The most disliked episode of the franchise - Final Showdown

[DevilEyes]

^ I feel the same way about Up the Long Ladder...

 

[Orac]

Code of Honor - 2
The Fight - 0
Spirit Folk - 0

1 for Code of Honor because the other two episodes are worse.

 

[Tiberius]

Code of Honor - 3
The Fight - 0
Spirit Folk - 0

1 for Code of Honor because the other two episodes are worse.

 

[Seven of Five]

Code of Honor - 4
The Fight - 0
Spirit Folk - 0

Saving Code of Honor, simply for the music. By now though we're comparing different grades of crap with each other. They're all bad.

The Fight - 0
Spirit Folk - 1

My final vote goes to the evil Spirit Folk episode. I hate it so much. Hokey Irish village? Check. Stupid jokes? Check. Holodeck cliches? Check. Stupid attachment to the holodeck that jeopardises the ship? Check.

 

[Admiral Shran]

The Fight - 0
Spirit Folk - 2

Spirit Folk - at least it didn't put me to sleep, literally.

 

[Seven of Five]

Sorry I did it wrong. I meant to vote for The Fight, as I want Spirit Folk to lose. It should read:

The Fight - 1
Spirit Folk - 1

I'm sorry the loss of my freezer has been very traumatic for me!

 

[tighr]

The Fight - 2
Spirit Folk - 1

I'll also vote for The Fight. Even though it was a waste of Boothby, there was at least the attempt at having aliens in this episode. Spirit Folk essentially created stupid Moriartys.

 

[Mr Silver]

The Fight - 2
Spirit Folk - 2

That should even things up!

 

[Seven of Five]

They're both terrible episodes so I don't mind who wins really. Just as long as people who voted for the opposition aren't forced to do a day-long marathon of all of the most disliked episodes.

 

[DevilEyes]

The Fight - 3
Spirit Folk - 2

Voting for The Fight, because Jimmy Bob once said in his review that it's a special experience if you watch it while high. I gotta try that sometime.

Also,

My final vote goes to the evil Spirit Folk episode. I hate it so much. Hokey Irish village? Check. Stupid jokes? Check. Holodeck cliches? Check. Stupid attachment to the holodeck that jeopardises the ship? Check.

What he said.

 

[Mr Silver]

The Fight - 3
Spirit Folk - 3

I'm going to even it up again.

 

[Orac]

The Fight - 3
Spirit Folk - 3

1 for Spirit Folk because I'zws0ipoim6y../;. hvj054 95674b

ETA Correction: The Fight loses.

The Fight - 0

 

[Mr Silver]

At least one of the two most unwatchable episodes is voted the most disliked of the franchise (the other being "Shades of Gray").

 

[BlueStuff]

They're both terrible episodes so I don't mind who wins really. Just as long as people who voted for the opposition aren't forced to do a day-long marathon of all of the most disliked episodes.

While that's a fantastic idea, I think it will be more beneficial to our sanity if we simply all took a collective vow never to watch The Fight again!


Game's over, guys. I don't have another, I'm afraid. Still, I'd like to thank each and every one who took part in this and also The least disliked. An unpredictable, often controversial game which I think only adds to the fun. Maybe I'll make it a yearly thing? The results are bound to be different every time.

 

[Seven of Five]

Oh my it's over. Aside from one or two questionable TOS and ENT episodes, there was a whole bunch of episodes there that were all deserving of their final resting place in this thread. Whether Shades of Gray ended up in the bottom two or not is all semantics - they were all terrible.

Thanks for the interesting contest BlueStuff. Lots of fun, somewhat contentious, like most stuff around here seems to be. We need some sort of ultimate episode showdown, with cannons and lasers and stuff! I'll wait patiently whilst you get it all ready.

 

[Mr Silver]

How about the most liked of the movies? Instead of 4 for an elimination - make it 10, as in 10 movies. And to make it even harder you can only vote once per round.

 

[tighr]

How about the most liked of the movies? Instead of 4 for an elimination - make it 10, as in 10 movies. And to make it even harder you can only vote once per round.

It would take less time if you just started off without any of the odd numbered movies!

 

[BlueStuff]

While cannons and lasers may be somewhat above my capabilities, bringing the movies into it is a fantastic idea! If a few more regulars can comment on this idea and agree on the rules (I agree we'd have to go straight from the points phase as there are too few movies for straight up eliminating to work) then expect that to be up in the Star Trek Movies I-X board sometime tomorrow.

 

[Seven of Five]

Sounds like a fine backup plan.

Just one laser?

 

[BlueStuff]

And I've just realized that after the movies, I can do the most/least disliked character etc (featuring regular characters only of course).

Looks like there'll be no shortage of fun for a while yet, guys!