• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 2x01 - "The Broken Circle"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    240
Interesting that in-series by the 24th century they all seemed happy enough to just say "Engage". Which makes the whole Seven thing in Pic 3.10 a bit odd. In the franchise, if you zone out it's really the two Captains Pike who made this a thing (Punch it/Hit it) with "Let's Fly" following on.
 
I was more lukewarm on the first season than most, I think. I thought it was solid, but nothing special.

This, though? I thought this was fantastic. Took all the quibbles I had about season 1 and dialled them back. Seen a few people say that the first episode was the weakest of the batch of 6 that people have seen? If that’s the case, I’m gonna have a hell of a time.

Peck as always, is remarkable. Just hitting it out of the park in every scene. It’s also easy to see where all the budget is going with these new shows, ‘cause this looks incredible.

Solid 8.
 
I like this series, I love the cast and the characters, but honestly, with every episode it seems to make something in TOS more jarring and/or implausible. Why? Why do violence to basic characters and story lines which have been foundational for decades, when there is so much new ground that could be covered?

I view it as a soft reboot, or an alternative universe, and find that greatly improves my enjoyment and appreciation of the show.
 
I view it as a soft reboot, or an alternative universe, and find that greatly improves my enjoyment and appreciation of the show.

I view it as the same universe and not to take canon seriously because the United Earth Probe Agency shows just how much the writers have always cared about canon.

ENTERPRISE is a bigger mess of Star Trek continuity than this ever was and I liked Enterprise just fine.
 
Good episode....a 7.

I don't like the flashy camera stuff like the flipping upside down when they jumped through the hatch in the floor. ( I mean.... Why?) A lot feels like too much.

Carol Kane I'm mixed on, I think Im going to like her but we can get her a lozenge or something?

But, I'm happy. I enjoyed it. Just don't fuck it up with Kirk.
 
You know you’ve got a pretty solid cast when your “leading man” is only in the first 5 minutes and the episode still goes hard. Just now realized when watching Ready Room and saw next weeks scene that Pike never came back. I kinda figured he’d be at the end going YOU DID WHAT?
 
They have to keep Pike away since Kirk is coming I think. They’re not supposed to officially meet until years later.
 
Carol Kane I'm mixed on, I think Im going to like her but we can get her a lozenge or something?
Yeah, I was thinking "that can't be her real voice." It was so jarring that I had to YouTube clips of her to make sure. It's definitely exaggerated and if that is a director's choice, it's a really bad one because that is one of the most annoying voices for a character I've heard in a very long time. An entire season of that? Yikes.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top