Binged this over the past few days and even as a cranky TOS/TNG purist I've got to say it was pretty solid. The pilot and Memento Mori were both pretty terrific. 8 and 9 were the only duds to me because they both felt really derivative (of the old holodeck malfunction episodes and Alien, respectively). Definitely want to watch Quality of Mercy again, feels like one that would improve when I know what is going on.
Like the cast too, particular Pike and Chapel. Peck is growing on me as Spock. Unlike some of you I really liked the Kirk casting, he had the easygoing confidence of young Shatner without coming off like a fratboy (coughChrispinecough)
I do with every single character didn't have to have PTSD or that everyone in the ST universe wasn't somehow related to each other like it's Utah but I guess that's just TV these days. Definitely want to watch the rest of the show at this point. It just felt a lot more like classic Star Trek largely due to the episodic structure with a new adventure on a new planet each week.