in combat. The experimental nature of this ship (curiously, why doesn't it have an "NX" designation if it's supposed to be experimental?), it having two warp cores and the extra unidentifiable "thing" in the engineering section, could conceivably be one of the most powerful ships in the fleet - certainly the fastest. Kind of weird they would have sent it out to hide on some distant rock somewhere. Definitely a lot of mysteries being set up with the Protostar alone.
Every Phaser Array Element has a maximum energy output limit, ergo the need for multiple elements.

This not only provides wider firing arcs, but provides many emitters to fire out of simultaneously.

And with advanced Energy Capacitors / Batteries, who knows how much energy you could have stored before battle to power each individual element within the array.
The Defiant seemed to consume their Power Cells relatively fast. But given how powerful the bolts they were firing, I'm not surprised that they wore out the Power Cells so easily and it needed to be replaced.

The Series 5 long-range tactical armor unit had a "Condensed Energy Matrix" which which alone could power a fleet of StarShips.

Imagine a hybrid Capacitor/Battery that gave out enough energy to make a small meter long torpedo go to warp, have shields, sensors, tractor beams, and energy weapons.

That's insane how much energy you could cram into that unit.

And I'm sure Voyager scanned the Druoda "War Head" and knows the structural makeup of every part of that projectile.

The most valuable part IMO being the incredible small portable power source that is the "Condensed Energy Matrix".

That much power, that fits in the size of a meter long tube that can be carried by two crew members is game changing.
 
Well, it's way smaller. Give it one of those craters we saw in "Q Who?" and it's essentially gone. :vulcan:

Timo Saloniemi

Again, if you're going strictly by what's shown on screen then there's no indication a Tactical Cube is smaller than a regular Cube. The CGI model was literally the standard Cube CGI model already built for Voyager with the "flak jacket" surface detailing and plating added (and only on three sides no less, to save rendering time and memory, since no more than three sides would be visible at once).

And even if it were smaller, it's armoured. A regular Borg cube looks like it barely has a hull, never mind armour. Making it more resistant to damage is rather the point.
 
The experimental nature of this ship (curiously, why doesn't it have an "NX" designation if it's supposed to be experimental?)

The Protostar does have an NX designation – NX-76884.

FDKP2OeVkAE_E3W
 
And even if it were smaller, it's armoured. A regular Borg cube looks like it barely has a hull, never mind armour. Making it more resistant to damage is rather the point.
This is why I think the "Tactical" versions of all Borg ships should take over as the primary designs if we're going to update the Borg for the future.

That Extra Armor is worth it IMO to standardize across all Borg Designs.

For a Cybernetic Hive-mind that is stated to adapt, their ship designs haven't changed core fundamental designs outside of shape.

They should've learned ALOT more from fighting and losing against StarFleet and Species 8472.

Just relying on the same ole designs with slightly different Geometric Shapes won't cut it IMO.

That's not learning & evolving.
 
Nothing in the episode establishes the flat sheet cladding as "armor". It's done just for the impression, but never explicated. For all we know, Cubes that don't have a protective layer of greeblies atop their flat panels are the most fragile of the lot.

...After all, we now have plenty of reason to think that at least some Borg ships are "grown" from assimilated seeds, and what we see in "Unimatrix Zero" could well represent a youngling that hasn't yet accrued the full set of add-ons!

The "U0" Cube is at a dramatic disadvantage here because it needs to be shown in a fight with the Delta Flyer, meaning the auxiliary has to look fairly large in comparison to the Cube in order to be discernible to begin with. No way the Tactical Cube could be multiple kilometers on the side, then, even if some of the later close-ups from the fight with the hero ship might technically allow for that. "Best of Both Worlds II" does slightly better in showing the action with the shuttlecraft, only revealing the whole Cube when we can plead perspective issues...

Timo Saloniemi
 
I suspect that nobody would want to play it then. It would crack in half if it collided with an asteroid.
 
STO's Version of the California Class. Has some added detail to fit STO's more 'realistic' style, but still keeps the basics.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
I wonder if we can swap the department-color stripes between yellow, red and blue? That would get me interested. #spacebarbie
 
STO's Version of the California Class. Has some added detail to fit STO's more 'realistic' style, but still keeps the basics.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

That's nice.

Between this, the Parliament-class, and the Obena-class, Lower Decks has the best collection of new ship designs of any Star Trek series ever.
 
Yeah. I'd have a few of the Eaglemoss ships if they weren't so small and expensive.

I don't mind paying for small models if they're well crafted and detailed, as fortunately many of the Trek ones are. Some of the other Eaglemoss model lines (cough, Doctor Who, cough) look like they've been modelled in Play-Doh and then fingerpainted :vulcan:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top