The Most Disliked Episode of DISCO, Finals - 2025 Edition...
- Thread starter Farscape One
- Start date
48 hours have passed, so "Mirrors" times out.
New round.
DISCO truly is the most difficult show for me to make a vote for... so much of it was terrible.
I am still not ready to vote for a season 1 or 2 episode yet, so I am forced to vote for "Life, Itself".
At least it was a better finale than ENT. Extremely low bar to clear, but that's all I can say for it.
"Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue - 0
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 0
"Life, Itself" - 1
New round.
DISCO truly is the most difficult show for me to make a vote for... so much of it was terrible.
I am still not ready to vote for a season 1 or 2 episode yet, so I am forced to vote for "Life, Itself".
At least it was a better finale than ENT. Extremely low bar to clear, but that's all I can say for it.
"Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue - 0
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 0
"Life, Itself" - 1
Vaulting Ambition again.
Vaulting Ambition" - 1
"What's Past is Prologue - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 0
"Life, Itself" - 2
Vaulting Ambition" - 1
"What's Past is Prologue - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 0
"Life, Itself" - 2
I really enjoyed Life Itself and I was really enjoying the flashforward epilogue until the calypso stuff which sours it a little. I cant in good conscience elect to save anything from the awful first season so that brings us to the great second season. I will save Light and Shadows again, we get great Spock, Pike and Georgiou moments and the funky mutated probe.
Vaulting Ambition" - 1
"What's Past is Prologue - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 1
"Life, Itself" - 2
Vaulting Ambition" - 1
"What's Past is Prologue - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 1
"Life, Itself" - 2
48 hours have passed. "Life, Itself" has timed out.
New round.
(There seems to be only 5 of us voting in the DISCO Finals... kind of a damning indictment on just how bad and unpopular this show is.)
Eek... down to only season 1 and 2 episodes left. I definitely can't vote for a season 2 one now... it's the second worst season in the entire franchise. So I'm left with either season 1 episode.
Voting "What's Past is Prologue". At least it ended the Mirror Universe arc of the season.
"Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue" - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 0
New round.
(There seems to be only 5 of us voting in the DISCO Finals... kind of a damning indictment on just how bad and unpopular this show is.)
Eek... down to only season 1 and 2 episodes left. I definitely can't vote for a season 2 one now... it's the second worst season in the entire franchise. So I'm left with either season 1 episode.
Voting "What's Past is Prologue". At least it ended the Mirror Universe arc of the season.
"Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue" - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 0
I'm voting for Light and Shadows this round.
I think the plot where Burnham visited Vulcan was better than the remaining other episodes.
Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue" - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 1
I think the plot where Burnham visited Vulcan was better than the remaining other episodes.
Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue" - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 1
Or maybe it's just a silly little game that's gone around so many times that nobody cares anymore.
It is a silly game that has gone around several times (and it's meant to be fun and a bit silly), yet you can find quite a few people participating in TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY, and ENT.
There just seems to be fewer and fewer people who bother with DISCO. (I just looked at the 2021 and 2023 Finals for DISCO, and it's only 7 or 8 people total both times, and that was while the show was still active. Now, only a year and a half after it ends, it's down to only 5 people. I have heard it mentioned before that DISCO will be forgotten by people more than the others before it... and this seems to lend credence to that idea.)
Sticking it out to the bitter end. Same vote as before.
"Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue" - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 2
"Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue" - 1
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 2
I really can't bring myself to vote for any of Discovery's mirror universe episodes. I really didn't like them. Of course, Discovery's first in Section 31 material was also horrible. So I guess my vote is going to "Light and Shadows.". It at least has some Spock*, even if it's crazy Spock.
Some Spock > Less Spock
It's math, people!
"Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue" - 2
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 3
* - Spock may be in "Perpetual Infinity," but I sure don't remember his role.
Some Spock > Less Spock
It's math, people!
"Vaulting Ambition" - 0
"What's Past is Prologue" - 2
"Perpetual Infinity" - 0
"Light and Shadows" - 3
* - Spock may be in "Perpetual Infinity," but I sure don't remember his role.
Similar threads
