It very much depends on the film. So, I have no idea.
Star Trek Rotten Tomatoes Rating
- Thread starter Argus Skyhawk
- Start date
How did "Revenge Of The Sith" manage eighty percent - one line of dialogue by James Earl Jones?
[small]I thought that it was pretty good[/small]
How did "Revenge Of The Sith" manage eighty percent - one line of dialogue by James Earl Jones?
[small]I thought that it was pretty good[/small]
I think I could have forgiven a lot in those three movies, but I never forgave them for the stupefying, dull dialogue and Hayden Christensen. He made Mark Hamill look like Marlon Brando.
Rotten Tomatoes' Critical Consensus:
Sounds like my kind of Trek film.
I have such a TREK erection right now...oh wait did I type that out aloud
I'm reminded of the Seinfeld line,
"They won.......you watched."
Don't get TOO carried away.
Two worlds collide
Rival nations
It's a primitive clash
Venting years of frustrations
Bravely we hope
Against all hope
There is so much at stake
Seems our freedom's up
Against the ropes
Does the crowd understand?
Is it East versus West
Or man against man
Can any nation stand alone
Rival nations
It's a primitive clash
Venting years of frustrations
Bravely we hope
Against all hope
There is so much at stake
Seems our freedom's up
Against the ropes
Does the crowd understand?
Is it East versus West
Or man against man
Can any nation stand alone
It's true that Ebert is outside the demographic groups that the studio is most eager to court with this film. So am I. So are a great many long-time Star Trek fans, as well as most of the folks who have actually worked on the Franchise in the past. It's many of us who have to make the most effort in order to be openminded about this film.
Good review from LA Times:
http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/la-et-trek7-2009may07,0,7954153.story
http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/la-et-trek7-2009may07,0,7954153.story
Good the LA times is a big Newspaper this is a good sign
Thank god this movie isn't longer than four hours then!
i just love the ass-beating this film is giving the SW prequels in reviews
What a strange connection to make!
If you're still hung up on the PT, I'd say get over it - the rest of the world apparently has. The last one came out FOUR years ago now!
A
Amaris
Guest
I like the Prequel Trilogy. It's unfortunate that to do so means pretending Anakin Skywalker doesn't exist, but when I do that, I really like it!
Honestly:
In TPM we had "yippee!" and "whoops!".
In AOTC we had emo Anakin fighting his troubled teenage soul.
In ROTS we had "NOOOOOOO!"
Oh, and to grace them all: Jar Jar Binks. <kill>
In my mind, Darth Vader is still the kickass, soulless SOB he was in ANH (with elements of the good man deep down in ROTJ), and mediocre revisionism will not change that. So I pretend he doesn't exist. I absolutely loved Ewan McGregor's portrayal of Obi Wan. Brilliant. Loved Ian MacDirmid, loved Natalie Portman as Padme. Every incarnation of Anakin Skywalker, however, was atrocious. The whole point of the Prequels, and they screwed it up from start to finish!
Sorry...bit of a rant.
J.
Similar threads
- Sticky
- Poll
