The Official STAR TREK Grading & Discussion Thread [SPOILERS]

Discussion in 'Star Trek Movies: Kelvin Universe' started by Agent Richard07, Apr 30, 2009.


Grade the movie...

  1. Excellent

    707 vote(s)
  2. Above Average

    213 vote(s)
  3. Average

    84 vote(s)
  4. Below Average

    46 vote(s)
  5. Poor

    77 vote(s)
  1. CorporalClegg

    CorporalClegg Admiral Admiral

    Aug 23, 2001
    Full of hot air.
    Though money says Vulcan will be resurrected with in this "franchise's" run.

    In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if it's the major driving-force of the next film.
  2. Ridcully

    Ridcully Commodore Commodore

    Aug 27, 2000
    Man that was worth the wait...could almost not wait today...been along time since any movie had me feel this way!!
    Great great great crew...and so many cool moments....
    Good introduction, I bet a few good stories are in store for us!
    Have not been so excited since Lord of the Rings!
  3. Brent

    Brent Admiral Admiral

    Apr 24, 2003

    Saw it this morning, seeing it again tonight. All I can say is, Finally.
  4. Gertch

    Gertch Admiral

    Jan 4, 2004
    Saw it during the lunch time showing today with some co-workers. About a dozen people in the theater.

    I voted Excellent.

    Yes, there are some things the big villain from the future could have done in his grief to actually fix the future. And yes it was too easy to have the villain be from the future in a mining ship that in the past almost outmatches anything else.

    I liked how they made use of character elements we're used to even though they didn't have to. They did a good job of showing this is an alternate timeline so they don't have to worry about canon going forward.

    I'm looking forward to more!!!
  5. CorporalClegg

    CorporalClegg Admiral Admiral

    Aug 23, 2001
    Full of hot air.
    One other thing: was anyone else put off by all the really contrived Kill/remove guy to insert character bits? It was even worse than "Caretaker" in this regard.

    I mean come on, yup the most incompetent communications officer in Starfleet gets assigned to the Flagship only to be quickly removed for a cadet. :rolleyes:
  6. Bob The Skutter

    Bob The Skutter Complete Arse Cleft Premium Member

    Jul 12, 2001
    Bob The Skutter
    I hope not. That's not to say I wouldn't see it, or pre-judge it, but Star Trek had the balls to do something big and change up the whole thing for once, and I wouldn't like to see a u-turn.
  7. Brent

    Brent Admiral Admiral

    Apr 24, 2003
    One thing I liked, Uhura saying an "alternate reality", it drives a stake in the ground that says yes, this is a new universe for sure. It works for me, our star trek still exists in an another reality, and now the audience is watching this new reality, we just aren't able to see the old one anymore, works for me.
  8. Mysterion

    Mysterion Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Jun 28, 2001
    SB-31, Daran V
    Well, that was better than I had expected it to be.

    A lot of fun. Note to Berman and Braga: THIS is what a "valentine to the fans" looks like, okay? On the one hand it is a reboot opening the world of ST up to all sorts of possibilities for years to come. On the other hand, I think it is also a nice homage to the TOS we all know and love. Somehwere in a basement in New Jersey, James Dixon is finally having the massive brain cramp that ends his life, I suspect.

    Bruce Greenwood rocks as Captain Pike. I very much hope we've not seen the last of him in any future movies. Also, did you notice his admiral's uniform in the promotion scene? Very similar to the uniform worn by Shatner as Admiral Kirk in the early part of ST:TMP.

    Urban's McCoy is eerily similar to Deforrest Kelly without it being a hokey imitation. Simon Pegg's Scotty is a lot of fun. Wonder who the little guy following him around is, why he's there, and where he came from.

    Quinto is a fantastic Spock in this movie, and so is Nimoy. I like Chris Pine's Kirk a lot more than i thought I would from what I had seen in the trailers.

    The Enterprise looks pretty good here in motion. the stills released earlier this year didn't do it justice. My only quible is the engine room sets which just don't fit the look of the rest of the sets we see, and also doesn't really look like it should fit inside the ship we see from the outside.

    It will be very interesting to see where future iterations of Trek go from here.

    I will probably go see this again before the weekend is over.
  9. flcat

    flcat Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Jan 9, 2003
    South Florida
    I can understand why some fans of the old show might be upset by the changes. It's like somebody rewriting Harper Lee's "To Kill A Mockingbird" to make it more "accessible" to modern readers. I had similar beefs with Battlestar Galactica. If you're going to make it something different from the original...why call it Battlestar Galactica if not for some kind of commercial tie-in?

    That said, I enjoyed the movie for what it was, a Star-Wars-esque summer action-romp. I thought everyone did a decent to good job with their characters, in particular Karl Urban as McCoy. I wasn't as overwhelmed by Pine as some here seem to be. To me, he seemed to be playing Brad Pitt playing Captain Kirk...but that's just my take. I think the movie will do well enough that we'll see at least a sequel or two.
  10. Gertch

    Gertch Admiral

    Jan 4, 2004
    Thanks for reminding me - I was very afraid I would only see Sylar from Quinto's performance. Not because of him really but from myself. I'm happy to report that he did such a wonderful job I totally bought him as Spock.

    I agree about Nimoy. It was great to see him and as always his performance was well done.

    I can't wait til the next film, The Search For Vulcan. ;) :lol:
  11. Michael

    Michael Le modérateur de fanart Moderator

    Jul 10, 2007
    Aloha Quadrant
    If I'm not mistaken, the guy sitting next to Admirals Komack (whose name is very likely a reference to an admiral with the same name from TOS) and Barnett in Kirk's hearing after he cheated on the Kobayashi Maru test was named Chandra. That could be a reference to Captain Chandra from TOS' Court Martial.
  12. shipfisher

    shipfisher Commander Red Shirt

    Sep 10, 2006
    The first viewing will have some of a "getting adjusted" factor for a lot of us old guard fans. Go back, relax and take it in again.

    I enjoyed it the first time, but even more the second. Any aesthetic issues I had faded, even if I felt a tad more "at home" in the opening Kelvin sequence.
  13. Eddie Roth

    Eddie Roth Commodore Commodore

    May 16, 2001
    With McCoy becoming chief medical officer, I thought so. With Uhura, no. There was a clear narrative motivation for her taking over. Also, Pike didn't promote her on the spot, he said "relieve Lieutenat so-and-so" because in this situation she was of more value on the bridge. And she stayed on duty during the crisis because she was needed. When Kirk takes command, he promotes her, that's the way I saw it.
  14. Trippy

    Trippy NaNoWriMo Victim Admiral

    Jan 4, 2005
    I have avoided this forum like the plague until I could see the film. I just got back. I have one thing to say right now:

    Fucking fantastic!
  15. Alex1939

    Alex1939 Captain Captain

    Dec 11, 2008
    The Good, the Bad, the Ugly.

    First impressions (2 hours post viewing movie):

    The Good-

    The special effects. Easily the best space scenes in Star Trek's history. The battle's looked great. The planet attacks look great. Excellent job with a few minor exceptions. I actually loved after the movie was over, the modern take on the original music, with excellent planet/space/sci-fi scenes. Really cool.

    Chris Pine, I really enjoyed watching him as Kirk. I was most skeptical about this performance regarding the movie, but overall I was pleased.

    The Bad-

    The Snow Alien scenes were lame. They did not look convincing and they looked dated.

    The time-travel plot was good, in the sense it allowed Nimoy to pass the torch to JJ. But if you think about it, and the "it's an alternate reality" scenes, bleh. It's better to enjoy this movie on pace, and not think deeply about one of the main plotlines, and the fact it erases everything in Star Trek post-Enterprise, and my dvd's have now vanished from my home.

    Nero. He was ok. There should've been more screen time devoted to him. His ear/scar should've been explained in the movie. His ending wasn't epic enough, in my eyes.

    Scotty's pet friend, I was very worried it was going to turn into a horrible Jar-Jar situation. At least it didn't get ugly like that. But it was pretty dumb, imo. I was disappointed in his character which surprised me.

    The Ugly-

    McCoy, I liked Urban ok. But when I think of ToS, I think Kirk, Spock, AND McCoy. In this re-imagining it's Kirk and Spock. McCoy is more on the level of the rest of the main crew. The scene with Nimoy and Quinto, near the end of the movie, didn't really work for me. I kept thinking, if McCoy were also in the scene, Old-Spock and McCoy could have a cool exchange. Did they even have a scene together?

    Product placement, the Nokia add was horendous. That shit doesn't belong in Trek.


    I enjoyed the 2 hours I was watching the movie. Do I think it will stand up as well as some of the classics? No. It might rank 4th or 5th best star trek movie for my personal tastes.

    I liked new Kirk, Spock, Sulu, Chekhov, and Uhura. Checkhov I thought was great, but I had very low expectations. As stated before, McCoy and Scotty I was somewhat disappointed with.

    But I want to see it again, and already have plans to see it again with a relative... so on that basis, it's a success. I think this movie will help keep Star Trek around, and that's a plus.
  16. DarthPipes

    DarthPipes Vice Admiral Admiral

    Mar 3, 2006
    Founding Father of New Vulcan I guess.
  17. Hermiod

    Hermiod Admiral Admiral

    Mar 16, 2006
    ^Sums it up nicely. An Excellent from me.
  18. pookha

    pookha Admiral Admiral

    Dec 26, 2002
    seeing a lot of old familar faces around here..

    i guess this is one of the great agree to disagree.
    to me nothing is wiped out.
    both realities will co exist.
    they are not dropping all the books for instance based on classic trek for instance.

    after thinking some stuff over one quibble is i might would have liked for the monster kirk stuff to either be shorter or go away and have a little more in there like..
    more abot kirks recent back ground..
    more of the background stuff from countdown.
  19. CorporalClegg

    CorporalClegg Admiral Admiral

    Aug 23, 2001
    Full of hot air.
    I should clarify. What I really meant is Vulcan's resurrection will be the focus--whether or not they succeed will ultimately be up to the suits.

    In fact that'd actually be my wet dream: for this group to do some good old fashioned high concept Star Trek revolved around them trying to restore Vulcan and failing.

    And I'd debate anyone who says high concept can't be successful in this day and age. Because, at least compared to today's standards, TDK was fairly high concept--certainly as much as any Trek episode.

    I'm not asking for anything along TMP's lines. As much as I'd like it, I know it's just not a possibility, but I do think Orci and Kurtzman have a good intelligent script in them, one that can still maintain the charm and fun of this movie.
  20. The Boy Who Cried Worf

    The Boy Who Cried Worf Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Jul 12, 2008

    Well I'm not saying I won't watch it 8 or 9 more times in my life, I'm just saying I didn't like it so much.:techman: